Speakeasy Pizza

Zakkry Walls

2024-04

…More

Melissa Dorsey

2024-04

…More

Sierra Pearson

2023-05

We hadn’t been to Orleans before but now we have a reason to come back again and again! We were in the area for Christmas photos and stopped in for a Pie, Sticks, and a couple of beers and we were impressed from start to finish.The owner was extremely friendly in checking on us throughout the meal, the service was fast and the brick oven pizza was incredible! The breadsticks were huge and some of the best we’ve had but the beer cheese dipping sauce was hands down the best we’ve had.The atmosphere was trendy and we admired every last detail from the ceilings to the light fixtures to the shelves on the walls. We also really appreciated the Holiday decor with nods to “A Christmas Story.”We found a reason to fall in love with Orleans and will definitely be making the trip again!

C. Morgan

2023-05

5 stars. That's all you need to know!As a lover of Pizza, especially brick oven, and even wood fired. I had to try this place in Orleans Indiana. Parking was good, there was plenty around the square. First thing I notice is a large fenced off area for outdoor seating. Upon entering the establishment the atmosphere is fantastic. Lots of period correct figures framed on the walls, great vintage decor. Large menu hanging that is easy to read. Place your order at the bar, and grab a seat. Did you see that fantastic brick oven back there?!? I ordered the #4 Margherita. Pizza came up quick as there wasn't hardly anyone else there due to being so early (11am). Pizza dough has good flavor, not your typical flour taste. Good cruch and a nice chewy center with plenty of small air pockets. Really good undercarriage. Pizza sauce was very flavorful of San Manzano tomatoes, slight chunkiness with bits of tomatoe in the sauce. Mozzarella seemed fresh. Basil was so fresh I watched them pull the leaves off the locally sourced plant.All in all, wonderful experience, excellent food, excellent staff, very nice atmosphere. This place should be a destination, not just something to grab "on the way through".

Paige Elkins

2023-08

Something To Be Proud Of.I can't tell you how refreshing it is to visit a small town business that is doing it right. From the logo, the design of the interior, the name, the food, and even the flavor combinations... you can tell everything has been done with intention and thought.The quality of the ingredients? Superb. You can tell they're fresh, they even had a fresh basil plant displayed upfront.Pizza? Best I've had in a long time. Truly beats any other pizzeria in the area, Bloomington included. The crust was my favorite. It was perfect. Most pizza places have you miserable after you eat, but Speakeasy has that thinner crust that leaves you full but not sick. You can taste the toppings and the flavor from the woodfire.I will gladly continue driving 40 minutes to get a slice of their pizza. Congratulations Speakeasy team, you're hard work shows and it's something to be proud of!

Peggy Williamson

2024-05

Love their pizza! Thank you for offering cauliflower crust! Wish you were open on Wednesday.Dietary restrictions: Cauliflower crust! Yum

Regina Goldman

2024-04

I get the Cauifower crust, and it is great ! Has nice cocktails and a good beer selection. The pizzas all have gangster names and some cool mugshots of the gangsters.Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free crust

Elizabeth R

2021-05

Gourmet pizza in a sleepy little town. First trip here, and I am totally impressed. The staff is beyond friendly. The restaurant is very clean. That woodfire pizza oven is absolutely gorgeous! Wide varieties of beer from all over, craft and domestics. The speakeasy cider was deliciously dangerous. I had the personal Bugsy pizza, it's a little eclectic, the wide variety of flavors will leave your taste buds in aw! Would highly recommend. On the next stop I'll try a more "normal" pizza so I can compare with others. The boyfriend had a calzone it looked delicious as well.

Virginia Webb

2024-04

…More

Jeff DeHaven

2024-04

…More

JR Davis

2023-05

Absolutely delicious! We devoured it like hungry bears! Friendly staff and great food. Loved my pepperoni and sausage pizza! Breadsticks with house made cheese dip that would make a puppy pull a freight chain!

