Pick Me Pets

4.1 (58)

4850 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203

Claim this business

Pet store

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Kelly Hammond

2017-05

Stopped here on a whim to see if they had feeder mice since it's way closer to home than uncle bills an was pleasantly surprised! Very clean and open, great selection of animals and supplies, knowledgeable and friendly staff. Will be going here from now on for all our pet needs, love supporting small business.

Keisah Higgins

2018-05

I love this place! The staff are family and down to earth. Good fish selection. Theres a great knowledgeable cichlid guy who comes in time to time and has helped me numerous of times.. Their prices are roughly the same as petsmart and other stores, may be a tad higher on a few items, but hey its not a big corporation. I Always come back..

Tana McKinney

2018-05

They are very accommodating, informative, and patient. They are very nice they didn't have frogs my daughter wanted so they ordered them for her. We got geckos but I can't stand jumpy bugs so the worker took all of the crickets out by hand. It really went above and beyond great customer service

April Kleppen

2017-05

I stop in to check this place out they had 4 puppies that was not responding to us even when we touch them they just lay there like they was drugged or something and not one person came up to me and ask if they could help they didn't care . cats running around jumping on top of the snakes tank with only a screen on top. Very dangerous for the cats. It was dirty never going back they but I will have those poor puppies checked on .

Nick Stallsmith

2018-05

Prices aren't the greatest, but they usually arent at small pet stores. Staff was pretty helpful, seemed relatively knowledgeable. Good fish selection and most seemed healthy.

Josh Garnel

2018-05

I've purchased several animals from them! A bearded dragon, two ferrets and a kitten. I'm debating on getting another kitten or cat. Unbelievable friendly people, great prices and great pets!

Terry Dykes

2018-05

Extremely kind and helpful staff! The only place to get good feeder mice. I will be bringing all my business here. Keep up the good work!

Adrian B.

2017-05

Axolotls here are very sick, one had a swollen jaw (infection) and only 1 out of 7 even had its gills. The rest were severely frayed or just plain missing. Despite many discussions with the staff on way to improve the tank and their condition in general, nothing has been done to help these poor helpless animals. Please do no go here!!!!

Greg Luke

2016-05

You get a homey feeling in here. A private owned pet shop with a staff that really cares for these animals. Much better than a major pet shop. Going here from now on!

Elleray Jam

2016-05

I always come here for my pet supplies, the staff is very friendly and the pets are well cared for. I definitely prefer this pet shop to others.

chad boogers

2017-05

i bought a fish it was sick and died within a week and they said my water was bad but my tank has been up and running for years with 20 diffant fish. expensive fish and they are all ok but the one i bought died and they cant do anything about it?????????

Joshua Priddy

2017-05

literally the best pet store i used to volunteer here they have helped me grow more and they have become like a second family to me and we will always be friends so go buy some pets! see you guys in september!

James Lough

2017-05

Love love this place. Very nice staff and always made to feel welcome and let's you take your time and look at all the items and animals.

Fight The Bully!

2019-05

I only came for the fish. Staff was friendly and fish were healthy but don't waste your time going because I think they went out of business. I went two days ago and the building was empty.

Veronica Morales (Awesome Vero)

2017-05

Nice little pet shop. They had more unusual animals than your chain pet store. They had a neat legless lizard.

Riley Procter

2017-05

If you by something and you get home and it doesn't work, they will not replace it. They will accuse you of breaking it. Used to love this place but they screwed me over on the last money I had.

Daniel Pate

2018-05

Perfect takes care of their pets and let's you handle them before purchasing would go there again

Lisa Ritchie

2017-05

I go here all the time and just love it. The staff is friendly and the owner and her mom are the best.πŸ˜ΈπŸ’–πŸΆπŸπŸ€πŸ’πŸ‡πŸ¦πŸ₯🐹🐍🐸🐟🐠🐑🐌🐚

Kingofsilenc

2018-05

Great people, willing to answer any questions, and very knowledgeable on the pets kept here.

Jose Romo

2017-05

Great place, great service, good variaty of pets as wells as supplies.

Darlene Green

2018-05

I LOVE ANIMALS AND CAN'T HAVE A ZOO AND DON'T FEEL PRESSURED TO BUY JUST BECAUSE I LOVE TO LOOK.

David Akers Jr

2018-05

It's small got what u need somethings are pricey some not. great nice People need more stuff Like lay out better

Paul Young

2018-05

Always friendly and helpful. Not like the big box pet stores

kenya jamz

2018-05

I wish this was a real pet store they sale pets that they find on the streets,I don't enjoy giving bad reviews,it should be illegal to sale animals like that.

Kenneth king

2016-05

Very friendly staff very clean pet shop.

Vanessa D

2018-05

Our go to for good quality fish.

Marlin Willis

2018-05

They have some amazing birds.

phoenix queen

2018-05

They did a vary nice job helping answer any questions.

Mark Owen

2018-05

Nice helpful staff. Could use some updating and cleaning.

Devin Martin

2017-05

Really honest and open pet shop.

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet