Island Inn

Really Useful

2023-10

It is on an island, which is 2-3 hours away from the mainland and cars. You could only come over on a boat,which runs once per day. So you could not expect to have a Hilton. The rooms are clean and small. But it is cozy and very cultural specific for the island. We stayed at Pierce Cottage which gave us a little more room and privacy. There are dirt or pebble paths between the cottages and the main building. Nobody is here for luxury or comfort. We want to walk the trail and look at the ocean. It is a beautiful place with unique characteristics.

Sebastian Russell

2023-07

Stayed in a corner room w/ private bath and partial ocean view. It's a rustic inn with all the historic charm that comes with. Having said, our room was clean, comfortable and had everything we needed for an island stay. Dinner and breakfast in the dining room were both excellent! Dinner had many seafood plates as well as other options. Breakfast had several standard pancake/egg/etc. options along with a fruit, bread, etc. buffet. Staff at hotel was all lovely and very helpful. Can't beat the location right off the ferry entrance and lovely view off the porch. Would highly recommend for your stay on the island.

Owen Bradley

2023-07

Rooms were great, we stayed in one of the cottages and it was cozy despite it pouring constantly for our first day. They are all so amazing here and the dinners are incredible. Some of the best seafood I've ever had. Everyone who worked here that we talked to was super nice and accommodating. I would definitely recommend if you're coming to Monhegan

Jennifer Benech

2023-09

Our room says meadow view but our view is of the next cottage. The skylight is nice to have but you can't really see out of it. Pretty noisy location as well. The room is nice and quaint and romantic but the other things can take away from it. We chose it for the private bathroom. We'd probably come back but definitely choose a different room next time.

2600 Striper

2023-07

We were put into Pierce Cottage, at first glance the room was nice but sometimes you can't tell a book by it's cover!The pedestal sink is very loose and doesn't appear to be connected to the wall, I went to brush my teeth and the water had a disgusting brown tint to it, the bed could probably use a new mattress. The trash in the bathroom had not been emptied by the cleaning lady.Our view was of the back of the hotel and storage.I complained about the brown water and was told that's the way it is, the morning manager then went on to say island life isn't for everyone.Well she told me, I'm two or three times her age what do I know! I owned and operated two vacation rental property management companies for almost twenty years and if someone had these types of complaints we would gladly let them leave and apologize and probably refund them for their night since they were unhappy.The island was interesting and lots of nice views and the local shops were nice but staying here at the Island Inn really killed it for me.I wanted to leave based on the disgusting water and uncomfortable bed but they refused to return our money for the unused night.I would NOT recommend staying here.

Ann Nappa

2023-05

Our stay of 4 nights was excellent. The service, food and views from the porch were tremendous. We had dinner every night at the Inn and enjoyed a menu of deliciously composed meals that perfectly used the ingredients that make Maine so special. Breakfasts are included in cost of room and more than fortified one for a day of hiking. This was our first visit and we met so many people who return summer after summer. One couple had come the first time on their Honeymoon 55 years ago and they continue to come back. That is a better recommendation than anything I could say!

Tempy Keller

2023-09

INCONSIDERATE NOISE POLLUTION from their boat “Fortunate Island” moored in the harbor.Impossible to rest with the high-pitch, loud ringing coming from the Island Inn owners boat bilge pump alarm. I think it is completely rude to subject visitors and locals to this.We are aware that two separate boats moored in the harbor also went by the Inn to complain to reception, and they still didn’t do anything about it. The ringing can be heard from their $400 a night rooms as well as rentals along the shore. Fix it. This is absurd.

Brad Malt

2023-05

A beautiful old inn, perched on top of a hill overlooking the harbor. The food is very good. Note there is no liquor, so bring or buy your own wine for dinner, they’ll happily serve it for youBut make sure you want the charming inn experience, not the luxury hotel experience. This is the best on the island, but the rooms are cramped, the bathrooms are small, the beds are small, the pillows are junk, etc.All of the is okay for an inn. The reason I give it 3 stars, not more, is that it is impossible to sleep. Once I propped open my window with a wastebasket (since it won’t stay open by itself), there was almost enough cool evening air to make the temperature tolerable (there is no AC). But that means you hear the island partying noise at night, and then the light comes streaming in early in the morning (which it would anyway since the shades aren’t room darkening). And, if the wind picks up in the morning, the door will rattle, the windows will rattle and your room will basically sound like a drum.Totally unacceptable to me, I wouldn’t stay here again on a bet. I don’t think it’s too much to ask to have a room you can sleep in.

Janet Nelson

2023-05

My husband, Nick Papouchis, and I started coming to the Inn a decade ago or more; we stayed for a few days, then more. Now our sons, their wives and our two grandchildren come for a long week For all of us, it is perfect. The Inn, the food, the porch, the quiet, the views, the trails, Artists, Cathedral woods, The Brewery. Our grandchildren on two coasts are now preparing for the Jamboree! And to greet us, Jennifer Marr at the front desk. Warm, competent, and always patient.

