Casey's

Luchini Cream

2023-08

7.5/10I’m from Chicago and I’ve made pizza from scratch in all types of ways from traditional to new recipes from pizza store owners for 10 years of my life! So I’m considered a professional Pizzaiolo! Casey’s is almost right where it needs to be for those who crave a almost great tasting pizza! It’s not over priced and it’s worth every bite ! If you hate the flop go for well done or ask for extra crispy!

Angel W

2023-11

…More

Joey

2023-05

Love Casey's Pizza and was happy to be able to go here again. 3 stars because Pizza is still good but they stopped making custom subs and we consistently find expired milk. Never seen a store who consistently has expired milk.

John Flanagan

2023-05

I live in Ogden, and rather go to Manhattan or JC's Casey's. Nothing is ever made or ready. Pre orders just sit at counter. "We don't make it until you get here". Store items not consistently stocked. Workers arguing in front of customers, workers debating on who's going to sign in to check out a customer then make you feel like you're a inconvenience. And to those few workers that are awesome, try to be the change this store needs! Come on management!

Sam Trokey

2019-05

I called in a pizza order at 1010 to be picked up at 1135. I have a short lunch break so I always try and give as much notice as I can. I showed up at 1131 and figured I would have a few minutes to wait. My pizza wasn't even being made yet! I asked how long it would take the lady told me 8 minutes. 20 minutes later I had finally gotten my pizza but couldn't eat it because my lunch break was over before I could eat. If she had been honest and said 20 minutes I would have canceled my order and gotten something quick to eat. Very very frustrating. I will never order there again.

DOOD J

2021-05

Actually not a bad little rest stop. I'm not from here, just passing through and was happy to be able to swing through here before getting back on the road. The place was clean and well stocked, the folks inside were pleasant enough and the location turned out to be pretty convenient for me too, no complaints.

Josh L

2021-05

Ordered sandwiches one day. They where garbage. Had 4 onion pieces on a sandwich threw 75% of the spinach away off the sandwich because it was wilted.Ordered pizza the next day called it in early so we could have it done on our lunch break. Get there to pick it up. Hadn't even been in the oven yet.If you cant complete a service that you offer. Why lie.

robert belyea

2020-05

Ordered 2 pizzas came back 30 min later and still hadn't started it. Refunded me the money and said they would get in making it. Came back and they gave my order to someone else! Now I've been waiting 1 hour and they tell me they are starting again. I'll never get pizza here again!

Harley Gossman

2020-05

Don't do it!!! Wife and I always have problems with food we order. I am not one to degrade businesses, but it gets more ridiculous every time I decide to take a gamble and spend my hard earned money for some convenient food. Not gonna list all problems in past 4 years, just last night's . so they have a problem with not having ingredients, not reading order correctly, and not even starting the order within 30min. So last night ordered 2 philly cheese steak subs. Wife said" I'll order". I said "I don't know, seems complicated for caseys. Onions and peppers will probably be cold and raw" . we decided to take a chance. But me being skeptical I ordered a backup sandwich(which was not made when picked up order, 20 min wait). got home open subs, they were cold,Bread cold, onions raw, green peppers raw, meat cold. Not room temp, cold. Called caseys asked if philly cheese steak is supposed to be cold and raw, already knowing cheese should be melted. Onions , peppers somewhat grilled or oven cooked. He actually told me that the cook had put through the oven . I said " there is no way, everything was cold and bread was soft " . it was obvious, the subs had not seen the inside of an oven. He then preceded to lie to me and say" the cook put in the oven, then put in the cooler so they would be cool for us". I was speechless. I've never had a cold philly cheese steak in my entire 41 years on this planet. I asked if I could get a refund, since we didn't eat our subs, only unwrapped them. He said we were stuck with them. So!! Order at your own risk. I will NOT be eating caseys food in the future. And a quick note! I have ordered food plenty of times ,waited 30 -40 minutes. Well past when I was suppose to pick food up, and not even on their radar yet. One time they said they were out of stuff so they didn't make it. True story !!!

American Made

2020-05

Walked into the gas station after getting gas and then went to the bathroom. I got asked where I lived before I went to the bathroom and a guy making pizzas was in the middle of the store announcing and asking if I was “out of the bathroom yet”. Bizarre, intrusive and lacking in business operations. They refuse to give you a receipt for gas even after you pay and initiate that you want one...

Josh Biltoft

2021-05

Good prices, cheapest gas in the Manhattan area! Good pizza and sandwiches also. Their app and rewards program is very helpful and gives you tons of good deals.

Steven Thompson

2018-05

Within the past year I have called twice to order breakfast puzzas and was told both times that they were out if cheese for the breakfast puzzas. Today I call for the special of Taco Pizza and am told they are out of salsa. Asked if I could get a different type puzza for the special price, was told No, can't do that. You can't sell pizzas if you don't have the ingredients. Very disappointed when Casey's is supposed to be known for pizzas.

Tyler Anderson

2019-05

The lady taking my order hung up multiple times before I finished my order. I showed up my pizza hadn't even been made 25 minutes later. They were kind enough to give me a free cheese bread. But then when my pizza came out, it wasn't even the right order.

Christopher Snyder

2018-05

Alot of items for soft drinks are out of stock. Pizza had no time stamps in them to tell how fresh they were. Also didn't have the mark on them to tell what kind of pizza they were.

Brennan Walter

2021-05

Ordered online. Food wasn't ready when promised. Not all employees wear masks over nose and mouth. Otherwise I always get friendly service.

Thomas Maia

2018-05

Went in at 6:00 a.m. they had no breakfast ready. I asked the lady and she said it was only six. She had plenty of time to BS with her coworker but not enough time to cook. Place has been going down hill over the last year.

donkey brains

2018-05

The past couple times I've been here the sprite soft drink was carbonation only and I didn't realize until I left everything else is ay okay

Gerrad Bell

2021-05

Very friendly service and the pastries they serve are always fresh, definitely enjoy stopping here on my way to work in the morning

Tessa White

2019-05

Pizza is by far way better than Domino's and pizza hut !!for a gas station pretty impressive.

Timotby Booth

2021-05

Pizza is good service is great to okay depending who is working at the time

serrano serrano

2021-05

Love their customer service, pizza and bread sticks. My family love the homemade 🍕.

Rita Powers

2017-05

I really like their Pizza. It taste great, has plenty of ingredients and I never get heartburn.

Hersh Harrison

2021-05

Delicious pizza, cold drinks. Wish we had a Casey's in Manhattan

Lorie Underwood

2021-05

Best pizza even the husband who won't eat pizza liked the chicken bacon ranch.

Rob Shaffer

2021-05

Right next to post never had an issue parking is a pain but they are working with what they have. Prices are fair

Mikey H.

2021-05

I mean its a gas station they don't take covid precautions very seriously as people walk in without masks all the time.

Valerie Damato

2019-05

My aunt went the one of employees try to put her hair on fire. Not to happy about it happen the other day

D M

2021-05

The store is always clean and well stocked. Staff is friendly

Sean Galbraith

2021-05

friendly staff great prices and love the rewards app

Heather Price

2022-05

Great pizza and friendly service.