Pet Supplies Plus Lawrence

4.5 (590)

10625 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46236
(317) 823-2230
petsuppliesplus.com

Claimed
Pet supply store
Pet store
Chain carrying natural & U.S.-made pet supplies, plus services such as grooming & adoption.

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Anthony Taylor

2024-03

The staff at this location of Pet Supplies Plus seemed too busy to offer assistance. I was also almost charged $10 more than I was supposed to be. Had I not caught it and pointed out the item on sale, the young lady would have overcharged me. She also offered no apology.

K C

2024-01

I really like this store and staff. They are always nice and friendly. Been a reward member for over a year and I must say, their deals are fantastic. You are missing out if you don't sign up. I always save something which is more than I can say at Petsmart. Once I discovered Pet Supplies, I stopped shopping there, plus their grooming was horrible and hurt my dog :/ Thanks and keep up the good work. One thing, make sure to clean the floors every night or early morning.

Corey Shelton

2024-05

I love the staff at this store. They’re so kind and helpful!

Danielle Hernandez

2023-12

Good size store. Took my dog for a bath in the self wash station they have. Little disappointed. They only have 2 tubs/ stations to use. One was waist high, which is nice and you won't hurt your back. The other is at floor level. Several people where waiting and I felt rushed. The sprayer was a little difficult but the dryer house was nice and long. Which was nice. Not sure I'd go back there to bath my dog, but definitely to shop.

Asmar Bilal Sr

2021-05

They had what I wanted. New leash. Training collar. It was a bit cheaper here. I had planned on ordering this online but grabbed it at comparable price. And it looks better than the one on ebay. I would have rated this place a 3 but I'm actually pleased so I decided to write a review.Thanks pet supplies plus!

Mark Rumney

2023-05

Love this store. Great staff, always good customer service.The supply of crickets for my bearded dragon almost always available and good supply of mealworms and other treats as well.Nice aquatic selection and have purchased a few additions to my tank here as well.My spoiled dog Noel gets some treats from here as well and we Will be trying out the self bath station soon.

Jennifer Grzanka

2023-09

Staff is helpful. Store is clean and well stocked most of the time. Pet supplies Plus is a little bit more expensive then chewy or Amazon most of the time, but they do price matching, and they're a smaller chain with good stuff available in a pinch. I shop at the one in greenwood usually but recently I've been going to the Lawrence store as it's closer. So far I really like it. The staff is really nice.

April Kimbrough

2024-04

Store was clean I went in mid afternoon wasn’t too busy they were out what I was looking for but I got a great deal by signing up for the rewards program..Self service wash the water was cold along with the dryer part also but overall got in and out not much of a wait seeing that it was a warmer day

Lisa loves the rollers

2022-05

I adopted the most beautiful Calico kitten here. Please if you're interested in a cat, go adopt one. They are rescue kitties. There is an adoption fee but well worth it.

Rob93 Aquatics

2023-11

Store is neat and clean. Always greeted at the door and at least asked two times if, I need help with finding something. The store can be busy or not busy when checking out it's a breeze.

Matt Jewell

2024-03

Store was clean and stocked but no one as at the counter to check people out until someone came back from a smoke break.

Elizabeth Harber

2023-12

I have visited a couple times in the past month and the customer service has been amazing!

Beulah Bricker

2024-03

Nice clean. Well stocked. Helpful staff.

Carmen Armstrong

2023-06

This Pet Supplies Plus has been one of my favorite pet stores in Indiana for a while. They have a HUGE variety of product (including raw food) for a very reasonable price. As a reptile enthusiast, I'd also like to acknowledge that while Pet Supplies care is not necessarily up to the professional standard, it does have the best reptile care I have seen from chain pet stores in this area. Very much recommend, they have great staff, great prices, and for a chain pet store they have decent pet care of their store animals.

DreQ

2023-05

Didn't know they price matched until I got to the register and the clerk said "wow that cart is empty" and I said "yeah I can get cat food for 5 dollars at dollar general instead of paying 10 dollars here for it" and he showed me how to pull up dollar generals price and show him and he matched it and even went 50 cents below the ad price. I love this store and I'm glad that the people are so helpful and that they price match. I'm definitely a returning customer.

