Pet Supplies Plus Evansville

Christopher A. Moers

2024-01

I went on the Black Friday sale day - fish were half price. I bought 6 glofish and put them in my 20 gallon hexagon aquarium. They are thriving! I saved $30 and my aquarium is now complete. I've never had to return a dead fish to Pet Supplies Plus. Now there are 14 glofish and they school together.

foose 1

2024-04

One of my favorite things about this store was the self service dog wash, but they more than doubled the cost. Used to be $25 for a card worth 5 washes. Now it's $60?! All I can say is WOW. I just tried Pet Food Center on North Green River Rd and their wash card is $30 for 6 washes. They have a bigger wash room with more stations and have soap and towels just like Pet Supplies Plus does. I'd be happy to come back to Pet Supplies if they brought it back to a reasonable price but until then, Pet Food Center it is.

Sarah Hartman

2023-10

Clean and organized pet supply store, with a wide selection of foods for all animals. I was able to find what I needed quickly and checkout was easy. Prices were expected.

Debi Wilson

2024-04

This small pet supply store was great! They beat the Amazon price on Fromm dog food plus they have a buy 12 get 1 free program on dog food. I found other products on sale for good prices. I will definitely be back.

Branabis

2024-04

The guy who owns this place is evansville's Steve Irwin. You might pay a little more but they have deals all the time and rewards for when you come back. Best store in town for all the pets in your family. :)

Rebecca Morrow

2024-02

This is my first time shopping at Pet Supplies Plus. My whole experience has been amazing. My girls (cats) are on a very specific type food and it's been hard trying to find it and PSP had it! I ordered online and did curbside pickup and it was available in less than an hour.The young lady that came out was incredibly sweet and professional, put the food in my car, and I drove home.Low and behold, there is a little note on my order with a cute joke: Why is a fish easy to weigh? -- Because it has its own scales!10/10 would recommend!

Katie Phillips

2023-12

The staff are all nice but apparently they got new management recently and jacked their dog wash station rates up. It was very affordable at $25 for 5 washes but now it's $60!!! That's an insane increase especially since it's just a self service dog wash. After I finish my wash card will likely be looking at other options in the area.

Debra

2024-04

They were very helpful in the past couple of months and assisted me and my sister greatly in setting up our new exotic fish aquarium 🙂 we are very pleased and we love it!

MysticalHaunts

2024-01

Love going here with my Service Dog she always gets to choose her own treats

Jerrod Eagleson-Realtor

2022-05

This is a great pet supply store! The employees are friendly and knowledgeable. We get all of our pet supplies there. They are always well stocked and their products are reasonable priced. We have bought several fish including a few blue crayfish. This weekend while going to pick up a few supplies for our fish tank, they had a litter of puppies… I knew I was in trouble when they told me they were a boxer/beagle mix… ( a Bogle…) we already had a 3 year old Bogle (Rosie) and she is an amazing dog. Needless to say, now we have two.🤷🏻‍♂️ I think we even forgot what we went in the store to pick up in the first place. 🤦🏻‍♂️ Thank you, Pet Supply Plus!

Darla Crawford

2024-02

Always super knowledgeable, and courteous! Whole store has a great vibe! 😊 Kinda feels like a smallish indie joint, or maybe...a family owned shop! Across the board: top notch!!

Lyndia Cunningham

2023-05

I put in Zeus’s curbside order for dog food today and saw a toy I thought he would like so I purchased it as well. After I submitted my order I got a call from the store saying they were sold out of that particular toy but asked if I wanted to replace it with something. I asked the employee to pick one out for him. I just wanted to tell whoever it was that picked this amazing caterpillar that they did an absolutely fantastic job. You can tell they love what they do and they have a knack for making animals happy 💗

Alexis Phillippe

2024-04

Cleanest pet supply store I've ever been to, a little pricey but the staff is absolutely wonderful!

Jenny of course!

