Crystal Springs Creamery

Mateo Gebon

2024-01

I’m happy I went out of my way to stop by here. The farm is very picturesque, and the store sells a lot of high quality dairy. Their chocolate milk is wonderfully creamy and rich, and I’d like to try their other flavors in the future. Their ice cream was excellent, and the Espresso Almond Fudge Swirl is maybe the best coffee ice cream I’ve ever tried. Their mini pies were also delicious. If only I lived closer by.

Wendell Rohrer

2024-02

A delightful, hidden gem. A high quality dairy store in a quaint country atmosphere. Thoroughly enjoyed getting ice cream cones and eating outside at the picnic table where the grandkids could also pet some calves this past summer. Even though I've lived in the area for years, we only just recently discovered this place. Now we're telling everyone about it. The store staff were also great and friendly.

Ricardo Rechtman

2023-07

A hidden treasure in the Elkhart-Goshen area! Beautiful farm setting. Icecream has a nice, smooth, texture and they offer many flavors! Coffee was delicious. I'll be back to try different flavors!

Beccaw

2023-12

Very wonderful family experience. You get to interact with baby cows in the summer months and some amazing treats each season! The people are lovely and they make amazing dairy products. I recommend the Ash Pothole or try Heifer Tracks!

Conan Armstrong-Ingram

2024-01

Great place for an amazing milkshake! The cheese curds are great and the milk is excellent too. Farm to your table Amish quality goodness.

T W

2023-05

We love the Cold Brew Coffee Milk and try to stop whenever we're in the area. The other items we've had are also delicious!

Nancy Cole

2024-04

The most delicious creamy chocolate milk ever. Good enough to use as creamer in your coffee w/o all the yuk.

Renee Shisler

2023-05

Cute and quaint. Just added homemade ice cream. Cones, 1/2 gallons and pints. Not to mention the varieties of milk, cheese curds, yogurt, baked goods, soup starters and jams. Fresh ground beef. Amazing!

Joseph Hunter

2024-04

Always great dairy products..honey,n baked goods..great place to stop for a laid back time...great ice cream treats..

Tammy Maginot

2023-06

Had an enjoyable experience and the items I bought are very delicious.

Barbara Meyer

2023-05

The most delicious creamy chocolate milk I have ever tasted! Sold on it.!! Travel miles to our nearest store to get these products! Love the glass bottles the milk comes in.

Kortney M

2022-05

We love Crystal Springs Creamery. We love to take the kids and have them all pick out their own milks. There is always a variety to choose from but specialty flavors do sell out so you have to get them while they're hot sort of speak. They have animals out in the spring that the children can pet and interact with. There's a variety of breads, cheeses, jams and jellies in addition to their milks. If you come in early spring you're able to see the newborn calves that are going to grow up and be the next generation of this creamery. It's a short drive off the main road and worth the wait if something is out of stock. They have a nice bottle exchange as well that will take a few dollars off of your next purchase.

Sarah Wagner

2023-09

I absolutely love coming here for a number of reasons. For one - obviously the fantastic milk. I was getting raw milk from a trusted source but my husband just could not get on board with it so we switched to Crystal Springs. It's not raw however it is slowly heated during the pasteurization process which keeps the nutrients and minerals in the milk. I also get my eggs from here. They are $4 a carton but they are organic and pasture raised which is a GREAT price. At the grocery stores, organic pasture raised eggs can cost up to $10 for a dozen. I also enjoy buying the 100% soy candles from here. I recommend if you have littles, coming here for an ice cream treat. It's $1.75 for a cow lick mini and it is plenty. Way cheaper and better for you than Dairy Queen or any other ice cream place for that matter. The only reason I took one star off is because I wish they had indoor seating. Other than this, I can't say I have any other complaints about this gem of a place.

Cadence Lehman

2023-08

They always have a wonderful selection of milk and other dairy products. Their meat selections are also incredible. The meats last so much longer and look more appetizing than chain grocery stores’. We don’t go anywhere else to buy our milk and beef if we can help it. The people are always friendly. I can guarantee you can find something you’ll enjoy in their store.

Spencer T

2021-05

They have several varieties of milk including orange creme and coffee as well as bacon, ground beef, and pork chops next to the baked goods. Baby calfs and a homey barn entrance/interior makes this a weekend stop for me and the kids

Deb Sailor

2023-05

Fresh milk, cheese, yogurt, ect. I also bought some fresh veggies and fresh cut flowers from them. I bought chocolate and strawberry milk in cute little glass jugs. My son in law said it tastes amazing. I loved the cheese curds. They have added ice cream.

Geraldine Randolph

2024-01

I went looking for low-fat healthy ice cream. They didn't have any, but I found healthy milk. Thanks, Crystal Springs. We will be back.

Danaca Paluzzi

2024-01

Delicious and fresh milks, cheeses, ice cream, and baked goods! Really enjoy the different selections of milkand cheeses.. Staff is friendyand helpful!

Pat Yoder

2024-02

They are very friendly and great ice-cream. Flavors milk is different and very good.

Marybeth Hoffer

2023-08

I bought Crystal Springs Creamery milk for the first time at Martin’s. My kids and grands loved the different flavors and I had to return the bottles back to the creamery for a refund. So much more to choose from besides milk! We came away today with ice cream and more milk flavors! Will have to go back for cheese curds and cottage cheese!

KELLY MATLOCK

2023-05

Love their fresh heavy whipping cream, butters, cheese curds, and sausage links and patties!!

Yvonne Broadway

2024-04

Best milk ever. I wish they would make their flavored milks with skim milk

Beth Letson

2022-05

The staff is so very friendly and helpful. Love the Banana Split Milk and my hubbies fav is the Coffee milk. Grabbed some country sausage and eggs too!! The grandkids had a blast petting the calves.

Deb Longcor

2023-11

This is a wonderful place and worth the drive. The ice cream is delicious and the servings huge! I'd love to tour their dairy operation sometime.

Kent Kidder

2023-11

I've been unsuccessful in trying to purchase premade creme fraiche locally. I came to Crystal Springs and although they do not sell it either, I purchased fresh heavy cream and buttermilk and made my best batch yet. Their products are really fresh and flavorful.

Raquel Jameson-Lee

2023-08

Love they cold brew and zucchini bread. Not to mention the vegetable stand out front- delicious, farm fresh, affordable and local. My kids love visiting the cows and getting ice cream, so it’s a fun stop for everyone.

Christina Hein

2023-05

Have been going here for years.They've grown so much, and it has been amazing to see the new things they come out with! I'm so glad they have been able to make updates to their space. They absolutely deserve whatever helps make their job easier!! We love visiting at LEAST weekly.

Rose Herban

2024-02

Really cute farm and store. It is super neat being able to see inside of the kitchen where they make ice cream!

Jennifer G.

2023-05

This is worth the drive! Delicious dairy products! They also have some great cookies and ice cream! They carry eggs as well and the last time I was there they were under $5 for a dozen. If you want local diary this is your shop!Support your local community!

Jessica Noffsinger

2023-05

We are regulars there, weekly going in for milk and eggs mostly. But all their products are great! I love that they are local, family owned, and stay away from chemicals as much as possible. Same for the other vendors they sell at their location. We can certainly taste the difference and the price is not too much high than your local grocery. So for cleaner, healthier food, I'll pay those cents more with them!