Dave Matheny - State Farm Insurance Agent

Shirley Sargent

2024-02

I’ve been with State Farm for 3 years. The staff is very friendly, knowledgeable and professional. I am pleased that I chose to go with Dave Matheny, State Farm insurance agency.

Bryan Overturf

2023-11

Dave Matheny State Farm is 100%, for their Customers and work diligently to get the Best policies at the Best rated, and Lisa Ackerman is the utmost Professional and Friendly agent, one could hope forGod Bless ya's Abundantly

Deb Respondek

2023-05

I have been with State Farm agent Dave Matheny (and retired agent Mr Poshard before him) for over 40 years. Dave & his office team are the VERY BEST! Over the years, they have provided us policies for all of our vehicles, life insurance, renters insurance and home owners insurance. They are extremely efficient, incredibly helpful and friendly, and very competitive on prices. We've only had a few claims during this time (storm damage to the roofs of our home & garage, and a few vehicle mishaps). They were very prompt and professional in handling everything. They take the load and worry off our shoulders and give us peace of mind. I feel blessed in knowing them. 👍

Kim Gwaltney

2023-12

Sooooo Appreciate how the Ladies of State Farm are there for us.TRULY - their office is next to ours & .... THEY ARE A GOOD NEIGHBOR!Kim

Betty Talley

2024-02

Has always answered any question. Took care of our damage to our motorcoach in a timely manner and always friendly personal.

Amy Emery

2023-05

We have had several Insurance companies in the span of our lives and this is by far the best we have ever had! The ladies in Dave Matheny's office go above and beyond to help their clients out. We couldn't be more happy with the services that we receive from this office. Everyone is super helpful and beyond nice to work with!

Kristen Smiddie

2023-05

The staff is very helpful. They are willing to discuss all the options we have. Having 2 teenage drivers they helped us figure out the coverage we needed. After a large ding to the side of my car, they helped navigate the process of getting the repair and in a timely manner.

Brad Irvin

2023-05

I have been insured by State Farm for almost 20 years with homeowners, life and auto insurance with Dave Matheny as my agent. I get the best coverage possible, never have to worry about anything anytime. The drive safe app has saved me almost $200.00 a year on my auto insurance alone. I can pay my bill over the phone which is so nice and super convenient. If I have any questions, it's just a phone call away. State Farm offers coverage that most other companies have never even heard of as far as my home and property is concerned. I am so pleased with the service I have.

Christie Matthews

2023-05

Always able to get a staff member on the phone or by email to take care of our needs. They are knowledgeable and upbeat and courteous to help you out. I never have any issues. Also, Dave and his office go the extra mile with information that you might not think of asking. It's nice to have customer service still in an age that is going fully electronic.

Melanie Allyn

2023-05

There is always someone there to have a real conversation with, and Dave had longevity with those employees. Every person there can offer solutions to individual issues. Everyone is friendly and very professional. I plan to continue doing business with them.

John Camacho

2024-02

Moved to the area 2yeare ago, and have been extremely happy with the service the staff has done. Explaining all questions I've had. Highly recommend

Renea Fields

2023-05

Dave and his entire office are so efficient, friendly and helpful! Amanda is phenomenal at her job. If you're looking for great people to service your insurance needs, I highly recommend Dave Matheny and his staff.

eightofnine

2023-05

I have been with this agency for a while and I have no complaints about any of the people who work there. I love having them handle my insurance policies and feel like they are just a phone call away. I highly recommend them.

Barbara Stallman

2023-05

They are always friendly and courtesy people. I have had insurance with Dave for a very long time. I recommend them to all of my friends and family

Lockye Drone

2024-02

Best insurance agency! Helpful friendly, and accommodating!

Russell Kaser

2019-05

Dave and his staff have been very professional, helpful and kind since the first day I walked into their office upon moving to Carmi. They thoughtfully listen and take the time to follow up to ensure satisfaction. All of my interactions have been quick, friendly and easy. I would strongly recommend them for your insurance needs. And they have wonderful dogs which of course makes them just super!

susan thomas

2023-05

Every time I need help they are always there for me. They always have an answer for me. This is the best State Farm office, Dave has a great bunch of ladies working with him and they are the best thank you for all you do.

Colby Rogers

2023-05

Amanda was very helpful and very nice each time I called. She helped with everything I asked and directed me to someone right away. Tammy was also very helpful and sent me a list very quick.

Jana Thompson

2021-05

My husband and I have been with Dave's office for over 20 years. If you are looking for an agent and staff that will support and help you with all your insurance needs then look no further. Amanda Dixon is a gem. She is Dave's office manager and one of the hardest working people there. If she doesn't know the answer she won't stop until she finds it for you. Besides being hard working, she also has a sense of humor and you can hear the smile in her voice when she talks to you. If you aren't insured at Dave's office call now and ask for Amanda!!!

David Scroggins

2023-05

Dave and his team have helped us through some tough times. The staff especially Lisa feel like friends when we call into the office and they always help. Dave and his team have made us State farm lifers. Insurance is expensive but it doesn't have to be miserable. We love our hometown State farm crew.

Fay Brown

2024-04

The staff are very friendly and take very good care of their customers. I recommend this office too anyone needing insurance.Fay Brown

Sarah wilson

2023-11

The best experience I’ve ever had with insurance was switching to this office! The lovely ladies in the office were so informative, patient and understanding, I’ve ever had the pleasure of doing business with! HIGHLY recommend!!!

Ryan Shepard

2023-05

Dave and his employees don't just treat you like another client; they make you feel like you are part of a family. You can tell that they are genuinely happy to help and see that your needs are taken care of. My family has been doing business with Dave for as long as I can remember, and that will definitely continue.

Vallerie Horner

2023-05

Always helpful, friendly, business feels appreciated. All question answered professionally,but friendly. Office staff always helpful, and with computer things as well. We are a team that works together to help with needs and concern.

Joseph Burnett

2021-05

I have been a customer with this office for close to 20 years. They have always been upfront and personal with any needs I may have, not to mention beyond competitive as far as rates are concerned. I would recommend this office to anyone and for extra kudos Amanda is a State Farm Wizard.

Gwendolyn McKay

2021-05

At Dave Matheny- State Farm, the employees are always so nice and caring. They’re always doing their job and more to make sure that each customer is satisfied and helped properly. I wouldn’t want to go anywhere else when it comes to my insurance or finances!!

Angela Sullivan

2023-05

Ladies in office are nice but the insurance part is terrible. 500 deductible that I don't have as a single mom and no car for at least 3 weeks. As a mom I am now stranded with 3 kids and it was an act of God a deer. Even though no fault of my own i have to now find a way to come up with this money and no car to do so.

Tammie Tesh

2023-07

I’ve been with this agent since 2005. Homeowners, multivehicle , golf cart, motorcycles. They have been nothing but great! Just wonderful to deal with ❤️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Jenny Inglis

2023-05

I discussed a change needed for our car insurance with Amanda. She accessed our account info and made the change quick and easy!

Traci Brinkley

2021-05

Dave Matheny’s staff is always helpful and professional. After my sons wreck they took care of everything, they made the whole process easy and stress free. I can’t say enough about this entire office staff.