Lee Janko

2022-05

This will be our 5th year at Island Inn. Actually stay in the Pierce Cottage overlooking the meadow and the lighthouse. We enjoy that porch and the main porch. Incredible. The staff are super friendly. We stay for a week and enjoy everything on the menu. The chefs are amazing. The menu is not pricy. You're in a 4-star restaurant on an island. It's all amazing.For the few negative reviews I noticed- really? Do us all a favor and stay on the mainland and enjoy your Holiday Inn.The Island keeps you busy. If you like to paint or sketch, you'll be in heaven. Great challenging well-marked trails and don't miss the brewery! Relax and enjoy. The island inn makes it easy.

Kent Bridges

2023-05

What an amazing, historical place to stay and dine. The staff is always friendly and accommodating and the food is so delicious! Everything from the Lobster Scrambled eggs to the Filet Mignon with Lobster Tail is mouth watering and well worth the trip for that alone. I couldn't ask for a better place to stay while exploring the Trails, looking for Faery houses and just reconnecting with the sound of the waves on the rocks. I highly reccommend this place. Don't forget to walk up to the brewery for some great beer!!

Chelsea Blais

2021-05

We had an amazing weekend. the employees at the inn are all so kind and helpful (especially Jennifer at the front desk) and the two waiters at the restaurant were awesome. Joshua and another gentleman waited on us for every meal we had and we saw them gracefully handle difficult customers and do an amazing job serving everyone their delicious food. The Halibut was the best and desserts were amazing. Breakfast was also great to have before hiking the island. FYI mask wearing is strictly enforced on the Island. Even so, it was well worth the trip and the Inn did the best they could during this time.

E

2021-05

This was our second visit, with a span of probably 10 years in between. Monhegan Island is a delight, and staying at the Island Inn just ties it all together. The rooms are what you would expect of an inn with so much history - perfect for us, although you might find them wanting if you are a 5 star hotel addict. Friendly staff manage the luggage and check in well, reminding us to wear masks and keep our distance, as it should be. The dinner was wonderful - we began with a risotto that would grace any table I have enjoyed in the last decade. Then baked haddock crusted with nuts, a favorite of mine. We ended with a blueberry dessert and one of dark chocolate, both lovely to behold and to eat. It's BYOB so no excuse for not having a decent bottle of wine! Breakfast the next morning is worth the trip with all kinds of great foods to tempt you and to send you out to the hiking trails. With wonderful views on all sides and total serenity in this beautiful spot, I can only say we will return, and sooner than 10 years.

Alessia Testa

2023-05

I had dinner both at the Island Inn and at Monhegan House. My experience at the Inn was, by far, much, much better than at Monhegan House. This is not to discredit the food at Monhegan House: their food is good quality, though they try to offer Italian dishes (which I tried): in my opinion, they should stick to what they know best, which is North-American style fish. At the Inn we had salad, muscles, swordfish and halibut. They were all excellent, both the quality of the fish and the dish preparation. Our waiter was really good as well. I highly recommend.

Todd Lizotte

2019-05

This place was unique. We had lunch here and I was surprised how much cares was taken in food preparation. Yes they have some standards for kids, but they have some items that were just seriously delicious. The clam chowder was amazing. Cream based but not thick, the right blend or broth. The seasoning was obviously fresh to order and the veg and clams cooked perfect. I also had the fish tacos, the creme fresh dressing was perfect, not over powering or bland, delicious and fresh. My son had the club sandwich, he said it was great as well. The inn was well kept with art work and comfort. They do a great job here to keep a Maine island feel. Stay a night or two and hike the island, you won't regret it.

Alex Iannicelli

2019-05

We went to the island inn for lunch and the food was very good. I had the fish tacos and loved it. The dining room atmosphere was quiet and nice and it was not that crowded. Our waitress was very nice and attentive to our needs. They have a good amount of variety in the menu including vegetarian options and stuff that kids will like as well.

kaela portero

2023-11

…More

Bruce Caisse

2018-05

We stayed here in September and it was delightful. This whole village is like being in an Andrew Wyeth painting! The Island Inn is classic Maine in every way. The hospitality was warm and the food was delicious. We rented a room on the third floor in September and didn't see many folks up there so it was pretty private. Cannot wait to go back!

Arlene Lagos

2016-05

I got married here 11 yrs ago and yesterday we renewed our vows here at the same spot overlooking the water, followed by a delicious meal with friends! Our server Raddick was courteous and professional. The rooms are clean and comfortable, the dining room was exceptionally decorated with beautiful paintings, and the food was delicious! We love it here and recommend it highly!

