Faytastic Pizza

Joshua Cave

2024-01

…More

Andrew Couchman

2023-11

Hole in the wall pizza joint. Sometimes great. Ingredients seem to change alot. Sometimes not so great. Had undercooked pizza there several times. It is overpriced. At the same time it's all shoals really has for pizza. If it was more friendly and Ingredients were consistent and cooked enough to get that awesome slightly browned cheesy goodness it would be 5 stars. But it's extremely inconsistent and sometimes the people there treat you like an inconvenience. A smiling face always willing to help goes a long way!Parking: On the main strip so sometimes theres a lack of parkingWheelchair accessibility: No wheelchair entrance.

Tenna Nicely

2023-11

…More

Harmony Kozak

2018-05

Visited Faytastic Pizza for the first time today! The service was very friendly. I ordered the Works pizza. It was good. I was a smig disappointed in the size of the pizza for the price. Granted with it not being a chain I would expect it to cost more. I definitely recommend this local establishment if you are in the area!

Dominia Truelove

2024-01

…More

Justin Jeffries

2023-07

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Thank you to Anthony Edwards for not only recommending this place but also making it for me. My family and I will definitely be back.

Tammy Duke

2023-05

…More

Marcus Lambert

2023-05

I believe this is the best hidden secret in the history of pizza. I grew up in Shoals IN, and I no longer live there but will drive 30 miles just to buy their food. These people know the art of making pizza! Beyond words!

Kelly Terry

2023-11

…More

Isaac

2022-05

Went out of their way to deliver me food, got stuck at gypsum overnight. If you’re a driver getting stuck there and they can deliver to you, your tip better be over $20. Best pizza and that from someone from Alaska.Thank you 🙏🏻

Jake Luttrell

2021-05

It’s hard to find a steak and cheese sandwich I can’t finish. I found one. Also, it was delicious.Price and taste comparison it blows Penn Station and Subways steak and cheese sandwiches out of the water!Looking forward to trying more of the menu.

Deborah Hellums

2018-05

My favorite pizza now is chicken bacon ranch deluxe,it was taco and combo. My favorite sandwich now is steak and cheese loaded,I love the homemade bbq on my sandwich. We make fresh dough daily. Many people love this home town favorite,we have people from everywhere that visit to have a tasty pizza made from scratch!!! The food is made with love. Excellent!!

Christine Flaherty

2023-09

…More

Debra Rehl

2024-02

…More

THOMAS TOWNE

2021-05

You pay a lot for average quality.Unprofessionally run by a ditz of an owner. Would not return under any circumstances. I purchased three incorrectly made food orders in a year. That's where I get off the bus.Goodbye and good riddance!

Betty Williams

2022-05

…More

Rose Briggs

2021-05

Found this place while on a road trip! Cute place. Food was great! Loved the stuffed crust! Friendly staff and fair prices. Hope I can come back someday.

Ronnette Odle

2020-05

Would not recommend this place.We placed an order by phone, they said it would be ready in 1hr 15 minutes. Went in to if it was ready after an hour, they hadn't even started making it yet; so it was going to be another 25 to 35 minutes longer.We told them to forget it.So we might not go back there again.

Jill

2020-05

Best pizza around. Only complaint is that they are closed Sundays. Is a must stop if you are around the Shoals area. The Cheesy breadsticks are also amazing as well.

Martin Evans

2019-05

Every time I've eaten there it has been a very good experience, friendly and reasonably priced and the food is very good not just the pizza, I mean everything.

Adam Carrico

2021-05

This was my first time to get pizza from here and I must say very very good,,,most definitely be stopping by there again,,,

Debby Cosner

2020-05

Haven't gotten anything bad from here. Just tried the chicken Fry's and really liked them. The bbq sauce with them was really tasty. Just needs to be more of it.

Sarah Kaiser

2022-05

Good dough, good toppings, consistent quality. Nothing fancy, but definitely one of our favorite local pies.

Mike Hellums

2019-05

I have always loved the food here I travel eighty miles just for a stromboli. Best on Earth. Quality food from great caring friendly people.

Martin Tarrh

2023-12

…More

Jonathan Sullivan

2021-05

Fay and Sarah and their staff make great pizzas and breadsticks. Sometimes the wait can be long, but the wait is always worth it!

melissa godfrey

2021-05

Love there pizza sticks I go out of my way just to go to shoals for there pizza bc it's better than what we have here

Fawad Ahmad

2021-05

I lived in many countries such as Europe, Asia and tell you what I found the best Pizza I ever had in Faytastic Pizza in Shoals INTry it you won’t regret!

Jerry Ervin

2019-05

The only pizza place in town, but they get good ingredients for their stuff which makes up for being the best pizza around!

Kelsey Slaten

2023-11

…More