Casey's

Jessica

2023-07

Clean store front, with friendly staff. Yummy quick food to grab at any time during the day. No cigarette butts all over the place, no gum wads every where, no litter all over the parking lot. Nice place to go!

Rachel V

2021-05

We love this Casey's location. The store and restrooms are always clean and the staff are friendly. We also very much appreciate that Casey's keeps the air pumps free. On our most recent visit, our daughter received a treat bag just for coming in. It made her day and it was a very nice gesture on the part of the employees.

D.R. Rocco

2019-05

I've ordered my last pizza from this place. As a rule, pizza from Casey's is pretty good. This particular Casey's, in Homer, just can't get it right. In the last year, I've probably ordered 8 pizzas from them. Every single one has crust so thin and under-cooked that I can't even pick it up to eat it. I have to hold my whole plate up to my mouth and slide the pizza off the plate directly into my mouth. Tonight, I ordered a pizza with tomato on it. I came with exactly 10 pieces of tomato on it. That's not an estimate or exaggeration. It had 10 pieces of tomato on it. For the first time, I called to complain about a pizza from this store. To their credit, they offered to remake it without any hassle. This time, they got an appropriate amount of tomato on the pizza but the crust is still paper thin and doughy. Gross.I'm done throwing my money away on pizza at the Homer Casey's. Next time, I'll try the store in Sidney. Hopefully, I'll have better luck there. If not, I guess I'll just be done with Casey's pizza for good.

Tiffany Bernard

2020-05

I placed an order online around 720, it said 25 minutes.. okay no biggee since I live about 15 mins away. So I waited til about 735 to show up. My pizza wasn’t even started and the person working was not busy at all. So I opted to stay and wait for my pizza. At 747 I went back in to check the progress and was told it would be another 10 minutes. So now I’ve sat in my car for over 30 minutes and it’s been 50 minutes since placing my order. I also asked for well done so I’m sure it will take longer than the ten minutes. To their credit I was given 2 two liters of pop for free, but that hardly makes up for my gas or waiting over an hour to eat once I actually get it. Next time I’ll be going to one of the other Casey’s in the area.

christy P

2020-05

Such friendly staff! Great food options! I swear I would starve if it wasn’t for this place! Such smiling faces and nice people! I order pizza from here all the time and it always tastes amazing!!! You can’t go wrong with Casey’s pizza!

Justin Gentry

2021-05

People are always nice. Great service and extremely convient to my location. I never pay to air up my tire if its low and most places are at 1.50$. Thank you Caseys

K SNIDE

2017-05

Stopped for quick snack before heading to Bowling Green. Nice to know all stores have same quality far from home !

Tammy Cordes

2022-05

…More

James Wilson

2021-05

THEY CARE AND HELP ANY BODY AND SO KIND AND ALWAYS FRIEND THERE FOR YOU

Joanne Meyers

2020-05

Nice clean store with friendly staff

Tammy Butler

2023-05

Good

Michael Wagner

2021-05

Cleaned and fast polite service

carol strube

2018-05

Great pizza and people

Bob Klein

2021-05

Great pizza!!!

Richard Wagle

2021-05

L

Jonas Baumann

2017-05

Already