4.5 (64)
203 N Michigan St, Plymouth, IN 46563
(574) 784-1004
facebook.com
Service options
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Elizabeth Wickens
2024-05
…More
Kristyn
2023-05
Big Lebowski and Longmire will not disappoint! Flatbread with great flavor! My mom is a picky eater and retired restaurant owner of 20 years and she said it was really good!
Paisley Blackburn
2023-12
…More
Troy
2023-08
We love good ice cream, this place did not disappoint. Friendly staff and good atmosphere. Price is perfect in my opinion, for the negative reviews regarding the price people have to understand the cost to operate a small business. I would rather pay a small business more money than pay less at a franchise operation. My family loves this place and will continue supporting it.
Karl Merkner
2023-10
Great service and good ice cream!
Nick Counts
2024-05
…More
Rebekah M
2023-07
Honestly way overpriced for what you're served. $4 for the smallest scoop I've ever seen at any ice-cream place and then 75 cents for less than a teaspoon of toppings... The ice cream had crystallization on it which is not a good thing either. Honestly you'd be better off to go to scoops and smiles in bass lake or even chain places such as dairy queen and Culver's. If you prefer a subpar product and to pay an unreasonable amount for what you get then this is the place for you.
Robin Doll
2023-05
Amazing ice cream, fabulous service, very clean and sanitary. Great selection of choices
Ashley Donley
2023-05
Quaint downtown ice cream shop featuring delicious homemade ice cream. Large variety of flavors, great quality. The location is a bit hard to find, they don't have a building sign yet and the bulk of the shop is location pretty far into the building. Not super speedy to get your scoops, but hopefully they'll get into a better rhythm once they've been open for a few weeks.
Blake Curtis
2023-05
Bearys is one of the best ice cream joints in plymouth and I highly recommend it other than dairy queen cause the ice cream is too die for and all the flavors! Yum but they also have food by some weird names but it is really good the priceing are awsome too
sandra saenz
2023-05
Great burger!!! Awesome flavor - will definetely eat here again!! Thanks so much!
StacynBrody Prather
2023-05
I love a good ice cream shop with real fresh scooped ice cream. This little gem has an amazing selection of ice cream flavors and ice cream concoctions for all. I had "The Rees" sundae. It was delicious just would like more peanut butter flavor in the pb ice cream!
Mike Dezenzo
2023-05
Great ice cream, ton of flavors. Smashburger was exceptional!Grandkids loved it!
Amanda McFarland
2023-05
I had the burger which was smash burger style. It was delicious! I also had the raspberry cheesecake ice cream which was also delicious. They have several other flavors of ice cream to choose from. They also serve hotdogs. I will definitely return.
Gabriel Campbell
2023-05
Very nice local ice cream shop. They have a good variety of flavors to choose from and the ice cream is very good. The prices are reasonable for a premium ice cream place; a normal scoop is $4. They also have really good waffle cones.
JavibearR32
2023-09
A great home town ice cream place, they also have food . I enjoy their smash burger. Great service and Hospitality.
Brittney Starr
2023-05
Cute place but pretty expensive. Waffle bowl tasted burnt and ice cream didn't taste like cookie dough. The cost for 3 small things was 23 bucks. Shake alone was 10. In my opinion, wasn't worth it. Probably won't return.
Amanda Petrucelli
2023-05
Super tasty ice cream with lots of flavor and topping options. I really recommend the smash burger, too. Staff was helpful and fun to talk to. I’ll be back!
Blake
2023-07
More than an ice cream shop! Beary’s has the best sandwiches in town. 10x plus customer and satisfied every time!
Steven Dulin
2023-05
Large amounts of flavors but the butterscotch bomb isn't anything butterscotch at all. Way over priced for the small amount of ice cream you get. Didn't have all flavors in stock kinda a let down being that it's the summer time where you would think they would have all the flavors.
Cait Seamon
2023-07
I love this place’s ice cream! It’s a very cozy vibe and the workers here are great! Come here for a good time!
Maddie VanHulle
2023-05
They offer a wide variety of flavors. I got the Salty Caramel Peanut, it was very delicious. I am definitely going to go back and try some other flavors!
Jennifer Fox
2023-06
My whole family loves Beary's!! The food & ice cream are excellent & the staff is very friendly and professional!!
Tammy Harvey
2023-05
Great little hometown ice cream shop. 2nd visit and the ice cream was great again! Had the salty carmel peanut.. Best flavored ice cream I've had in a long time!
M Jones
2023-05
A great selection of ice cream. The Pistachio was very yummy :)Great place for kids, there are fun games and activities for kids to play.Very friendly owners.
Renee Colley
2023-05
It is very nice that there is an Ice Cream Shop in downtown Plymouth
JT
2023-05
Nice little hometown ice cream shop. They have every flavor you could think of. The staff was friendly and very welcoming.
Michael Keiper
2023-06
Cool little shop didn’t give 5 stars because you can’t see the ice cream before you order but you can get samples to try.
Maggie Kubley
2023-05
HUGE FAN of Beary’s!!! I’m obsessed with the banana pudding ice cream, it’s delicious. The food is also really good - def grab a burger when you stop by.
Nike Swissha
2023-10
Couldn't' get a basic order right. Ordered a chili cheese dog and I received something entirely else. Nobody was around ordering anything so there was no way to mess that order up. Very disappointed.
Pet Stores in the USA
Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.
Broswe by Population