3.7 (63)
5256 IL-140, Bethalto, IL 62010
(618) 377-1134
caseys.com
Service options
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Abigail Cox
2024-02
I frequent caseys, but tonight I am blown away by the help I was offered tonight. My vehicle wasn't starting before I could leave. An employee by the name of Nathaniel stopped his work and came out to help me start my car so I could get home. I am so thankful. I admire all the employees at this establishment. Everytime I go in, I have a humble interaction with the employees, not just a appreciated purchase. You can't pay a price on good relationships and great morals. Thank you! Also Nathaniel helped me on one of the coldest nights we've had.
Kayla Merritt
2023-08
We ordered a taco pizza and the pizza is supposed to come with lettuce, tomato, refied beans and salsa which it did not. All I got was sausage cheese and a couple of crumbs of Doritos. This is not the first but the second time this has happened to me. We try to call them to let them know they completely messed up the pizza but over 40 minutes of them not answering the phone is just too much.
Shonna Stanton
2021-05
Store was clean, the cashier told us everything we needed and where to find it without us even asking and even showed me how to use the flavor soda machineThanks so much great servive
Kim uhles
2023-05
Our pizza is normal good, tonight it was terrible. It wasn't cooked all the way, the toppings wasn't even warm. For 36.00 I expect it to be way better !!It will be a longtime before we go back!!
Cathi FAM Journey
2022-05
Manager Dorothy is the best! She knows all of the regular customers names and is super nice. Clean store with nice clean restrooms. Has 🍕, sub sandwiches (like the other sub shops), freshly made cookies and their doughnuts are awesome especially the raspberry flips lol! My choice for soft serve rather going into town.
Tabetha Williams
2023-06
You can never order anything unless doing so online. Because they simply don't answer there phone EVER!! IVE CALLED MULTIPLE TIME MULTIPLE DIFFERENT DAYS doesn't matter they just don't answer.
Brett Ahring
2018-05
Pizza is almost always not on time that is stated over the phone. Very bad kitchen management. It's a shame as my kids love their pizza. Great pizza just have to wait at this store sometimes as much as 45 minutes over the time quoted over the phone. Need some managing help!!
George Salmon
2023-05
They don't have slushy no more and lemon aid is broke so I stop going there they don't have nothing I want no more I will drive extra 2 to 3 mile to get what I can drink cause they can't keep nothing I want!!!!
Fred Gowin
2021-05
The pizza at Casey's has a crust with a bakery flavor to it. It's really unique, and nice when you want something that's not too thin and not too thick.
Free Karma
2020-05
Delivery was closed, Pizza Pickup is open and Manuel in the kitchen did a great job. Cookies are good as well. Karma (swoosh)
Molly Cares
2023-10
This store never answers their phone. And the website doesn't tell what the special is.
Dawn Marsh
2021-05
Most of the staff there is nice. The food is always awesome! The cashier robyn is super sweet and very helpful.
Candrice Mann
2021-05
Friendly and helpful staff, store is always clean. Love their supreme pizza.
Payson Porter
2022-05
Look, I know gas station pizza is sort of a meme at this point, but this is actual quality stuff. Highly recommended if you want cheap pizza.
Dacra couch
2021-05
Didn't have ingredients for one of the chicken pizzas. Ordered a supreme instead.
Jason Baker
2018-05
Love this Caseys! Clean, friendly staff, never had to wait for our order, not a single bad experience.
Barbara Davidson
2017-05
Love their coffee and fruit bowls. Convenient location. Friendly employees.
Steve H
2019-05
I dont know why anyone would pay more. Just go down the street and save 20% or more every day Casey's prices are getting stupid
Kyle Langenstein
2020-05
This particular Casey's NEVER has receipt paper at the gas pumps. EVER.
Mary Downing
2023-05
Most gas pumps not working with credit cards
Whitney Dyckman
2024-02
BEST GAS EVER đź’Żđź’Żđź’Ż
Johnny Cline
2021-05
For myself it's the pizza place some really good pizza
Stephen Duffy
2021-05
Great food fair prices
Chris Vandehey
2017-05
Their pizza is a gift from the God's.
Sue Kennedy
2020-05
Good prices, clean restrooms
Craig Carnes
2018-05
Food is always good.
Mary Parkhurst
2020-05
Good service nice employees
Mark Wolff
2021-05
Always GREAT PIZZA!!
Amber Thompson
2021-05
Great customer service
Leslie Dealey
2021-05
Was great pizza
| Monday | 4 AM-12 AM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 4 AM-12 AM |
| Wednesday | 4 AM-12 AM |
| Thursday | 4 AM-12 AM |
| Friday | 4 AM-12 AM |
| Saturday | 4 AM-12 AM |
| Sunday | 4 AM-12 AM |
Scan the QR code to leave a review.
Powered by bulkqrcodegenerator.com
Pet Stores in the USA
Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.
Broswe by Population