Kalee McFall

2021-05

DELICIOUS! The pizza is always amazing and so is the staff. I love their beer cheese breadstick sauce! My husband's favorite is the Calzone. Even though there may be a line out the door, they dish out the food at a very acceptable time. And it's great quality! The owners come out from the back periodically to acknowledge their customers on a personal basis. Their live videos through Facebook are fun to watch. My husband and I look forward to their new special for the week! We have made our Wednesday's "Speakeasy" night!

Jennifer Meyer

2021-05

Love, love, love this restaurant! Great atmosphere and staff! They only use the best ingredients. Excellent beer selection, too. I can't wait to go back for more!

Miranda Ramirez

2022-05

Best pizza around! I ordered the cauliflower crust and you can't even tell it's cauliflower! The fire fed brick oven is even from Italy so I was told. I was also told they use fresh ingredients! And their selection of beer and ciders is excellent! Ask what sauces they have! I was very impressed and will definitely be back!!!

Wyatt Glasscock

2023-05

Wow! Such an amazing place to get pizza ! The Beer Cheese and Breadsticks were great and the Oven Baked pizza was even better ! Great selections of Beer and Pizzas all in a super cool building located in Downtown Orleans on the Square! Definitely stop by and try it for yourself, you won’t be disappointed!

Kinley Norton

2022-05

This place was the best pizza place I have been to, hands down! The owner was really nice and had a southern charm about him. Even my 10 year old commented on how good the customer service was. Delicious pizza and frozen peach margarita and very fast service. Would definitely recommend and plan on visiting again! ☺️

Bob Beck

2024-03

Had their pizza out of their food truck and it was amazing. I can only imagine how good it is at the store.

Jesse Rhodes

2024-01

…More

Rich Brotherton

2024-02

…More

Matt Schwab

2024-03

…More

Janet Morand

2024-03

…More

Matthew Winebrenner

2024-04

…More

KrystalShet77

2023-05

We absolutely adore the Speakeasy! Matt, Cody and the staff are friendly, and they put out an amazing product. You will NOT be disappointed, nor will you leave hungry. I love the on-tap beer options, breadsticks and brick oven pizzas. I love the atmosphere, and I love how the owners are so invested in their business and customers. My recommendation, however, is to go early in order to get a seat because this place is always hopping!

Ron Burcham

2024-03

…More

m k

2023-08

Hands down the BEST pizza I've ever eaten in Indiana!!! I'm from NY and moving here has been very difficult to find something that even closely compares. Speakeasy Pizza blew us out of the water. So delicious! The crust, the sauce, everything was perfect. I ate the Margherita and my boyfriend had the Chorizo. The Nutella dessert pizza was also amazing. Definitely returning next time I'm in town!

Paul Warner

2023-06

Had Salad which was good but could have been cut up to edible pieces or they could have provided knives. Breadsticks were good but the dipping sauces were a little bland. They had Yeungling draft that was very good. We didn't eat pizza but they do have a wood fired oven so I think it would be good.

Philip Vetter

2023-05

I honestly think this is the best pizza in Southern Indiana. Great and fast service, very fair prices and a good selection of beer/cider.

Dawn Wilks

2023-05

From the first moment you walk into this restaurant you are greeted with a very home like atmosphere. Very friendly and respectful place to eat, not to mention the food! The pizza is like no other they use all fresh vegetables and it is cooked in a wood oven. Let me just say it is amazing! Then you have the salads, loaded with all the fresh vegetables of your choice , many types of shredded cheese and your choice of meat. And yes it’s not your typical iceberg lettuce either. They use a spring mix which makes it even better. You can’t go wrong , if you try it just once believe me it will become your go to place. I know it’s ours!

Verona Coffee House

2023-10

…More

Franklin Talbott

2023-09

Matt and Cody are the Best! The staff is top notch. And the food..... Oh my. Tastebuds in foodie bliss! Notch to mention a LARGE selection of beers and of coarse, Bourbon.Parking: It's on the town square. No problem parking.Kid-friendliness: More of an adult vibe but kids are welcome.