4.5 (1265)
124 N Market St, Winamac, IN 46996
(574) 946-4343
oneeyedjackswinamac.com
Service options
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Gregg Garrison
2024-04
I was a little shocked at the experience I had. The ambiance was very delightful. The wait wasn't much to speak of. The group was greeted very nicely and kindly. The server was very attentive. The food was amazing. I was in awe when the food came to the table from the rack of ribs (yummy) to the large amount of tasty fish. I had the chicken wrap. It was absolutely great. I always check the restrooms before I eat. It gives an idea of how the kitchen will be. It wasn't a 10 but understandable. I will visit this restaurant again. If you're looking for a great dinner, this is the spot to stop
Brianna Dilts
2024-04
This place was awesome! It was my mother's and my first time eating here and we split one of the Deuce tenderloin sandwiches and fries and it was delicious! They gave us plenty of toppings for the both of us. We both only were able to finish half of each of our already halved sandwiches! The staff here were very friendly and they worked quickly and diligently. I definitely recommended giving this place a try if you haven't before!
Phil long
2024-03
First time here. We were welcomed at the bar by Jay, he was great. He made good suggestions, he could tell we had never been here. I had to get the tenderloin and she had a custom burger. Her burger was cooked perfectly, she likes well done and that can be tricky. It was done but still juicy, perfect. My tenderloin was the best I have ever had. Most places it's a frozen puck, not here. It was the most tender, juicy, and the batter was a nice flakey crisp. Glad we decided to stop in. We'll be back with family and friends! Thanks to the staff. Oh and I forgot to mention the pretzel bites, good choice as well.
Jacque Wenger
2024-04
…More
Josh W
2024-04
…More
Elizabeth Carlson
2024-04
…More
Dustin Noony
2024-04
…More
Janice Davis
2023-12
…More
Jacki Z
2023-05
…More
Louise Nielson
2023-05
Not only were the waitresses super nice and helpful, but they really took care of everything we needed with a smile! The food was delicious! I had the tenderloin and it was the best I have ever eaten! All of the meals served were great! I definitely would definitely go back to eat when in the area!
Cindy Pickering
2023-10
…More
Jeff Shelburne
2024-03
Got there 30 minutes before closing... but was served fairly quickly.... Food is delicious... we were seated in the front area... the other rooms seem like better atmosphere.... Had their famous tenderloin... and was not disappointed. It was extraordinary and huge.... I only ate about 1/3 of it... leftovers taken home. Tator tots were very good, but the portion was small... I like more tutorials tots.... my friend said the patty melt he had was exceptional.... I recommend this place!
Christi Upson
2024-04
…More
Jeffry Smith
2023-12
…More
Robby Robb
2024-04
Pleasant visit. Claim to fame is the pork tenderloin sandwich with good reason. You can also get a 32oz Two Hearted. Just an FYI
Matt Kennedy
2023-05
The portions were big, and the food was cooked well, but had zero seasoning. Tasted like grease for the most part. Catering to an older crowd is understandable, but I like salt and pepper at the very least in my batter. The service was slow, we ordered before another bigger party, and they got their food almost ten minutes before us. There seemed to be plenty of staff, but only one young lady running all of service. Our server seemed to have left maybe?
Jean Bethany
2023-07
Well known for their Pork Tenderloin Sandwich. 12 ounces are massive on a regular bun. Pair that with Sweet Potato waffle fries meant I brought half my sandwich home with some fries. On the other hand the beef sandwich could have used more meat. With the top of the hogie bun in place you would never know there was any meat and cheese on the bun. We'll give It another chance but out of 6 people two were unhappy with their sandwiches. Oh, $3.11 for pop, it is unlimited. Be aware gratuity is included on your check.
Sunman
2024-03
…More
Lynnette Scharf
2024-04
…More
Chris and Rachel Thurwanger
2021-05
Finally made it to One Eyed Jack's!!!! This is a nice family friendly place. The staff was very nice and funny. The food is delicious. The portions are HUGE!!! My hubby and I had the burgers. Very good! My only complaint is that we didnt have enough room for dessert!! As we have seen on the reviews, the tots are not fried twice, they just need to not fry them so long or bake them in the oven. The fries on the other hand do need to be fried a little longer. Otherwise very delicious!!! Son had the tenderloin that I brought home for him. He loved it!!! Clean place, with clean bathrooms.
Jenkie Jolson
2023-09
…More
Shane Hammond
2024-04
…More
Brad Dolezal
2023-11
The food was awesome we had the tenderloin and it was thick crisp and meaty. Wonderful. Condiments served on the side tater tots crisp and fresh. My wife loved the homemade cherry pie. The restaurant was super clean including restrooms. Nice decor and the workers were very pleasant helpful and cheerful. A great surprise and a great find. Will be back.
Mark H. Smith
2024-04
This place is awesome it's my go to place for their famous pork tenderline sandwich it's literally a 2 hand or the park line is huge, and the bun itself measures almost 5 inches across. The prices are more than fair it's a great little place wait staff is awesome cooks are awesome what more can i say period i'll keep going back over and over again
Bailey Storey
2024-01
…More
DR0101
2023-07
…More
Bel Spinner
2022-05
We LOVE coming to One Eyed Jack's for the breaded tenderloin sandwiches! We live out of state and can't get good tenderloins where we live so we always try to come get the best of the best while we are visiting the area! I cannot recommend this place highly enough - great food, great atmosphere, great service! They have a great kids menu too which makes it a great place to bring the whole family.
Rich Green
2023-09
Come hungry to One Eyed Jacks! Great food and unbelievable portions at very reasonable prices! The standard cheeseburger is 8 oz (1/2 pound), and it was absolutely great. It's easily one of the best burgers you'll find! My son ordered the smallest breaded tenderloin on the menu, and it was literally large enough to make three sandwiches. The cut of the meat was 1/2' to 3/4" thick across its breadth, and mouth watering delicious, easily the best of its type anywhere!
Bryan Chamberlain
2023-05
After many years of reading about One Eyed Jack's breaded pork tenderloin sandwiches, I finally had the chance to have one for lunch today.I was not disappointed.(So big, I took 1/2 of it home to share with my daughter.)
Justin Kiel
2024-04
…More
| Monday | 10:30 AM-8 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM-8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM-8 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM-9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM-9 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM-9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Scan the QR code to leave a review.
Powered by bulkqrcodegenerator.com
Pet Stores in the USA
Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.
Broswe by Population