Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop

Amber Powers

2023-10

…More

Glenn Schwenk

2024-01

Monday evening with family.Friendly waitress. Loved her playful snarky attitude. Great service. Great pizza. Loved the bread sticks.Parking: More than 20. We parked at door.

Sebastian Pask

2023-11

Mikey's Pizza Pitstop is a great place to go for pizza and wings if you're in the Rochester, Indiana area. The Buffalo pizza is particularly good, with a generous amount of chicken and cheese. However, it can be a bit salty, so be prepared for that. The BBQ sauce on the wings is also a bit disappointing, but the wings themselves are cooked to perfection. The prices at Mikey's are a little higher than other pizza places in the area, but the quality of the food is worth it.The atmosphere at Mikey's is great, with a casual and relaxed vibe. The music is always good, and the staff is friendly and attentive. Our waitress was nice, and she made sure that we had everything we needed.Overall, I would recommend Mikey's Pizza Pitstop to anyone looking for a good pizza and wings experience. Just be prepared for the higher prices and the salty Buffalo pizza.

MARY GIBSON

2024-03

…More

Judy Zimmerman

2020-05

Great food choices downtown Rochester Indiana! Several menu choices from pizza,burgers,wings,and pasta. I chose a burger as a quicker option while traveling. It was thick, juicy and delicious along with fries and cheese dipping soft. Skip fast food and try this place! I will definitely go back!

Ben M

2022-05

…More

Melissa Biggs

2024-01

…More

M H

2023-07

Taco pizza was super thin tonight. Hardly any cheese, meat, beans. Mostly rated it a two because the chips on top of the pizza were SO STALE! I would not serve food like that to my guests. I’ll give Mikey’s another try but it will be a long time before I do.

Fernando Billafana

2023-09

Nothing spectacular... It's definitely over priced . 10 dollars for 10 fried pickles. But we got the sampler platter for 16.99 that comes with 4 mottarella sticks, 10 potato wedges 6 boneless wings, 6 onion rings an 2 soft drinks for 6 dolars.. so it's about $20 dollars a person to eat here

Monroe Alfrey

2023-07

Food was excellent.Service was slow but that is to be expected (unfortunately) in these times.Mikey's is always a consideration when we find ourselves hungry and in the Rochester area.You won't be disappointed. We never have been.

Cheryl Kreamer

2023-09

First time there, we got carry out. The place was pleasant. I ordered a pizza with everything, breadsticks, cauliflower and mushrooms. First off the breadsticks were great I loved them! Cauliflower was also good! My husband liked the mushrooms too! Now we get to the more disappointing part- surprisingly the pizza. The very FIRST bite I took, I got a bone sliver in my tooth from the sausage! I thought ok, not a good first experience but it happens sometimes with sausage. The sauce wasn’t my favorite either. But if I gave my rating yesterday it probably would be more on the 3-4 range. However, today I got out the leftover pizza and split a piece of pizza with my son. So a half of a slice. Again in my VERY first bite- I got ANOTHER bone sliver! I thought no way this is possible but sure enough I spit out my bite and there it was, fairly big. This can take your pizza experience to poor pretty quick. My husband has had their pizza before and said it was pretty good from what he remembered but he only got pepperoni. So while the appetizers were really good I’m not sure I’d give them another try.

Lauren Scharp

2023-10

…More

Kim Sunde

2024-02

…More

harrison see

2023-05

…More

Nathan Choler

2022-05

We were looking for a local place to stop for dinner on the way home from a trip and stumbled upon this restaurant. To say the menu is large is an understatement. They have wings, they have pizza, they have sandwiches, they have pasta, they have pretty much anything a family with a 6 and 3 year old could want. As for the quality, it was great, both kids actually finished their food. I had a meat lovers pizza and they put some kind of garlic butter on the crust that made it amazing. Our waitress was excellent, brought refills on drinks without asking, checked in multiple times, and was super personable. We came in around 5:15 on a Saturday and it wasn't very busy, but by the time we left at 6:15 almost every table was taken on the family side. We all really enjoyed this restaurant and would definitely consider stopping here again if in the area.

Jacki Pawski

2022-05

Pizza was excellent, as always! We placed a large order a day early for a going away party to be picked up the nect day. Mikey's opens at 11:00 am and said they would have the order ready no later than 11:45 am. Mikey's had EVERYTHING completely ready on time. It was a pretty large order and to have it ready 45 minutes after they opened, they would have had to come in early and start on it early.Amazing customer service and amazing food!

Kimberly Minks

2021-05

Great food at great prices. Restaurant and their restrooms are always neat and tidy. Courtney is one of the best servers I've ever had the pleasure of dealing with. Super friendly and helpful. Attentive and quick to take care of any needs we had. She's one of the best hands down. Great lady! Made our dining experience very pleasurable!

Cindy Bucher

2023-05

Waited hour to get our food and one waitress for the whole place think you better get some help. Nothing against the waitress she was trying but good God this is ridiculous. The only thing we ordered was wings what you have to do kill the chickens and clean them? And once we got our wings there was 8 drummies and only two wings.

Mike Gray

2023-05

Some of the best pizza I've had in a long time! So good I had to come back for round two while I was visiting town. Loved the garlic butter sauce/crust.

Jesse Miniear

2023-05

…More

Jerry Kandel

2022-05

I was in town for a couple days and decided to check Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop out. Had pizza and wings the first night and the second night had the Italian club sandwich. Both were excellent and very tasty. Servers were very friendly and attentive and the food arrived in a reasonable amount of time. I would certainly recommend this eating establishment to others!

Savannah Nick

2022-05

Food was good. Service horrible sat for q long period of time with no beverages and food. they were kinda busy but I seen our waitress taking better care of other tables she knew that came in after us then she did us. Also being a server I know we need to treat all guest the best we can including those we know and DONT!!!

Adrienne Beck

2023-05

i have a love/hate relationship with Mikey’s so far, of my two times eating there. the waitress is very nice. but the food is not my favorite, or the prices.Parking: odd parking.

Jake Baker

2023-05

Good pizza, their mixed drink menu was great we pretty much tried every drink on it. The waitress was prompt and took care of us. Tons of menu options. I would like to try more of the items they have.

Marie Benzing

2021-05

Your waitress put me on hold for 1 hour. I got to your place and I was still left on hold. She said we've been busy. She asked me if still wanted to order..... so, I was on hold for a hour and had to wait 40 more minutes for my food. She didn't say sorry or anything. She over charged the people behind me for an extra order of breadsticks. Poor service is why I gave you a one. The food was good and hot. She is a poor waitress. I didn't get a good feeling that the other waitress liked her. 😕

Howard House

2024-04

…More

Brandon Craig

2019-05

Very cool local pizza place! I love the racing memorabilia all around from the local race track. They have all kinds of options. Definitely not just a pizza joint. My coworker and I appreciated the fresh made pizza crust and bread. The bread on my stromboli was excellent...as was the sandwich as a whole. I was very satisfied and would recommend Mikey's. Hope to come back when I am in the area.

Victoria J

2022-05

We love this place. They have THE BEST wings. Every time we head home from Michigan we always stop for cheese pizza and their honey bbq wings. Their breadsticks are absolutely amazing as well. Staff is amazing and we will always stop here!

Bruce Miller

2024-02

…More

Jennifer Norris

2023-05

Stopped in on our way thru Rochester. Service was great and all the food was good! The breaded tenderloin was really, really good and the nachos were loaded with all the yummy stuff!