Pic N Save

4 (149)

9135 S Mill Rd, Knightstown, IN 46148

Claim this business

Grocery store

From the business

  • Small business

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Sue Ream

2023-05

There are two grocery options in Knightstown- Pic N Save and Dollar General, and they are across the street from each other. So while you may not find everything you need at either, you can get your basics and a few additional quirky unique items at this Pic N Save. Nestled between the grocery aisles you will find an aisle full of everything from prom dresses to bags of soil. This is also the clearance aisle, and it has a little bit of an eclectic thrift store vibe to it. Another unusual feature of this store is an in-house deli/restaurant where you can pick up pre-made sandwiches, pizza, burgers, and other food options-or buy the ingredients and make it yourself at home. Through the times I have visited this store, I have been entertained by a seasonal decoration space beside the cash register. Sometimes it has mannequins or a little village, but it reminds you of a storefront window but in the store.

Vicki Jones

2024-02

My granddaughter was there today and picked up some no bake cookies. When she got to the counter she noticed mold on them. She explained that she didn't want them because of the mold. One employee spoke to the other employee in their language and looked at her and said nothing. I believe they need to learn English if they want to run a store in our country and don't be selling moldy food

Marie Gail Stratford

2024-01

This is no longer Pic'n'Save and I've taken a star away for the dishonesty of stealing the Google Maps spot. Very unethical!I don't understand what happened here. The store was sold but instead of retaining employees all new employees, so no familiar faces. Also THIS IS NOT A GROCERY STORE OR A CAFE NOW. It is set up like a vape and liquor store and it also has some food. I am surprised that Indian people put that much liquor and smokes in the front of their stores. Perhaps it is a cultural thing, but this community needs a grocery store, which Pic'n'Save was.The workers are very RUDE. In our community, greeting the customer is important. They do not greet customers and will talk in a language I do not know to someone else while ringing me up. It is a struggle to attempt to be kind to these people, although I truly want them to be welcome in my community, when they treat the community people so poorly and took away our grocery store to turn it into a liquor and vape shop. ANY grocery store that is a true grocery store keeps FOOD in front and alcohol to the back of the store. I wouldn't bring young children to the store either as Trojan products are not discreetly placed in aisles but rather displayed in the cases at the cash register. So you will be forced into birds-and-bees conversations with curious 7-year-olds courtesy of My Market.

Bal S

2023-11

Disappointing experience. RUDE employees, I ordered their new menu , but chicken was under cooked, lacked freshness. I wasted my money. The new owner doesn't know how to treat his customers with respect, if you ask them a question they don't reply back , poor customer service.

Scott Stauffer

2024-05

New owners new name , very nice people and you can tell they are trying to make it a nice place

Jami Ferrell

2023-07

I usually like going into this grocery store but today was frustrating enough to write a review. My son placed a to-go order using my car's speaker phone. I heard it all. He was very polite while giving order details, confirming his name for her and said thank you after she told him 30 min for the order. After waiting an additional 20 minutes in the store they placed 2 bags on the counter and told him it was his order. He checked the bag as we drove off and it was wrong.I went in with him to return the food and get a refund since we didn't have more time to wait. At least one other group of people had been given the wrong food as well (not his order) I understand mistakes happen and operating a small business is tough but the lady in charge immediately blamed us by stating for me and everyone else waiting in the long line that my son had hung up on her and she didn't know if she should make the order. They had him pay for the order 20 minutes prior when he paid for another item so I knew that was untrue. 50 minutes wasted from our day and not only was there no apology, we were blamed. It's okay if you mess up but don't blame customers who followed all of your directions. A simple, "I'm sorry" would have gone a long way.

Detre Darlene Smith

2024-01

This is one of my favorite fresh meats they even sale bathroom essentials and clothing

Sharon Crawford

2023-05

Very convenient. Prices are high but you must pay for the convenience I guess. Sometimes I get surprised and it's got good prices on certain items. They deliver now on certain days and times. And I am disabled so they will walk out to the car and get the payment and bring product to me.

Rebecca Addison

2023-11

For many years my family and I have been going to this store and it has always been pleasant and friendly. They have sold it and with that comes changes. Beautiful changes but now when I go in they are not friendly at all and they look at you as if you are the outsider when you are not. The new owners are Indian and I have no problem with that at all!! I have a very dear friend who is Indian and she is a sweetheart. The men in the store now look at you like you are not welcome and I don’t get the feeling at my friends store at all !! She was very kind from the day I met her! So is her family. So at this place why are we the outsiders now? You give the new owners a complement on the changes and they do not give eye contact and say “yeah” not thank you not thanks not I appreciate it just yeah. Rude and I will not go back in the store!!!!