Greg Kobylarz

2020-05

…More

Patricia Riley Odone

2021-05

2 years ago was my first time on the Island and I fell in love with it. My then boyfriend had booked the private suite with balcony and private bathroom as a surprise...it was a wonderful visit. Fast forward 2 years and we decided to go back for the first couple days of our Honeymoon. Sadly, our experience was a stark contrast.When booking our room unfortunately the private suite wasn't available. I told the woman we were coming on our Honeymoon and I'd like the best room they had available. She assured me we had booked a great room, just as nice as the suite but without the balcony and a view of the village. In fact, while it was probably "the best room available the day I called" it was nowhere near as nice other than having its own bathroom. It was tiny. So tiny we tried to avoid being in it because the only option other than standing beside the bed was to be laying on it...we couldn't just relax in our room. It was a corner room and the "view of the village" was obstructed by a fire escape/balcony and the other window looked at the staff housing.We thought we might get at least a "congratulations on your wedding, or thank you for choosing us for your honeymoon or even a little note in the room or recognition at check in...but absolutely nothing. As a matter of fact we even mentioned it to 2 different wait staff in conversation at dinner and then breakfast with absolutely no response...it was so disappointing. Even when checking in and mentioning it...nothing...no response what so ever and yes, she heard us.We decided to get out for a walk and see what was open knowing covid changing a lot of the norms.What we experienced immediately was the attempt to "shame us" if we didn't have our masks on 24/7. Don't misunderstand, we know and believe in the safety of masks and whenever we saw people, even from a distance, we would pull up our masks but it was evident they wanted the masks on ALL the time. (Even the CDC says masks are not needed outside unless you can not social distance...that was never the case.) There were sandwich boards every 20 feet it seemed saying you must wear it at ALL times.If we had know that we never would have come...period.We felt like the locals were stuck between wanting us there because of the money guests bring to the island and really...not wanting us there at all. There were a few places we visited that were the exception...the brewery and the little grocery store, both of which were very friendly and seems grateful to those who still chose to come.It left such a sour taste in our mouth I'm not sure we'll return covid or no covid. Thank god the hiking views are spectacular and it was beautiful while we were there...it was our only saving grace.

Meg Horne

2023-11

…More

chucho chucho

2022-05

We had a mixed experience at the Island Inn. Like the rest of Monhegan, the Island Inn gives alternating vibes of being really friendly and also just wishing tourists would leave them alone.The pros: amazing water views, great food at the restaurant, and many staff who were extremely helpful and pleasant.The cons: the rooms are not heated (so beware if it’s a cold day— we slept in fleece jackets because our room was CHILLY), and sometimes the staff was less than hospitable. For example, the only lobby bathrooms are on the far side of the building and sometimes they lock the access and get a little huffy if you ask to use them. They also end breakfast on the early side and don’t really tell anybody so you might miss the window if you’re not an early riser. Also, dinner is byob but they close the B(arnacle shop that they own) at 5pm.Overall, a nice place to stay on Monhegan but we would not go back if the weather might be at all cold. But it definitely had the vibe the whole island does - give us your money, but god forbid you need to pee.

Aglaia Davis

2022-05

…More

Melanie Diehl

2017-05

Arriving on Monhegan Island by the Elizabeth Ann from Port Clyde was the beginning of two incredible days. Our luggage was delivered to our room on the 3rd floor, corner room, overlooking the wharf. A seaside view from our bed! The room was simple and cozy; nothing more was needed after a day of hiking the incredible trails and picnicking on the rocks near the crashing waves. The rockers and Adirondacks were the perfect place to kick back and watch the sail boats. Breakfast was fresh and satisfying. Cannot wait to return to this rugged and serene place.

Elizabeth Cram

2018-05

Rooms are light and airy (especially the queen room with deck facing the harbor). Service is outstanding. Local art always present. The island is a small and delicate ecosystem so always think conservation when you travel there, but go, tread lightly and relax.

Wyatt Bricca

2017-05

Very relaxed atmosphere. Definitely an early-to-bed crowd. The concierge staff was friendly and kind. Dinner at the restaurant was affordable and tasty. It's a great hotel with a lot of charm and character.

Clinton Conley

2022-05

Lovely island hospitality, nothing fancy, perfectly charming. Classic porch with rockers overlooking harbor tableau.Early risers/caffeine fiends beware: no coffee until 7am. Not right!

Will

2020-05

If you want to spend the night on Monhegan, this is THE place to stay. Staying here is like living in a postcard from a bygone era. The dinner was great, and the view from the porch is legendary. The rooms were nice and the shared bathrooms should not be a deterrent.

Jeffrey Potter

2018-05

Beautiful and charming old inn. It was as if I had stepped a hundred years back into a well kept piece of history! I loved my meal there as I waited for the ferry to bring me back to reality. Don't miss visiting here when you go to Monhegan Island.