Rentown Country Store

Jeanne L

2023-09

Wonderful grocery/everything store near Nappanee, Indiana. Wondered cheeses, fresh fruit and veggies, fabulous home baked pies, cookies, breads etc. Lots of pans, utensils and anything cooking related. Even a small area of children’s toys and books. Restaurant across the street is yummy too!

Diane McMahan

2024-04

Rentown is a great place to go to get very real farm food! They have everything: lots of meat, cheese, eggs, and hand made products like soaps, lotions, etc. Definitely a good experience!!! And great products!!

William Wherrett

2024-04

Friendly people, excellent products. Baked goods, yummy. Prices on the high side but well worth the cost. If you pay with a credit card, there's an extra fee added. Plenty of excellent parking. We will return soon. One of our favorite places!!

Eduard C Hanganu

2023-05

Awesome store. Wholesale merchandise sale, or small amounts for personal use. We found in the store merchandise that we could not find in other stores at prices more than competitive. Be sure to spend at least an hour or two hours from row to row in order to get all the good stuff!

Local Guide

2023-08

This store is fantastic! They have an excellent selection of cheeses and baked goods--the cheeses are especially cool because they have flavored cheeses (e.g. morel & leek) that are in things like cheddar or muenster. It's not just all havarti, like most places. The prices are reasonable, and they take credit cards. Make sure you eat at the Dutchmaid across the street, too!

Adriana Bentancourt

2024-04

What a wonderful place to visit ! Amazing jams and apple butter lots of items to choose from. A wonderful cultural experience. The staff were extremely kind and informative

maintman1960

2024-03

Great baked goods and more cheese selections than you can imagine.

Curtis BBguy

2024-03

Great place to purchase cheese and some hard to find items. There is an upcharge if you use a card. To save a little bring cash.

janet Dieringer

2022-05

The manager, (Dennis) by far, is the most accommodating and knowledgeable individual I have meet in his field. His suggestions concerning his lawn furniture and services have been, spot on, perfect. It's great to have confidence in someone who genuinely has your interests in mind. Thanks for your services.

Keith Speheger

2023-10

This little Amish Country Store is a must visit. So many fresh grocery items and fresh baked goods that your mouth waters as soon as you step inside. Their prices are very reasonable also

Anthony M

2023-07

Excellent selection of homemade pies and breads. It's basically a general store owned and managed by the Amish with too many farm fresh items to list. The apple pies are right out of the oven and are amazing. We will definitely be returning customers.

Janinemarie Jacoby

2024-02

My husband Dean Redlin and I love this store. It's clean and has good deals and the people that own it are very godly people.

Joe Radican

2018-05

Went there for the baked good while visiting family. The temperature was below zero but business as usual for the friendly staff. Loved the little wagons the let you use to take your groceries to your car. The family loved the homemade cookies.

Deanna Fox

2024-01

Me and my family go there at least once a month and stock up on some great deals 😀

Micah L

2023-08

They have a great cheese selection, but it must be purchased in bulk. No slicing is available. There is also a nice local baked goods selection. The prices are really high unless it is on sale, and then it is really good.

Tim Radford

2023-08

Got a giant box of fresh chicken on a really good deal. They had a good deal on frozen small whole chickens. We always find something else to pick up while we are there plus quality ingredients. Some of the best cottage cheese I've ever had.

Cynthia Coffey

2023-05

I wish I could give more stars 🌟 I just love this place. Got already made baked goods and got flours to make my own. Everything is just so fresh and the employees there are the best. Thank you for such good items and love talking with the employees ❤

Timmy K

2023-12

Love to shop there for some of the best breads and cheeses around.

Caleb Pereau

2023-06

Amish baked goods are the way to go. Everytime we make the trip to Michigan we stop by this place and absolutely load our basket as full as our arms can carry. They are always so polite and everything is obviously baked with love and no hate in there hearts whatsoever. It's a gem

Jenni Greene

2023-12

Love everything ❤ about this store...but I do have a ? If they take snap

Brooke Casselman

2023-11

The food is GREAT and the people and so nice. Well DEFINITELY be coming back👍👍👍!!

Alexander Reinhardt

2023-08

Cool Amish store, they have a wide range of products including some local items. The highlight is the cheese selection and specials, you can't find much better prices for the quality you get.

Marilyn Zabinski

2023-12

Always find the many different kinds of cheese that you do not find in any other store.

Michael Mattern

2023-08

I always enjoy shopping here because I know the cheeses and meats are fresher than the grocery stores. The people are friendly and respectful of everyone, and the prices are very reasonable.

Jay Earl

2019-05

First time visit. A conveniently located but country setting near both Bremen and Nappanee. I highly recommend coming and shopping at the store next door. An inn attached would really do well! Thank you

Christine Swanson

2023-05

This is one of our favorite stops on our get-away from the house days (30 miles for us). We love taking this country drive. Renowned Country Store is a favorite as it offers a wide selection of meats, cheeses, bakery, pantry, toys and cutlery goods with fairer prices than chain groceries. They keep it clean and well-stocked and provide good customer service. My husband LOVES their bakery selections, ALL of them ... so yummy!

Kristen Kubit

2023-11

Love going here for great food and prices, everything is always so fresh

Dustin Milton

2023-11

I love the fresh breads and desserts!! The restaurant here is delicious as well!!

Cindy Claeys

2023-05

Love shopping at this store. The ladies are awesome. Everyone is very friendly and accommodating.I always find what I’m looking for especially things that I can’t find in our grocery stores.I’m anxiously awaiting to get their peaches that usually come in July.

Tracy Roahrig

2021-05

Love this place! The cinnamon rolls are amazing. Cookies are very good too!! They have a big assortment of bulk candy, dried fruit, seasonings, and baking needs. Not to mention the assortment of cheese. This is where I go when I want to treat myself with baked goods cause with my busy life I dont have much time for baking anymore.