Penchem Tack Store

Melanie Hatch

2021-05

Awesome store! Drove an hour and a half to check it out. We were not disappointed and we will be back. HUGE selection. The downstairs is all saddles. Some used tack, mostly new and mostly western. Lots of bits.

Larry Graham

2023-11

If you are a person who likes leather this is the place to visit! All kinds of leather products tack for your horses! The downstairs saddle room is amazing!Worth the visit!

Suzi Doer

2023-07

Martin, Circle Y, Billy Cook, Tucker, and others, new and used. Was there today to have some repair work done to bridles and saddles and they have probably 300 saddles new and used. They also carry 5 star pads and other quality name brands. Tons of bridles and cinches including mohair. Halters, saddle bags, pommel bags, too much to name. Worth the drive and the good prices. They also carry some Amish brands including Crooked Creek which we own a trail saddle and it is excellent. Johnny Pencham is the owner, Amish. This is a full retail store and has gifts items including leather purses and Amish made items. The chaps are around $250 and would be $400 or more online. Highly recommend Pencham’s. Worth the drive.

Sabrina Duke

2023-05

I absolutely loved this place. The young man who worked there was super helpful. They had so much to choose from, and from what I could tell, great prices. I will definitely go back, and I highly recommend this place if you're looking for tack for your horses.

Chloee Ward

2023-09

Nice I got my ponys halter from here and it is still clean and it looks good on her and they have English saddles and they are way too cheap and nice they have used bits and halters too and bare back pads wips strips purses hats saddle pads and lots of Western saddles and a delli near by

helen hurst

2023-12

Bought local honey and asked directions. Great hospitality and friendly service.

darrell dunlap

2023-05

Deceptively well stocked country store that specializes in fine leather goods from quality belts to excellent saddles. They also stock Red Wing Boots.Staff was a bit on the standoff but civil side but they warm up to you quickly.

Scott G

2023-05

Awesome tack store they sell some western wear lots of boots and leather goods and some the sharpest well made saddles and bridles you can find with good amish owner's...💯

dina dargo

2022-05

I have purchased 2 saddles and a great variety of other tack at this shop, and I can't say enough good things about them. Exceptional service, excellent quality, and very fair prices. highly recommended!

Cathy Oliver

2023-06

Well taken care of by very friendly employees.

Judy Gibbs

2018-05

A great place to purchase tack. They have a nice selection of saddles, bridles, halters, riding helmets, etc.. Quality leather items with a nice variety to choose from. Owner was very helpful and friendly.

Ellen Vaughter

2023-05

Great selection of saddles, tack, and supplies. Very high quality items.

Pamela

2022-05

Great place to get Myra handbags as well as your horse needs. Leather wallets and a few holsters. Lots of other things too!

G Perez

2021-05

Nice range of tack and saddles, plus boots. In house leather and saddle works is ideal for finding what you need. Plus employees are very helpful.

Jason Lawrence

2021-05

Best place around to buy red wing boots. I've bought several pairs for my son and myself. They are normally $30+ cheaper if you don't mind the drive just a few miles south of Elkton on 181. Or just north of Guthrie.

Robin Winans

2019-05

Amish owned tack store where everyone is helpful and courteous. Knowledgeable and skilled to repair a damaged saddle, or build a new custom one. They buy used tack to repair and resell as well as offer new tack.

Tracey Rozwalka

2024-03

They have everything you need

K T

2019-05

Very little help, the guys downstairs are seldom in. The store sure smells good though. It's expensive but the only place to get most of the stuff they sell especially harnesses.

Jaclyn Jones

2022-05

Great place.. they have hard to find hardware for cheap. Good selection of halters, fly masks and hay bags but a bit pricey.

Watkins Watkins

2023-05

Love the selection of saddles, farrier supplies and the location. Thanks for the good customer service.

nik pars

2022-05

They are wonderful people to deal with, they are knowledgeable about all of their products and equine. It is worth the trip up to purchase in person.

Jared Eaves

2019-05

Great prices, nice and helpful people, and a good selection of quality stuff. Really good selection of saddles too. We highly recommend this store.

Matthew Smith

2018-05

I nice little shop for equestrians and farmers. They have everything that a horse owner would need. It's worth a visit if you are in the area.

Robyn Sanford

2023-07

They make some great leather purses, wallets, belts, etc.

Brian “CowboyB” Felts

2023-11

Best place to buy tack!!

Beverly Wright

2018-05

Bought a new Circle Y endurance saddle and traded in my old Tucker. So happy!! Johnny is the BEST! !

Linda Hofslien

2022-05

Some beautiful saddles, a large array of western tack and leather goods. Very nice place.

James Schlabach

2023-05

Great selection of saddles, tack, accessories, etc !

Michael Westphal

2019-05

Always enjoy stopping here. It's a nice small tack store that I have traded with for several years.

DE

2023-07

Great selection of excellent quality merchandise.