Myers' Market

Summer Grundlock

2024-01

The perfect place to get quality, locally sourced meats. Myers' Market is a small, family owned butcher that offers a variety of meats. Any time I have bought meats from here, I was NOT disappointed. They also offer soups, sandwiches, & sides that you can try out for yourself. In the warmer months, they have cookouts on Thursdays where they showcase some of their products for the community, such as ribeye sandwiches. YUM. I highly recommend giving Myers' Market a visit next time you are looking for some high quality meat or if you're looking to try a new spot for lunch!

Peckster McClain

2024-03

It was amazing. Had half a hoagie and it was the best sandwich I've had. Store staff is very friendly and helpful. Would recommend!! 10/10!!

Christina Richardson

2023-11

Our family loves Myers Market and we will always be customers! Fresh meat, lots of variety, so many items in the store. Too much to list but it's all high quality 💖

Joe Prica

2024-02

Awesome selection of local goods, and the meat selection was amazing, local honey and pottery, love this place we will definitely be back.

Matthew David

2024-04

This place is nasty and the employees are rude and disrespectful and disgusting. I do not recommend coming here. The sandwich had mold on it

Brent Monnin

2024-02

The staff is very friendly and it is an absolutely a great place to shop for fresh meat and snacks. Thank you!

Katie Dale

2023-10

Myers Market catered our wedding in Greencastle this past weekend and we could not have had a better experience! Not only was the food amazing, they were so accommodating, kind, and efficient. Would highly recommend!

Flora Brothers Painting

2023-10

Can't say enough good things about Myers' Market. The meat is top notch, packed with flavor, and very high quality. We also love their Thursday grill outs!

Richard Fisher

2024-04

Awesome place to get the best deli sandwich this side of the Mississippi.

Ricky Albright

2023-06

They have the best meat anywhere and they make individual sandwiches they have it all

Jessie Hoskins

2020-05

High-quality! I love the unique items, like candy and snacks. The sandwiches and soups are always flavorful. The prices are hard to beat for such fresh meat. I also love that the owner is local and gives back to the community. Definitely recommend.

Kathleen Kyle

2019-05

Love this place! Had lunch with family here yesterday and had fried turkey on marble rye with broad ripple chips. Best deli turkey sandwich I’ve eaten. Love the broad ripple chips! Sandwich with pickle, one side and drink is cheaper and healthier than a fast food combo ! Store is very quaint and reminds me of small town country meat market I went to as a kid. Nice variety of fresh meats and stocked with many unique items like apple butter, seasonings etc. Very clean, professional and customer focused environment. They even have a viewing window to watch the butcher. Will definitely be back!

Carylon Smith

2023-05

They have the best soup and sandwiches. And the meats are really good and stks are awesome!!! The people are down home and friendly. I recommend if you haven't been there you need to go. Like family.

Josh Frye

2024-01

Go during lunch for a deli sandwich or just shop a lot of local products. And just about anything from the meat counter will taste great as well. If you want a special kind of cut ask and they might be able to accommodate your request.

Kyle Boehner

2023-05

First time I chose to eat here. Highly recommend to anyone who wants a good deli sandwich. Can't wait to try more options. Can't wait to try the fresh meats. Staff was friendly.

Jeff Miller

2016-05

Fantastic service. Call-ahead ordering, membership rewards, locally sourced goods, and a "hometown" feel are just a few of the things you can expect at Myer's Meat Market. Check their Facebook page for the latest lunch offerings - and keep an eye out for the steak sandwich lunches!Another must-try: fried chicken deli meat. I wouldn't have believed it if I didn't try it myself, but the flavor is absolutely spot-on!

Mike Elmore

2023-08

Bought the Pork belly bites yesterday. Cooked them in the air fryer today. They are super delicious!

Drew Hammond

2023-05

Purveyors & makers of many great things, but without question the finest Brats you'll ever find. Anywhere. Great place & great people, but even if they weren't they'd still get 5 Stars from me for their Brats alone.

M Thomas

2020-05

Thank goodness for Mitch and his integrity!I bought a beef tenderloin to serve for Christmas dinner. Upon opening the pkg at home, the meat smelled odd. I thought it might be the processing and continued to prepare it. But the noxious odor remained. None of my guests could eat it; quite an embarrassing moment. Afterward, I called Mitch who was absolutely apologetic, reimbursed me and followed up with other customers to be sure there were no other complaints.Thank you, Mitch. You run an honest business and I am a grateful, loyal, customer.

Elaine Richard

2021-05

I love this place. Best meat around and prices aren't "break the bank" prices! Everyone is always kind n helpful. I usually send in an order using their friendly app and they always ate quick. Again.. love Myers Market!

Mark Shapard

2019-05

Great Deli close to Depauw. I really enjoy the soups and sandwiches. For am inexpensive, quick, and tasty lunch or dinner, I highly recommend Myers' Market. They also have an awesome selection on locally grown and produced foods, including a large variety of locally roasted coffee in bulk.

Seth Monholand

2018-05

Sandwiched are great and a good deal, totally have to come on a Thursday, for one of their cookout. Also, there are so many great craft food finds. I look forward to doing alot of shopping here.

Derek Chastain

2018-05

Love coming in here for my bacon and coffee! Deli sandwiches are also amazing. Service is excellent and everything is mostly local. Can't find a better stop when coming through Greencastle.

Gregg Schrader

2019-05

No complaints until 7/12/2018. Purchased roast beef and fried chicken deli meats. We noticed a strange off smell when we opened up the refrigerator later that same day. We had roast beef sandwiches the next day for lunch – could not get past the smell and tossed the rest. While making a sliced fried chicken sandwich about three slices into the pile I spotted a hair that did not belong to either of us. Hoping for a better experience with the prime NY strip steaks and pork cutlets in the freezer. Will not return or recommend.

Logan Kuhne

2018-05

Delicious sandwiches, fantastic meats and candies. Their Thursday lunch grill out deserves a spot in your weekly schedule.Nothing fancy--just excellent people, good food and community.

Treva Roussey

2023-05

We love getting our meat here. The jams and sauce selection is nice too. Keep up the great work!

Paula Evans

2018-05

Myers' has a great selection of high quality meats which their butcher cuts daily. They also have Metro Deli meats containing fewer than 5 ingredients which are very tasty and healthier than most deli selections. Farm fresh eggs, milk and yogurt from Traders Point and lots of other Indiana specialty foods and a friendly and very helpful staff make this a great place to shop!

ellen Carter

2023-05

1st time shopping and bought New York strips…..they were a perfect cut and literally melted in your mouth. I will definitely be going again and again.

Emma Tobin

2020-05

Very cute men working there, although the one with long, blonde hair has disappeared lately, which is why it is not a full five stars. Very good sandwiches, great service. Will definitely go back again when I see the blonde one through the window next. #bringbackblondie

Dawn Query

2018-05

Love going here for lunch, quick and easy to order, Mitch and his employees are always nice and polite. Many options of local products and the meat selection and pricing are better than the big chain stores.