James Sternberg

2023-06

I think this place deserves 5 stars but the hrs are getting annoying. The best part of the local place is that when I notice I'm out of dog food I can run down the street and get some. Considering I feed the dogs in the morning and evening this no longer is the case as I have been met by a closed sign with even more restrictive hrs multiple times now. I just ordered my first bag of dog food online from the Big Box place and will probably continue doing so.

CNasty198five

2021-05

Everytime I go there it's hard in my wallet lol but seriously they have a good staff of polite young kids and knowledgeable as well and the peices are cheaper than most other places highly recommend this location

wink hupe

2020-05

Always friendly and helpful. Also very clean and lots of items to choose from . Took dog things back with no questions asked .My Westie always love visiting this store .

Debbie Dehler

2023-05

This is my last trip to this convenient store... because we are moving, and there isn't one near where we are moving. (Boo).The staff is always friendly. Today's cashier could speak more clearly and louder.

Kathie Marcellus

2023-05

I order the night before and my products are delivered after 4pm as I requested the next day! The Lawrence location has great management and staff that goes 100% + everytime! I appreciate this service and always give the delivery person a nice tip!

Max C

2023-06

called to if my order was ready and Sonia was so nice and didn't leave me hanging on phone. I can't wait to go in store shopping next.

Trish t

2024-02

Take advantage of the coupons that they send you. I won't shop there otherwise. They are expensive.

Jennifer Parks

2023-05

The store is always clean and stocked well. The employees are helpful, polite and knowledgeable. I have purchased food, pet carriers, furniture and toys from here with no issues. On the 1 occasion I had to return an interactive toy that my cat was scared of, they refunded me the price with no questions or hassle and it was several weeks later due to health & weather issues.

Hannah Gouker

2023-05

Always has what I need. I often do same-day delivery online and it’s accurate and prompt! I’d recommend. Go visit them too. I like browsing the aisles.

Lisa Sears

2023-05

Always the BEST of service from Pet Supplies Plus.....we just recently had a huge bag of dog food delivered and they did an outstanding job....packaged in a waterproof outer thick wrapper, and the delivery driver placed it super close to our front door. We love their promotional sales as well. A+++

debbie hibler

2023-05

I placed an order yesterday for dog food and it was suppose to be delivered today . I called to follow up on it and they could not answer when I would get it since it was suppose to be today . Manager was so rude and said she might get to me by Monday . She was just plain rude about it . Don’t day it will be delivered and not get to the customer or at least say I am sorry for your inconvenience. Trying to find out when my credit card would be credited and she hung up on me . Just a rude person . I will never do business at this location . I love the Noblesville location . I guess they were not going to call me and let me know I wasn’t even going to get my dog food today . POOR BUSINESS. The customer use to be first but not here

Dale Gwin

2023-05

April 2023New Store Hours!!10a-6p All week.Unsure if this is temporary or permanent.______________Dec. 2022My first time to this store. I had something specific in mind before I went which often ends up disappointing without an open mind. They had exactly what I was seeking. I thought a bit pricey but it was days before Christmas and selections were well shopped.There were other items I found that I thought useful but hadn't set out to purchase. Store was busy and lines at check out but still moved quickly. I will go back when needing speciality items or new treats for my pet that I can't find at big box discount stores.

Mags F (Feverlight)

2022-05

Never had a bad time here. Especially as a surprise frog owner, I learned a lot with these guys at my back, and they're always so willing to help out. If they can't supply/can't help with something, they've never been afraid to recommend someone/somewhere else that would have my answers, and I will continue to go here until the end of days. Thank you so much for all of your patience and help, guys! <3

Michael Hutzler

2018-05

Very helpful and friendly employees every time I visit here. Always leave with the best products for my best friend.

Randall Robinson II

2022-05

No change at all with this company. Still horrible service. Too much time talking when shelves are empty. You either have to buy a tiny bag or a huge bag and don't do the free bag program, it will take several customer complaints to get nothing resolved. But, they are great with creating excuses across the company.The staff were too busy with their own conversation to provide assistance. The register was blocked with dump bins of product. The store was not appealing at all.

Opening Hours

Monday 9 AM-9 PM
Tuesday 9 AM-9 PM
Wednesday 9 AM-9 PM
Thursday 9 AM-9 PM
Friday 9 AM-9 PM
Saturday 9 AM-9 PM
Sunday 10 AM-6 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet