4.5 (59)
206 Townsend Ave, Boothbay Harbor, ME 04538
(207) 380-7377
facebook.com
Service options
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Tom Cotter
2023-09
I love Gifford’s ice cream, and Camp Coffee is the best I have tasted! The staff at Sarah’s is very friendly, courteous and efficient. It’s the perfect combination and the best ice cream in the Harbor.
Michael Jahn
2023-08
The ice cream is fine, it’s Gifford a which is always quality, but the service was abysmal. They took almost 15 minutes to do 3 orders and got almost all of them wrong. I can’t recommend.
Jane Gilbert
2023-08
Great little Ice Cream Shop. The girls were super patient and answered all of my questions as I rolled through pretty much every flavor before deciding on my selection. Great service and location.
Bette Luksha-Gammell
2021-05
2020 updateNow sundaes are one size . Our 1st visit my husband's was 3 scoops of ice cream. I mentioned that was to much for me, and they were nice and offered a smaller one at the old prices.Our last 3 visits we've received different size cups each time. Last night we again ordered his & a small for me. We both received one scoop of ice cream in a small cup. He is very disappointed. When he mentioned it, he was told this was the correct size. Being weekly regulars, this may have been our last visit. One size does not fit all.Carries Gifford's ice cream !I love the Toasted Coconut.Open 12-10Outside tables under the shade.
Julie Hodgkins
2023-08
We love Sarah's scoops a bit pricey at 16 $ for two small cones but friendly staff and great treat on a hot day.
Douglas “Doug” Graham
2022-05
I had the brownie sundae with Muddy Boots ice cream ad it was fabulous! The rest of our party really enjoyed the Blueberry Sunday and the Chocolate Chip Mint Ice Cream. The portions are large and the prices reasonable, too.
Vincent Guerrieri
2019-05
It is just an ice cream stand on the side of the road, but it serves Giffords ice cream, a premium brand that long ago left my home area. It has cups and cones in several sizes as well as confections like milk shakes, frappe, sundaes, etc. There are picnic tables lining the parking lot. We were in Boothbay for three days and went to Sarah 's twice.
Jenna Locke
2020-05
Great customer service but for the amount of icecream, to me it's the most expensive icecream facility here in town out of all the icecream places we have along with minimal choice selection. But they do have good icecream and some very nice flavors. Just not a place if go often bc of the very high prices.
Phil Trivilino
2019-05
Great ice cream with a huge selection.
Sarah Hall
2022-05
I had smores and it was delicious. My husband loved the peppermint and his grandfather had coffee. Great ice cream, we will be back
Charise Melvin
2020-05
Young people seemed to be running it and didn't really know how and what to do and it of many advertised flavors Soft serve machine was broken?. One worker had to be guided to make a milkshake. Not impressed in a town like Boothbay Harbor.
Losee Rich
2023-06
Great roadside ME ice cream place with Gifford's Ice Cream!
Rosalie Wilson
2023-08
Delicious ice cream with lots of flavor options!
multisport10
2023-06
Gifford Ice-cream, very pricey! Find another place
Elijah Gudroe
2020-05
A great family friendly little ice cream shop you can grab very quality ice cream at! Giffords is some of the best you can get!!!
Philip Paisnel
2019-05
I made the mistake of asking for a large, I didn't expect half the ice cream tub in a bowl. This is a nice little spot to come to for ice cream with the price
Jeff Grady
2020-05
Nice shakes, always good service... not instant, think its cash only. Picnic tables . Good test, bathroom across the street
Carol Anthony
2023-05
Excellent ice cream. I had the Maine blueberry.
Luke Connors (Thales)
2021-05
Friendly, fast, and with a smile. Great service, even better ice cream.
Chester Liu
2017-05
Awesome roadside ice cream shop, has floats and other things too.
Bill Suffolk
2019-05
The best ice cream place on your way down into the harbor !
JenninOakland
2023-09
BEST ICE CREAM IN TOWN!!!! 😋
Katty Kauffman
2018-05
Fabulous flavors, generous portions, terrific staff. Thank you.
Jason Burke
2017-05
Huge portions! Friendly staff! Cash or check only is only reason I didn't rate 5 stars
B utcher
2019-05
Love this place the owner is awsome and has done an amazing job with the place since it has opened
Barbara Spaziano
2022-05
They're frozen yogurts are awesome.
Cathy Williams
2023-05
Excellent, loved the Southern Peach 🍑
Davis Foulger
2020-05
Good service. Good ice cream.
John Gove
2019-05
The service is the best there is around not to mention rhe product!!!!
Kaleb Schmittler
2023-05
Awsome palce to get ice cream
Pet Stores in the USA
Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.
Broswe by Population