Cassidy Kane

2023-08

This store was good at one point that was years ago. This store has gone way down hill. Rude employees. There’s two good females with brown hair I think both working mornings but the rest are trash.

Lexie Altum

2023-05

I am a home health aid and travel around a bit. Stopped in here for the first time today for a Client. And was greeted by the nicest staff. Ordered fried mushrooms, potato wedges with the best nacho cheese, and a breaded tenderloin. Gretchen the cashier actually recommended the wedges and the cheese and I’m glad she did! Everything was made to order and fresh. I will be coming back for another round. Thanks again for this great experience my first visit! 10/10 will go back again! Also have great deals on literally everything! Check them out on Facebook for the menu!!

K McRoberts

2018-05

I love the food and service is always friendly!

Brandi Drake

2021-05

I had never ate there before but this time our family did, it wasn't what I was expecting but the service is always great and people are always kind. They don't use fryers and don't grill there burgers and don't put barley any topping so it is an interesting taste. Not something I think I will buy again but I will have to try the pizza next time and maybe it will be more for my palette. I might want to add I ordered the Big texas burger, breaded/baked tenderloin, Baked breaded mushrooms and baked fries.

Kathi Glover

2023-05

Male cashier a little rude. Other than that alwaz good service.-----------------------------3-11-23 the male cashier is actually a nice person. He was probably just having off day when we were there.

Rachel Adams

2023-05

I love this little home town market! They have a surprising wide variety of stick. Some items are a little pricy but I prefer supporting local businesses. The deli is phenomenal!!!!! Friendly staff!

Stanley Chambers

2023-11

My chicken was pink ,had it been cooked it would have been good

Kyle Dudley

2023-08

Pic n save is a good place to go and get some really good burgers and Bosco Stix very delicious.

Mike Danco

2023-05

Great little country store! Deli/grocery/grill and pizza too! Great prices and friendly people

Judy Wilemon

2023-05

I love this place it is small town homie great employees good food great food grocery store and little restaurant just really nice really clean I love it

Mark Reece

2023-08

Love this place. Employees always friendly and helpful. It's great to have a hometown small business. Best deli around. Love the cheese choices.

Lisa Roland

2023-05

Best deli around. Where else can you get a sack of 10 hamburgers that are made from fresh ground beef for under $10?Cavaletto's are genuinely good people who care about their customers. Virgil, keep making that great chicken salad!! ☺️

Moe Wright

2023-05

Great staff, and prices are good to pick up a few quick things. The restaurant they have in the inside has great food for wonderful prices.

Patricia Proffitt

2023-05

AWESOME Staff. Fresh deli meats! Awesome pizza deals. Just an awesome little country store that takes me way back. 😊

Billy Fulp

2021-05

This place is absolutely awesome all the staff is awesome great prices on their food everything in the store the restaurant part is just amazing I give it a five stars if I could give it a 10 I would

Billy Mize

2023-05

It has really clean the store up.The people working there are very friendly and helpful.

lilpitt66

2023-05

Won't go back RUDE cold food asked for sauce cups n wanted to charge me extra $$$$dear God no people no... they go w the food.. now I'm going to go somewhere else..

Bobetta Shaw

2024-01

Went to get lunch meat and cheese and couldn't get any one to wait on me. Don't like the feel of the place now. I won't be back.

TheLittleDreadyBoy

2019-05

Witnessed a fine example of waste here by Home City Ice, threw out perfectly good bags of ice because "they were bad". Ice was frozen and very much very cold. Fine example of the wastefulness of our country.

PC Remedies

2022-05

Nice little hometown grocery store that gets more new items in every week. Wonderful and family owned.

Lana White

2022-05

Nice little Country Store and staff had a lot of different things interesting little store. Good prices😊

Opening Hours

Monday 7 AM-8 PM
Tuesday 7 AM-8 PM
Wednesday 7 AM-8 PM
Thursday 7 AM-8 PM
Friday 7 AM-8 PM
Saturday 7 AM-8 PM
Sunday 7 AM-8 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet