1886 Café

Realistic Reviews

2023-12

I really loved this place! They have that great small-town diner appeal and a terrific menu that offers some surprising twists on classic favorites. I highly recommend the chicken nachos, and from our groups experience, you can't go wrong with any of their burgers. The owners are really lovely people who operate the place themselves, which I love. They're located on Main St in Mayetta, KS, so if you're traveling up 75, make sure to pop over and check them out, as they're just off the highway.

Brenda Clark

2024-04

…More

Dezerie Stevens

2023-05

We were visiting from Colorado and wanted a breakfast place close to our hotel at Prarie Band, after searching on Google maps this quaint family owned restaurant popped up. I knew it was going to be good when they asked how I wanted my bacon cooked. This is truly a farm to table made from scratch yummy goodness restaurant. Hash browns were home made not frozen, dark yoked fresh eggs! I think the only think that was not farm fresh was the ketchup! Lol 5 out of 5 stars . We will definitely stop by each time we come out to Kansas.

Erin Dessain

2024-02

…More

Lorraine

2023-05

…More

Susan Rollins

2024-03

…More

Michael Wescott

2023-05

…More

Shane Ware

2023-12

…More

James Perkins

2024-03

…More

Angel Munday

2024-04

…More

Sheila Gray

2023-11

…More

Nina Núñez

2024-04

…More

Christy Lawson

2023-11

…More

Paula W

2023-12

…More

Barbara Hren

2024-05

…More

gemma collins

2023-05

…More

Maresa Goslin

2023-10

…More

Jon Mehler

2024-04

…More

Anna Olderbak

2023-06

We were cruising the area in search of wildlife and decided to take a break for lunch. We didn’t want a franchised place and opted for a mom and pop style restaurant when we saw this listed on google and decided to take a chance on 1886. The food was bomb and the people were nice. I will definitely tell people about this place.

Jane Johnson

2023-09

…More

Jeremy W.

2023-05

I ate here on a Tuesday around noon and I was the only one the restaurant. I got nervous wondering if I had wandered into a place I would regret. But my fears were almost immediately subdued! The staff was amazingly friendly and the coffee was well above average (great sign!). I had the burrito and the fried hasbrowns they both were probably one of the best I've ever had. If I'm ever near holton/Topeka area I will be stopping from now on.

Penny Jennings

2023-05

We ordered breakfast. Half order of biscuits and gravy which was like a full order. I typically don't like B&G but the bite I snuck was really good. The bacon was thick and cooked perfectly. Homemade hashbrowns..so good. Two very large pancakes and eggs. Great prices and oh a coffee I could drink without dousing it in creamer. Also, Great service.

Patch Miller

2023-05

…More

Timothy Washington

2023-05

A friend invited me for dinner at 1886 Cafe in Mayetta, KS. On the drive home we continued to talk about the wonderful experience we had. She enjoyed the catfish platter and I ordered the smoked chicken pasta dish. The food was delicious! The restaurant presented a nice, clean, friendly environment. To top things off the staff were outstanding. They were attentive and showed genuine concern for each customer. I will definitely return for another visit.

Lori Sokol

2023-08

We found 1886 as a lunch option on our way to a quick golf weekend playing Firekeeper. Reminded us of a small town diner. Our group had BLT’s, phillys and a burger. Everything was delicious and service was great! Part of our group went back Saturday morning for breakfast. The breakfast burrito, scramble and “eggs in a basket”, were yummy. If you can get the homemade chips or hashbrowns, you’ll be glad you did!

Troy Clark

2023-05

…More

Nick Simon

2023-06

We stopped in for breakfast, we love small town hole in the wall places and this place is top notch!! Locally sourced food and cooked to order by people who know how to make food great!! We’ll be back for sure!

Greg Larson

2023-09

Breakfast on way from Texas to Iowa.Was more than we could eat & they went above & beyond to make sure our allergy needs were met…banana milk, no tomato, gluten free. Wish you were in our neighborhood!!!Dietary restrictions: Went out if their way to take care of us.

Richard Witt

2023-10

…More

Oliver Tootle

2023-12

…More