Sundaes on Sylvan

Allison Corner

2023-08

We were there to celebrate the adoption of one of our friends kiddos. The day each one joined the family is "gotcha day". He was surprised by the delicious sundae to celebrate his gotcha day. Thanks for the amazing ice cream.

Valerie Getts

2023-07

Love the employees AND the ice cream... my daughter is fond of the bright blue ice cream... we always enjoy going here to cool of and relax. WAAAAAY better than the new place in Albion

Rachel Buell

2020-05

First off, it smelled amazing when walking in. They were making cones 😋 Nice variety of flavors of ice cream. Sampled a few different kinds and liked them all. Also tried the pulled pork and chicken sandwiches which were pretty good. Didn't care for their pretzels though. Its a cute little place with lake themed decor throughout. And the sitting area out back had a pleasant view.

DARIUSZ P.

2023-08

The only ice cream parlor in the area, several ice cream flavors, served safely, do not drip on the hands.

Matthew Perry

2023-05

Showed up with a large family, and the service was fast and extremely friendly. And the ice cream was delicious! Try the Sea Monster (Caramel ice cream with Oreo cookies and cookie dough)

Kelsey G

2019-05

Fantastic ice cream overlooking the lake. The ice cream rotates often and is always fresh. Generally visit with a big group, so we sit on the back porch, but there is indoor seating and a couple front porch seats as well. Service is always friendly! Recently had the lavender honey ice cream and I could eat it everyday!

Rodney Daler

2023-06

Mint ice cream tasted freezer burnt ,and only after a few bits started feeling sick to my stomach.definetly wouldn't recommend getting ice cream from here .my wife had something that was supposed to be strawberry cheese cake and you could see that it was freezer burnt .a waste of 12.00 bucks for sure

Finola La-Follette

2023-05

Never open when they say they are. Can't trust the hours posted. I have even called in the past to confirm their hours only to come and see they closed early. Employee's were walking out the door when we arrived and refused to stay and serve us. Very very disappointing.

Amanda Schultz

2023-08

Ordered Twix and got Espresso. No Twix pieces and tasted like coffee, which I don't like.

Rachel

2022-05

Had the 4th of July special and it was so good!

Brandi Bittelmeyer

2019-05

Cute shop with great ice cream. They have a lot of flavors (many which are not visible in the freezer case, so make sure you read the full menu to view all their opinions!) The staff were all very friendly.

Selina Rathburn

2023-05

We drive out of our way to visit SOS as often as we can. The ice cream is delicious, the prices are reasonable, the staff is wonderful, and the environment is stellar.

Adam OHaver

2020-05

Great selection of flavors, friendly staff, and plenty of seating. Great local ice cream shop with very fair prices. Highly recommend!

Pam

2023-05

A Quant and cute place, very friendly, great ice cream. Sizes and amount of ice cream is worth the price!!

steven c cook

2022-05

Amazing service. Owners and staff are very friendly. The memorial day special, warm cherry cobbler with ice cream was delicious.

Michele Burkheimer - Real Estate Agent

2021-05

My husband and I visit ice cream shops when we are out on the motorcycle. This ice cream shop was ranked in the top 20 in Indiana so we rode an hour to give it a try. Was not worth it. It was very bland and flavorless. Very disappointed.

Brenda Perry

2018-05

Tonight was my 1st time visiting , I have been really missing out on the Best Ice Cream in all the area. I will be visiting their business again.I had Sea Salt Carmel Ice Cream it was the Best.

Matthew Coffman

2021-05

Always friendly service and the absolute largest selection and best ice cream with great seating overlooking Sylvan Lake!

Ken Moudy

2019-05

Great ice cream in a quaint old house overlooking Sylvan Lake. Staff is very friendly and attentive and lots of flavors to choose from. A must visit for the grandkids.

Joan Minter

2020-05

Good ice cream, pleasant to eat outside next to Sylvan lake, LOVE taking my grandkids there when they come to visit, they love it! They always ask to go there.

Randall Myers

2019-05

Friendly service and very good ice cream, especially the buckeye ice cream which is very very rich. It's a little pricey, but worth it to support a family business

Shawndra Nicodemus

2019-05

Very friendly staff! Great ice cream! Cute interior and exterior. Highly recommend!

Dale Schrock

2020-05

The choice of flavored ice cream was awesome. Loved the decorations and with it being on the lake, reminds me of home ❤

ane h devries

2020-05

Love the ice cream. I got 2 scoops of 2 different kinds. Big portions. Yummy

Karen Clapp-Morris

2023-09

Moo ville Ice cream! Super good

Caroline Sizelove

2022-05

New owners this season. Ice cream brand does not have as much flavor as previous owner's brand.

Kim Freiburger

2023-05

Tons of flavors and super rich. The young ladies working behind the counter were really nice!

Autumn Montoya

2023-05

Best little I've cream shop in a small town.

Shane Replogle

2020-05

Awesome icecream in Rome City! It is easily accessible from your boat on Sylvan lake next to the public boat access.

Rob Beechy

2021-05

Great place for some good ice cream.