Casey's

3.8 (56)

837 N College Ave, Geneseo, IL 61254
(309) 603-0664
caseys.com

Claimed
Pizza delivery
Convenience store
Gas station
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods.

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Matthew Summers

2024-01

Placed an order for a tenderloin and a grilled chicken salad was told I would receive it in thirty to forty five minutes. It took a little over a hour and a half for me to receive my order. Don’t recommend delivery. When the delivery person Patricia arrived. I asked what happened and She turned around walked away saying with an attitude. I’m pretty sure that why the manager gave you a free soda. Very rude slow delivery

Samantha Thornburg

2023-05

Ordered some delivery pizza last night (11/3/22), they were out of the popcorn chicken side, called me and offered to swap it out for chicken strips (which cost more) at no added cost! Then the driver accidentally forgot my redbulls with my order, which I was gonna eat and then head up there and grab them but she was back with the redbulls, without a call placed, before I even finished eating! No place is perfect, but you become perfect with how you handle your imperfections. I would say this Casey's has got it figured out! Keep up the good work guys!

Nichole Klinge

2018-05

Called to order pizza for delivery. We were having a pool party for our church group. Ordered 6 pizzas and was told it would be 1 hour. We called at 6:50 and the pizzas didn't arrive until after 9pm. No apology let alone offer to compensate us for our wait. On the plus side the pizzas were hot and did taste good. Very disappointed though, some of our guests left hungry.

Judy VanDeWoestyne

2021-05

Last time I'll order pizza from this location. Not only is this the second time they've been more than 30 minutes past the estimated delivery time, no one is answering the phone. I have tried 3 times to check to see if there was a misunderstanding, like maybe they thought I was going to pick it up. I just hope this doesn't mean they are being robbed or the store is on fire or something else.

Connor McSparin

2022-05

People ordering DoorDash at this specific location beware, they do not prepare food according to time posted & are not customer friendly. (Lori- Supervior I believe/Benjamn- Cook, super unfriendly)

Liz Lively

2021-05

Extremely Rude, Don't like wanting service and get screamed at What, because your to busy tell the other standing around your nightly date plans, then have to come back in just to be treated badly and getting told don't come back after telling her you give horrible service,your not wearing your mask as your own stores policy states right now. Will never go back in there.

Seth Rusk

2021-05

Stop through this casey's just about every morning. Some days the hot food is better then others depending on who's cooking.. Stopped in this morning and not one thing was in the warmers for breakfast!! Step it up!

Elizabeth Maynard

2021-05

This place is ok. Seems like they never have there side cooler filled, and the pizza warmer has old pizza in the warmer Everytime I go in there.

BassPitt9191

2021-05

Gas is 3.25, for the most watered down gasoline in the states they sure put a pretty price on it, bp is 3.09, go there and your vehicle will last 10x longer for 10x cheaper

RES JR.

2023-05

Be prepared to wait a minimum of a half hour after the time they give you. That's if they bother picking up the phone to take your order.

Cartoon Hub

2020-05

You guys aren't a hometown store. Your a chain of gas stations in this area and more across the country. I like the guy who works the night shifts tho keep on rockin’ man.

Gregg McCarty Sr

2023-05

Friendly staff, food is good & a nice quick shop in town

Kyle Bess

2019-05

Always amazing service. Love the breakfast pizza!

J.D. Walck

2021-05

I've always had good friendly service here. Stop on the way to work every week or so.

Luke Clendenin

2018-05

Never had an issue pizza always good.

Kristi Johnson

2021-05

They have good food and their clean place

Andrew Wagner

2018-05

Wonderful store, wonderful people, and even a really good burger.

Christine

2018-05

Absolutely love their breakfast pizza!

Claire Crawford

2019-05

Delicious pizza! Friendly people!

Levi Neumann

2020-05

They let me use the bathroom

Jay Moore

2021-05

Pizza is always good.

Redneck andtheCrew

2021-05

Mess up orders constantly

Andrew ryan

2021-05

Poor delivery service

Mary Johnson

2021-05

Just stopped for gas

Christina Folker

2021-05

Awesome pizza

Marje Shedlosky

2021-05

Best pizza

T tsholt

2021-05

Good pizza

Pete Hill

2021-05

Lots of choices

David Holderman

2021-05

Great place

Opening Hours

Monday 4 AM-10 PM
Tuesday 4 AM-10 PM
Wednesday 4 AM-10 PM
Thursday 4 AM-10 PM
Friday 4 AM-10 PM
Saturday 4 AM-10 PM
Sunday 4 AM-10 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet