Cimino's Pizza

Vanessa Wishard

2024-04

…More

bill p

2023-07

My family loved the food. I wasn't busy when we dined in, and we received great service. Jimmy bread sticks were good and came out quick. We got a veggie pizza with standard crust and a pepperoni double decker pizza. Both were great. They use a super high quality cheese, very stretchy.

Dawn Stahl (Dawn McIlvain Stahl)

2019-05

An Italian restaurant and pizzeria with an extensive menu, charming atmosphere, excellent service, a separate and well-stocked bar, and my all-time favorite pizza. Every item that comes out looks and smells delicious and seems to satisfy the person who ordered it, but we've literally only ever had the pan pizza — we've driven hours to get it before. It has an overall garlicky savoriness that I love, a thick and flavorful crust, an abundance of high-quality cheese, and a price that can't be beat.

Paula Stanbury

2024-04

…More

Jerry

2024-02

The waitress was not in her game . Not sure what was going on . As she was the only waitress there they had 3-4 bus girls standing around . Our drinks were not correct . We received somebody else’s order for My wife’s drink all I ordered was anmy wife’s drink all I ordered was a soda, and I had to go up and receive that myself at the counter Our food sat in the window for 15mins . The only person that new what was going on was the bartender on the other side He apologize . we paid for our salad in our drinks and we left. If they keep business up like this, they will be closing the doors.

Amanda Fuller

2023-05

…More

Beck Schulte

2024-02

Tried to order from the Pec location since it says they are open til 1am but no one ever answered the phone. If you aren't actually open til 1am then I would have ordered food from somewhere else before they closed.

Michael T Wallin

2024-04

…More

Samm Smith

2023-05

I placed an order for pick up.. when I got home I realized one of the pizzas was incorrect. They were quick to remake it and had even offered to deliver it. Thank you!!

Eva Doubleday

2024-05

…More

Bert Schweinler

2024-03

…More

K P

2023-05

Just moved to Pec from another state and was anxious to try the pizza, even though a neighbor said it was awful and greasy. We order a meat lover's pan pizza and specifically ask for it to be baked well done, because we don't like pizza that is soft and everything falls off when you pick it up. We were shocked at how deep this pizza was, because where we're from, they're not prepared this way. I will say that was, hands down, the best pizza I have ever had. I took pictures of it and sent it to family members to see because it was soooooo good. We anxiously and excitedly ordered another one the next week and had been talking about our excitement to have another, and it was terrible. We had to put it in the oven for at least 10 more minutes because it didn't seem ready. The next month when family came down they really wanted to try it, so we ordered another and it was great! They also said it was the best pizza they'd ever had and wanted to have it again the next night, so we ordered it again. As before, this one was TERRIBLE and we had to put it back in the oven for 15 more minutes. They kept saying that they couldn't believe it was the same pizza we'd eaten just the night before. So here I am again giving it another try and the same situation of it not seeming like it was ready and me specifically requesting that the pizza is baked to well done. The pizza is good but the inconsistencies are horrible and what seems to be consistent.

Nicole Santana

2023-06

Cimino’s (all their locations really) have always been promising. Never been disappointed by their food. Called in an order last night, I was placed on hold to tally the total and he returned to inform me that one of the meals comes with a salad and asked which dresses but after picking the food up and getting home there was no salad. I didn’t care because I didn’t specifically order one just though it was odd for them to specifically bring it up and then forget about it.

Mike Heitzman

2023-08

…More

Sheena Dobbs

2023-05

…More

Ruth Madden

2023-06

…More

Steven Druien

2024-02

…More

Edward Rook

2023-05

Comfortable family atmosphere, but sadly lacking in service and quality of food. Most of the entrees you would want from an Italian restaurant have been adulterated with American cheese and canned sauce, and taste about as good as a frozen dinner. The salad dressing was not chef made but rather a baggie like you would get with a McDonalds salad. The lasagna was mush due to bad preparation or possibly being reheated too many times. The rolls taste like they come from a premade box of frozen dough. The pizza crust is so tough and chewy I don't even make my children finish their slices.Don't come here expecting authentic Italian cuisine. Nobody Italian is running this chain restaurant at this point, the chefs are not creating the food from scratch. This is the Happy Wok of Italian food, though luckily for them they are not facing any competition within a 20 minute drive.The waitress did not come to check on us during our meal and I had to get up four times to ask her for various things because she was simply standing around by the kitchen instead of coming around periodically.The staff and public call the restaurant "sim-een-oes" rather than according to the true Italian pronunciation "chim-een-oes" which further proves that a true dyed-in-the-wool Italian has ceased to operate these establishments and long ago stopped upholding the great Italian heritage that the restaurant name originated from.To feel better I am trying to imagine that someone at this restaurant will decide it needs a Gordon Ramsey style makeover so Pecatonica can enjoy good quality, authentic Italian food.

Marie Duggan

2024-01

…More

William Caldwell (Wildoe)

2019-05

My wife and I stopped in on our anniversary for a late dinner. The food as usual was great but the waitress we had that night really set the place apart from any other time. They stayed open late so we could enjoy our time together and take our time with our meals! We WILL be going back!

cindi nystrom

2020-05

First time customers,, went at 5:30 on a Friday night,,, not super busy,, ordered a large everything pizza and it was like warm and have had better frozen pizza. Service was good,,we will try again for something else. Prices comparable.

Scott Morgan

2023-05

Ordered take out told us 20 to 25 min to pick it up. It took 45 min stood at counter for 20 min. Philly beef was good tho.

Brad Kerr

2023-06

…More

Stacey Nolan

2022-05

…More

Peggy Grow

2018-05

We've been enjoying Cimino's restaurant since it 1st opened !!! They have the BEST pizza....we drive over 20 miles for the experience. The homemade bread I would love to have the recipe for. Tonight's salmon was delicious!!! Highly recommend this restaurant.

Aaron Fulrath

2017-05

Pizza done right! Pizza dough is fresh unlike Winnebago biz with same name. Lasagna is top notch! Been here several times and never disappointed and prices are low for quality of food and portions.

Shawn T

2023-05

Excellent Italian food and deep dish pizza. Full bar with dining area,very clean and comfortable atmosphere.Parking: Parking on street as well as a moderate sized lot to just west of the building.Kid-friendliness: Very family friendly environment.Wheelchair accessibility: Plenty of room for mobility with walker/wheelchair. No ramps or steps to get inside.

Shari Ritter

2018-05

We were on our way home from Chicago and thought this little town would have a great local restaurant! We stopped and asked a couple of locals on the street, they recommended Cimino's. Beth was absolutely amazing and the food was just as good! Great prices too!!

Jennifer Fedorev

2018-05

I am a regular customer who has ordered delivery, usually on Friday nights for the past 4-5 years. Last night I placed an order at 723pm and as usual, gave my phone number- repeated it, and credit card info, she repeated the card info correctly (I was surprised as the background noise was loud). At 915 after waiting a very long time (as usual) I called to question the status of the order and was told, well, your card didn't go through (which makes no sense) and I asked why I wasn't contacted, she replied that the number was incorrect, I asked what phone number was used and they said they "used a number off of their caller ID". She then said if we reordered again they would get it out to us very soon. We were hungry and it was late, I gave the same card info, etc and it went through. We then received our food at 1030pm and paid FULL price. NEVER AGAIN!!!!!

w fegg

2023-05

Very good chicken parmigiana. Was very hot which was nice. Exceptional service. Great they were not very busy