2024-05

Favorite pet store by far. Great selection and wonderful staff

Denise King

2023-12

My experience is always Awesome at Petsmart. I can easily find the things I am looking for. I love looking at the other pets Petsmart has. I love walking thru the store and looking at all the new items on the shelves. I love the Christmas pajamas, they have for my guinea pig Everyone at Petsmart is always nice and friendly, Great Listeners ,very acknowledgable of products, Thank you Petsmart You are the BEST I will always be a customer

Brenda Davis

2024-02

My first visit was at the Evansville store, I was able to get all the things I needed definitely be a repeat customer....very satisfied

Davy Ritchie

2024-03

Great place to buy nutritional pet food or give your dog a bath. The staff is very friendly and helpful.

Britt Reed

2022-05

Pet Supplies Plus goes out of their way for it's customers & their pets. With the unsafe weather conditions today, I wasn't able to get food for my buddies. PSP made sure to deliver the items to me despite their closing and the hazardous roads. We are so grateful!!They are always helpful in store and knowledgeable about their products & animals in general. I love this place. Do your self a favor and check it out! Adding a picture of a full, happy, Beardie. 🖤🖤

jennifer compton

2023-10

Where is Jeff? Nobody greets you or ask if you need help my dog was barking and all I got was stares like he was going to bite, the cashier was the only one that greeted me and ask if I needed help but at that point I was just ready to go. I have not seen a black person work there since they been open. It's definitely not the same without Jeff.

Richard Sutton

2024-04

The manager was rude. Not helpful at all. I will never go there again.

Stephanie Pierce

2023-05

This place is AMAZING! Everyone was super friendly. Jeff was great and let us handle animals and offered assistance for anything we needed. Our kids had a blast.

Neil Mason

2024-01

Love this place. Staff is nice, able to get what i need for my pets.

Shannon Casey

2023-05

This place is amazing. I've bought fish several times. Recently my 10 month old kitten developed a abscess. She's under a vets care but the staff has been so knowledgeable & helpful with supplies. I'll never go anywhere else.

T S

2023-05

Greeted by the most friendly staff, the store was very neat and orderly with a huge selection of pet products. Very impressed and will definitely bring Mr Mojo Brown Sugar Daddy back 😊

Scot Martin

2024-03

They have a wide variety of products and a friendly and knowledgeable staff

Andrew Seib

2023-08

Jeff is the best! It’s rare that you see a business owner go above and beyond for their customers every chance they get. Since my first experience here Jeff and his great team have continued to impress!

Patrick Scheidegger

2023-08

Great selection of dog and cat items, more that I could ever imagine! Very unique and personal dog collars/leashes. A whole section of natural medicine for animals!! ✅ Lots of harnesses. TONS OF TREATS!!! Even fresh baked doggie doughnuts 🍩!!! (healthy of course) Good selection of aquariums, and decent selection of tropical fish. And all looked healthy to me. Small yet adequate section for aquarium filters and chemicals. Chemicals well stocked in every brand. Reptiles, amphibians, and other odd pets have a great selection of accessories. They have GIANT MILLIPEDES the size of hot dogs! And tarantulas. etc. Price was good with items on sale, which I'd estimate was about 1/6 of the entire store. VERY UNIQUE pets and items for pets. VERY NICE and POLITE employees!! Haven't been treated with such respect and good manners in a long time!! Refreshing. Highly recommend!!

Jezediah Skelton

2023-11

Are you a regular customer come in there at least once a week since it is got taken over by corporate or whatever has happened the things I used to get are not available the plants have been taken away which they were about the only place that had a lot of plants so really kind of disappointed I'll probably try to find Dave

Myra Belcher

2023-05

This will always be my favorite pet store, I got my leopard gecko here about three years ago, the owners own reptiles themselves and they're always a huge help when it comes to questions and etc. They have a variety of different animals and I just love going there. Our dog loves their specialty cookies and I personally love the verity of dog clothes, collars, and toys! The staff is always siper helpful and kind!

Yolanda Conner

2023-07

Always work with you from allowing my pup to go early for bath and early for product when I’m stressed on time!! Thank you!!!