Gary's Dam Bait Shop

4.5 (161)

592 W Center Cross St, Edinburgh, IN 46124
(317) 364-6366

Claim this business

Bait shop
Fishing store

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Ezra Scott

2024-03

I own African Clawed frogs and they were doing kind of poorly for a while—they stopped eating the food I’d been feeding them and seemed lethargic. I knew they liked worms but wasn’t regularly feeding them, so I decided to get some Earthworms….they perked right up and they’ve been back to their normal froggy selves! Now when they see me walk by the tank they’ll come up and beg for food. They want more worms! So greatful, I was sure that my frogs were going to die. The worms I get are nightcrawlers and they’re always HUGE worms that are super active every time I open the container. Sometimes they’re so big I have to cut them in half for my frogs. Way cheaper than worms I’ve previously gotten at Walmart and Petsmart, and again, bigger too!

Heather Caldwell

2023-05

I LOVE THIS PLACE. The same cool guy is working each time I’ve been and I didn’t feel like I was there to buy anything, I felt like I had stopped by a friends house. We talked like friends and there was an Amazing atmosphere. I intend to go again for sure. He was also very helpful with lifting my heavy pumpkins since I have a neck injury….. I highly recommend!

Oscar Gamino

2024-04

Friendly and awesome atmosphere, Great hospitality, visiting the area and scouting the rivers and was directed to a couple areas. Super happy awesome, thanks Gary let me know when you’re coming to Wisconsin and I’ll take you to a couple spots for big Kings and walleyes

Heather Allen

2023-05

They have amazing, reasonably priced, fresh vegetables all summer long! Locally grown tomatoes, corn, squash and so much more! I always find better tasting produce here than at the store! They are also very friendly ☺️🤗 Definitely more than just your average bait shop!

Kat Vazquez

2023-05

Best minnows ever! I know that sounds weird but hear me out. I bought some minnows on Saturday on a non-oxygenated $5 bucket they sell. I went fishing and had some left over. I thought, "Let me see if I can keep them alive and go fishing tomorrow." It rained and I didn't go, and the week went on. Today is Thursday and they're still alive! They've been from pleasant weather, through frost warnings, and no food sitting in a bucket outside. It's a clear sign I need to go fishing today. Some of them suckers might get off the hook, get some food and keep on swimming with a new story to tell. LOL

David Griggs

2021-05

This is a great place to just stop and take a min to relax. Sits right next to Edinburgh Dam on the Big Blue River. Has been around my whole life. Nice selection of anything and everything you can imagine and prices are actually very reasonable. The people are very polite and will enjoy taking their time to speak and help you in anyway possible. Again rather you need fishing gear or bait or just simply need time to relax stop by and check out Bobs. Want disappoint!!

Steppin Quillen

2023-07

Great people, very friendly.. love to take kids there to get the classic "bait shop" experiance

Stephen Toles

2023-05

Excellent place to go. Definitely some good ole boys that everytime you walk in the door you feel welcome to be there

Sandy Schultz

2023-09

Cool little bait shop. Besides bait for fishing needsthey sell melons, tomatoes, gourds.. all when in season

Justice Burton

2023-05

My youngest son loves to fish and always finds things here. I buy our cricuts here for our Dragon and camillion and you get more for your money than at pet store.

Debra Shinkle

2021-05

Great Bait Shop ~ Gary the owner is very knowledgeable & FRIENDLY ~ Stop by & see him

R Jay

2023-05

Cool, little baitshop. It's right by the dam. I bought some peaches from there, which were delicious. The dam was a great place to selfish, but I didn't catch anything.

S Ballestero

2018-05

Was looking at the water but grey place to buy your hair to fish.

Shane Lortz

2019-05

Great place been going there since I was a kid with my grandfather and father. They are polite and very helpful. The owner is a great man and makes sure his customers are taken care of. He goes above and beyond.

Heather Johnsen

2017-05

Bob is fantastic!! Despite what google says, his store is NOT permanently closed!! We went in for our first visit, and he was awesome. Found everything we needed and his minnows lasted for over 24 hours! Will only be going here for our bait and tackle from now on.

Zenitha Leonard

2019-05

Has the best hair jigs around! Bait is always fresh! Love the friendly Smile and kind service. Only place we get our bait! Randy and Zenitha Leonard

Don Osak

2019-05

Best bate and prices around cant get minnows anywhere else.friendly and knowledge able people can tell you best placesbto fish and whats bitten. They also have a grate catfish tournament once a year for local fisher men and women to enter from local fisging spots. Good times. grate place

Donald Collins

2022-05

Great place, friendly people, they have everything you need love going there and taking my son brings back alot of memories.

Tonia Atnip

2023-05

I had a good experience there the guy running the place was very informative got some really pretty mums

Eric Titus

2020-05

Great place to buy bait. I also recently had a 45 year old reel repaired and it works like new. So this place offers more than bait. Check it out

Kristi Poff

2023-08

We stop here everytime we go fishing at Driftwood Lake or Atterberry.

Gary Foster

2023-05

I've been there 3or4 times and they have been very friendly and helpful. They are my new bait shop.

Chris May

2023-05

Only place around my area to buy minnows.. Good customer service has some unique stuff

Sue Bunch

2023-05

Owner nice talkative building has bait shop. Got to see the dam and lake behind store.

Nola Gustafson

2023-07

I grew up in Edinburgh this bait shop is the best around

Tim Mitchell

2023-05

Wide variety of baits,excellent location on the river,some fresh local produce in season

Marianne Schell

2022-05

They have very tasty bulk cheese and venison summer sausage that melts in your mouth .

Roy McKinney

2021-05

Real good service when Bob Jesse had it he started to someone else he's one heck of a guy I give it five stars

Joshua Allen

2020-05

Really good prices on bait and tackle. Great customer service!!! I wouldn't go anywhere else.

Billy Mead

2023-05

Good Hometown business great vibe bait good selection great prices good service

Opening Hours

Monday 8 AM-6 PM
Tuesday 8 AM-6 PM
Wednesday 8 AM-6 PM
Thursday 8 AM-6 PM
Friday 8 AM-6 PM
Saturday 8 AM-6 PM
Sunday 8 AM-6 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet