The Tin Cup

Rodney Groff

2022-05

Went with a large group, we had reservations. They had it all set up for us by time we got there. We all sat down and they took our orders. The service was great, there were two waitresses taking care of us and they got our food out very quickly, I was very impressed. I had walleye, deep fried, with slaw and baked beans. The The walleye was fresh and flaky and tender, 3 large pieces for $11. The baked beans were about like most baked beans in restaurants, not much more than pork and beans out of a can, but they did have some smoky flavor, reminded me of Bushes baked beans out of the can. The slaw was cream based slaw, not my favorite and it was a little too creamy, but not bad. The tartar sauce was not much more than Miracle Whip with a little bit of sweet relish. My wife ordered lemon pepper catfish, grilled. It was very tasty and flaky she also had Baked potato and a side salad which was nothing more than a bowl of lettuce with a little cup of dice tomatoes, not much. Overall we all had fun and everyone said what they ordered was good.

Jami Smith

2023-05

If you leave hungry, it's on you. Very reasonably priced, the food was outstanding and the server was very polite.

Amy Ohms

2023-10

Very casual. Food is equivalent to homemade, nothing spectacular though. Good food but not out of this world . Service was attentive and fast but not outwardly friendly. Nice for a quick homestyle dinner at decent prices but not for all the hype it's given.(It's a local favorite, I'm sure, more for the nostalgia and patron loyalty of a family owned and run than for its fair)

Matt May

2024-02

…More

Bruno Biava

2022-05

I have been to the Tin Cup many times before and I have never been disappointed... and I recommend the Walleye dinner as well as the Catfish...also on Thursdays they have a Taco Salad Special that's worth the Trip, too... servings are generous and well worth any wait you might have to endure before you are waited on and served.Today I had Catfish with French Fries and Coleslaw... and as usual it was Divine... the breading the Tin Cup uses on their Walleye and Catfish complements the oh-so-delicate flavor of the fish and doesn't overpower it with Spices. The French Fries were Seasoned just right and the Coleslaw was Creamy and Crisp.😁Aaaaahhhhhhh....If I can offer any advice, it would be that you should understand that besides being the only sit-down restaurant in the little town of Noble, it is a very popular gathering place for family members and friends from outside the area, and sometimes they get a little overwhelmed by all the business that comes through their doors.... Some things are definitely worth the wait... and a meal from the Tin Cup in Noble is one of them.(One time, I came in during a Rush... and while I was waiting, a lady came in with a young girl for Ice Cream... and remarked about how good it is and how she sometimes got a gallon to take home... this reminded me of Roger Taylor, the one time Manager of the Prairie Farms Creamery in Olney... and prompted me to include the Tin Cup in my List 'From Here I Can Go Home'.)

Megan Klier

2023-11

…More

ruth negele

2022-05

Great fish, had tenderloin sandwich which was really good and huge . Friendly staff

Heather Greenwood

2023-10

…More

the flying potato

2023-07

…More

Jean Duffield

2023-08

A friend and I stopped in for lunch while we were in Nobel. We both had the special which was fried chicken. It came with mashed potatoes, gravy and the vegetable of the day which happened to be corn. It was very good. My only criticism is that the gravy was brown gravy. To me, when you serve mashed potatoes and gravy with chicken, the gravy should be white.

Dwayne Knox

2023-09

…More

skylar frank

2023-05

Best place around for breakfast. My wife kids and I make a trip once a week. Good company. Great service. Great food. Check it out and they won't disappoint.

robin Marriott

2022-05

Very good! We had a party of 18 and food was hot, fresh and fast! We were in and out in an hour. PLUS... not everyone had the specials! We had individual orders divided! Waitresses were awesome. We will be back!

Marcella Evans

2023-05

Great value, their breaded tenderloin is as big as the plate and the mountain of fries comes in a basket on the side, drink is included. Friendly and fast service. Absolutely Beautiful

Sergio Martinez

2023-05

The food was good, the service was good, there was parking, the price was good. The place looked meh and that's why it gets four stars. If the place got remodeled it would easily get 5 stars. It has been some time since I been there, so maybe they have.Parking: It has parking in front and in the back with entrance in front and in the back of the restaurant.

Sarah Arnold

2023-10

…More

Deborah Hanson

2020-05

Great catfish dinner. Friendly staff

Matthew Painter

2022-05

…More

don redman

2023-05

Excellent food help and take home waitress on call. They dont even mind if your married engaged significant other... They only have one stipulation!!!$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ . Thats all watch thier charm ypur checkbook all electronics that habe any type of sensitive information. Check out these games playtinka spinx and see what they are all really about . Anyways great food and a awesome owner Kevin!!

Monty Shupe

2022-05

…More

donnie keller

2023-06

I must disagree with your 4.5 star rating. Why? Well because Kevin and the girls at the Tin Cup easily deserve a solid ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ hands down.

Aaron Thomas

2023-11

…More

Ed Brumley

2018-05

A small town cafe worth the exit off of US50 into downtown Noble. Simple and so worth it. The food is incredible, generous and not expensive. Best fried chicken, meatloaf, cat fish, walleye fish for miles around. The service is great too!

Michael Anderson

2019-05

One of our favorite hide aways. Resturant is small & always busy but service is fast & excellent. Big servings & very affordable. Amazing how small restaurant in small town be so great. Super fried fish & BBQ pork steak. Must give it a try.

Kurt Mowrer

2023-05

Our favorite breakfast place when we visit the area. Friendly service, GREAT food and prices that don't deflate your billfold. Comfortable and clean environment.

heather cates

2021-05

Place is a little run down and not very clean.Not much to choose from. I ordered shrimp not very good. Not for sure what happened to this place.. haven't ate here in quit a few years. Use to be really nice won't be going back

Lee White

2023-10

…More

Richard Tucker

2017-05

The best bbq ribs I have ever eaten. Tender enough to fall off the bone. Portions were plenty. Excellent value.Wife had walleye platter, which was excellent.Highly recommend this restaurant.

S CAMPBELL

2019-05

Fish sandwich was not done and slimy in the middle. My server was borderline rude and needed to listen and put phone down. Very disappointed due to everyone saying it was great. My first and last visit glad it only cost 13$ yes for a fish sandwich and drink that I couldn't eat.

Paul Mcgill

2019-05

They were short staffed but we were told that when we ordered. So there was a little bit of a wait and it was worth it. The food was a little different than what I can find where I live and it was excellent. Well worth the wait. I will be back the next time I pass through Carlyle.