The Original Fish of Stroh

Alicia Guyton

2024-03

The waitress didn't clean our table before we sate down,she didn't even give is menus ignored us when we asked for some and for the table to be cleaned and we were waited for 20 minutes, before finally getting up and leaving. Pretty sure the waitress was drunk as you could smell the booze on her as she kept walking past our table. 0/10 do NOT recommend. Drove all the way from Lagrange to try this place.

Grandma Bower

2019-05

Oh,where to begin?This was the first time, since I grew up in LaGrange, which was about 20 years, that I've been there.Same place, same PHENOMENAL food.Get the all-you-can-eat,you get baked potato,all you can eat fish and salad bar and drink for two people is under $45!The waitress was great as well. Go... you have to now.What are you waiting for goodbye!You will thank me for the tip.🐟

ron machus

2023-10

have fish there many years ago..thought they went out of business got very excited when I found out they were opened. well they should go out of business. The place was a shack and that's being nice...prices way..way.to high.If it was good I wouldn't mind...the tea was spoiled...the fish was nasty and the tartar sauce was the worse...used to be that was the only place I'd have tartar sauce..no more...I'll never go back...what a disappointment 😞.

Lisa Powell

2023-08

Love the atmosphere. Loved the server.The fish was alright until it started cooling. The fries are hard. The onion rings are tender but you get 4 with a meal!! They need more breading. I ate 2 of my 4 little chicken strips that were not very good. Hard and salty. The corn fritters were My favorite.We will not return as we paid $50.49 for 8 fritters, 3 pieces of fish, fries, 4 onion rings, 2 tiny dishes of nasty Cole slaw, 4 chicken strips and 2 bad fountain drinks.Never again!

Arlene Kirts

2023-06

Dirty place. Selling racist “art” pieces. Fish was rubbery and very greasy. Even the water tasted odd. Like the cups weren’t washed properly. Tiny women’s bathroom and very dirty. Very expensive for an alright service. Drunk people about. Not for us.

Camren Kintz

2023-08

…More

Melanie Slack

2023-05

Nice little hole in the wall! We got the fish and fries lunch special and coleslaw! Batter on fish was yummy, fish was juicy and flaky! Everything was delicious! Cole slaw is the bomb! Great prices and our waitress was very nice!

Christy Mann

2023-05

…More

Jim Zix

2023-05

…More

Paige Kyrrn

2023-05

…More

Terrie A

2024-04

…More

Josh Honderich

2020-05

I haven't been there for some many years, so I was worried about what our experience might be this time. I was more than happy to experience the same great tasting fish I grew up with! That fish took me back to being a kid and eating there!

April Whitaker Merrick

2022-05

Filthy, everything we touched was sticky. Food was over priced, was never offered a refill on our drinks. Fries were cold, the food wasn't worth what we paid. Didn't even ask if we were satisfied with our food. Used to be a really good restaurant. We won't be back!

Curtis Gratz

2023-08

…More

Shay Owsley

2022-05

We waited forever for our food and were the only ones there. Our food finally came out and there was hair in the sampler platter. We were told that it was cheese so they brought it back with it still there. We pulled it out and it was a hair. They took it back and just removed the onion ring. Our food was cold. It was very expensive. Will not be back.

Bonnie Bennett

2020-05

We arrived there a half hour before they opened on Sunday. They told us to come in & they would serve us. Even got the salad bar ready for us.We ordered the 3 piece fish special with choice of potato & salad. It was very delicious

dkrontz

2019-05

The best all you can eat fish anywhere! The fish was amazing with their homeade breading and tartar sauce (If you like tartar sauce). They also have amazing cheese sticks, with a fair amount of 8, for the cheapest price I have seen in quite a while. The waitress was very homely, and the service was overall good aswell.

Dennis Harter

2017-05

Having been told some long time back that the Original Fish of Stroh in Stroh Indiana was closed I had not been in several years. After finding out it was still open I went there for the fish and it was still delicious. The service was also very good and friendly as well. I am sure it will not be nearly as long between future visits. So glad they are still open and serving wonderful food.

Karen Grimes

2019-05

Worst fish I ever had. We arrived around 5:30 PM & not one person in the family room on 6/11/18. Fish was so greasy & over cooked almost un-eatable. Drove from fort wayne & guarantee... we will never go back. Owner's personality was the best part of the experience!

Jason Dove

2022-05

Called to make a reservation. That was a joke, and unnecessary. Ordered 4 all you could eat fish, now I know why the reservation was unnecessary. Disgusting, it was cooked in old grease, so it looked burned, and was soaked all the way threw with grease. Fries were just as bad. Salad was lettuce and cheese, lots of croutons with dressing, coleslaw was sour. This was a Friday night. That should be enough.

Bob S

2018-05

Food is very good. You gotta try the fish dinner. It's excellent! Service is excellent. The staff is friendly and really make you feel important. Like you're part of the family.

Stanley Dobrzynski

2022-05

We had heard of this fish place for years but never got there. Today we did and it was well worth it. The cod fish meal was great and we liked the small town usa atmosphere.

Michele Haber

2023-05

Very small and dumpy looking inside & out. Their original fish is no longer Cod but instead pollack. Their prices are too high. Very disappointing so much that we left without ordering.

Jon Caldwell

2014-05

BEST FISH SANDWICHES EVER!Fresh fish, seasoned perfectly, and AWESOME tartar sauce recipe. I love it!I live on the West side of Indiana, but go out of the way to eat here when I am anywhere near the area.

Chuck Ercolino

2022-05

The best fish in the world! Always fast courteous service. We drive four hours to go here.

Gguy

2022-05

Nice little place, food was Hot and Tasty! They took good care of us too, tried hard to please!

Trudy Webb

2023-05

…More

Rosalie Ercolino

2021-05

Fish was wonderful! Our waitress was very friendly and outgoing! Well worth our almost 2 hour drive.

Dianna Konkle

2020-05

Wayne's been wanting to go here for years as the one that was in Elkhart has been gone for years. Food was great and the waiter was even better, such a sweetheart.

Cheryl Hawkins

2021-05

Very disappointing, batter was not like the original owners. Service was good. Prices were high for what was on your plate. Probably will not go back.