Cavataio's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Nicholas Jackson

2024-04

I would like to give them a higher rating to be honest. The only problem is they let different cooks use their own recipes. It can lead to them offering something on the menu and the chef not knowing how to cook the dish.Years ago I took my children's mother there on a date night after not having an opportunity to spend any time together; and after ordering one of her favorite dishes pasta con broccoli and receiving something that was obviously not that type a pasta but something but something that was made by somebody that did't know what it was, I had to deal with her being upset and console her because she was looking forward to the meal. It wasn't long after that we both learned how to cook it.It's definitely true that the smallest thing can change your taste pretty drastically when it comes to the white sauce.I plan on visiting there soon and hopefully finding something positive to say in an update of this review m

Chris Henderson

2019-05

Coming from Bethalto where Roma's pizza is King, I was absolutely happy with their pizza, service was fantastic, and the salad bar was nice. Would definitely recommend, the friend chicken was very good as well. An all you can eat salad bar and home made soups will make your day !!

Adam Favre

2024-03

…More

Jennifer Sullivan

2024-04

…More

Connie Theriac

2023-11

The waitress was absolutely wonderful. However, our party ordered 2 Chicago styles, the buffalo chicken didn't have the buffalo or ranch sauce on it as advertised on the menu. This was made right by not charging for this pizza. The other was sausage and mushroom. They did not put any cheese on it and corrected the error by providing a container of cheese to take home with the pizza, after we requested some cheese to take with it. The two regular crust pizzas we ordered were great. Like I said, the waitress was wonderful. The issues we had came from the kitchen.

Fred Hoover

2024-04

…More

Annette Korunka

2024-04

…More

Storme Hannan

2023-05

Passing thru on a road trip and found this gem of an Italian restaurant. Salad bar and soup were amazing and the gnocchi is amazing!!!

sonya Hansel

2024-03

…More

Karen Rutherford

2021-05

We love pizza hot and fresh. The employee was super nice. But the elder people was not just looking like what is black people doing in this restaurant

AJ Darneal

2024-01

…More

Melissa Meske

2023-09

…More

Brian Voyles

2023-07

…More

Kriz Gentry

2023-11

Food is bland... Burgers are always over cooked and the desserts are frozen only thing fresh in that place is the noodles

kathleen Vitalis

2023-09

…More

Cathy Periandri

2021-05

Very friendly staff. Delicious salad and pizza. Thankful they are open again for indoor dining!

Katrina Edge

2023-09

…More

Calley Mize

2023-09

…More

Robin Booth

2023-08

…More

Rick Allen

2024-02

…More

Pennilyn Cloud

2023-05

Love love love this place. Best place to eat in Staunton. The staff are so friendly, and the owners make sure everyone knows they’re welcome and appreciated. My family and I especially love Ms. Cathy’s scratch-made soups on the amazing salad bar, but my go-to is their spaghetti.. the meatballs are delicious.

Dan Lesko (TheoryCraft)

2023-05

My favorite place for pizza in Staunton. Vince and his family are just fantastic people. Great restaurant for a family outing or just having lunch with a few friends. Great salad bar, if greens are your jam. Vinni's special is my wife and my go to pizza. And whatever you do, don't pass on the formaggio sticks, as they are a must for an appetizer. Just a great place all around

William Castillo

2023-05

Home town family restaurant. There are downsides to the place, but this has been family owned and operated and is almost a landmark if the community. The restaurant always gives back to the community and participates in local events. Food is good 99% of the time. Service is always aceptional. If traveling through, definitely worth the stop. If local, always a sold choice for dinner.

Stephanie Pieper

2021-05

We drive over 45 minutes for this pizza! It is so tasty, and the family that owns the place is amazing. During the pandemic, they supplied lunch to kids in need for free. That is a business I can stand behind fully. Not only that, but the pizza is absolutely delicious, the cheese sticks are fantastic, and the roast beef sandwich rivals many that I have had on The Hill. It is truly great food.

Robert Hursey

2023-09

Tracy from Mississippi Culture Brewing recommended and it did not disappoint. Katie our server was excellent.

Justin Jones

2020-05

Best Italian pizza I've had in a long time. The cross was consistently crispy all the way through and not burnt. You can tell that you high Quality Meats and real cheese. And the staff was beyond helpful and friendly.

Chris Garcia

2023-05

We've been going here for years and the taste is amazing. The owners are very involved with their community. My favorite pizza place.

Aubree Cloninger

2023-05

EXCELLENT PIZZA!! This has got to be the best pizza I’ve ever had! I can’t wait to try the other food 🤤🤤🤤

Ryan Isaacs

2013-05

Stopped here while passing through the area. Cheese garlic bread was good, but the meat sauce that came with it on the side tasted like Chef Boyardee sauce, but my wife liked it. The pizza was very good and tasted fresh! Service was also very friendly. Would definitely recommend this place and will stop there again.

Carl D

2017-05

The wings are awesome!!! As well as reasonably priced. There is one sauce, buffalo, and it is spot on. The lasagna is wonderful. I punish my diet once a month by traveling 40 miles to this location, eating an order of wings and a serving of lasagna. Then I waddle back home and sleep for two days. This is one of my Top 5 restaurants.