Lilly's Sweet Shop

4.9 (37)

499 Wabash Ave, Carthage, IL 62321
(217) 357-0009
facebook.com

Claim this business

Ice cream shop

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Trevor J. Sandidge

2018-05

No trip to Carthage of mine is completed without a trip to Lilly's. The frozen yogurt is always amazing, but the service is even better! Not to mention, all proceeds go to a great cause. Highly Recommended!

Bonnie Obrien

2019-05

Wonderful. Finally a frozen yogurt closet to me. I live in NE Missouri and I cannot eat ice cream anymore but can eat frozen yogurt. I had the salted Caramel and it was delicious. I ho look e they stay in business forever.

J P

2019-05

Drop-Dead-Amazing Fudge! Huge variety of flavors, and very true to their names. Really enjoyed the Raspberry Swirl and Cherry Nut, and my wine-loving friends thought the Merlot delectable. Had a great holiday deal where if you buy a pound of fudge, you get a half pound free, for under twelve dollars total- six quarter pound fudge pieces. Worth it.

Thorsten Robrecht

2019-05

The very best frozen Yogurt of the middle west. A perfect service and super nice and clean shop. My full 5 stars - the best reason to make a stop over in Carthage

Chukwuebuka Ogwo

2019-05

Amazing.. . beautiful and amazing. The vanilla/strawberry frozen yogurt was the out of this world. The fudge was also fantastic. Excellent desert , beautiful environment and outstanding service. Well done Lilly's

Richard Salgado

2019-05

Total find. Just visiting Carthage and thought it looked fun. Just exactly the sort of unique local treasure you hope to find on a trip. Great yogurt and environment.

The Red Door Collections

2019-05

My wife and I were in town visiting our kids. We dropped by to get some treats and were blessed by the sweet couple that own the place. Cute establishment, good treats, and GREAT SERVICE!

Kaitlynn Michelle

2019-05

The best frozen yogurt I’ve ever had! The owner is so friendly too.

Nick Swartz

2019-05

Love it, wish it was open all year! Great yogurt! Great place for the kids to play. Friendly staff!!!!

Jeff Bair

2019-05

A fun little shop with great fudge-ice cream-frozen yogurt and toppings galore.

Kelly Davison

2020-05

The owners are amazing and the yogurts and desserts are beyond amazing.

Billie Harrison

2019-05

Its a great place to get yogurt and its a great bunch of people that run it

gavin mimi

2019-05

Our 1st time there. Very good. A lot of activities for kids, too.

Alín Martínez

2018-05

It's always a delicious and healthy option for a fresh dessert

Matt Dickinson

2019-05

No better place for winding down the day with delicious sweets!

Connie Schulz

2019-05

Yogert is yummy and fudge is delicious!

Brother O'Brien

2020-05

They give your dog free yogurt!!

Jared Weeks

2019-05

Great home town frozen yogurt

Joseph Aanenson

2018-05

This place is fantastic! the service is wonderful, and the people are super friendly!!

Keith yex

2019-05

New Mango . YUMMY

Esbozando MisTus

2018-05

Lovely!

Mary Wood

2018-05

Delicious and fun place

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 4-9 PM
Wednesday 4-9 PM
Thursday 4-9 PM
Friday 4-9 PM
Saturday 4-9 PM
Sunday 4-9 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet