Rexburg Cakes

Rachel morrow

2023-08

I called last minute on a Friday night for a cake for my daughter Saturday night. The owner was so sweet and kind and made me the most exquisite cake I HAVE EVER seen! I told her my daughter liked phantom of the opera and to use her best judgment and artistic ability and boy did she deliver. Recommend 100% and to Top it off the cake was divinely delicious! Thank you Rexburg Cakes!

Julie Webster

2023-08

I have purchased three cakes from Rexburg Cakes for three separate occasions. Each cake turned out stunningly beautiful! Constance is super talented, creative, and wonderful to work with!

Kimleelynn *

2023-06

We ordered our wedding cake from this amazing business. I have followed her on Facebook for many years and saw that she offers gluten free cake and her designs fit exactly what we were looking for. I was so excited that she could fit us in her schedule! Our cake turned out wonderful, thanks to her! It was incredibly delishious, the flavors were amazing and the cake itself was moist and not crumbly at all. We went with the Gluten-Free Vanilla Sugar Cookie with the triple berry jam filling for borh of our layers. We are so grateful for all her effort in making our gluten free wedding cake for us to enjoy. My husband said that if he didn't know it was gluten free, he wouldn't have questioned it. Top notch quality and taste. She was great to work with and so friendly. I will definitely keep her in mind if we need any other yummy gluten free cakes or cupcakes.

Patty Unruh Parkinson

2022-05

Rexburg Cakes did an awesome job on the cakes and cupcakes for my daughter's wedding. Besides being professional in the delivery and set up, everything was so delicious! They went above and beyond on one of the hottest days of the year, making the bride and groom so happy! The guests were equally pleased! The cupcakes and cake were not only beautiful, they were delicious. They were not overly sweet, like a children's cupcake, but made for an adult's taste. We provided the flowers and because the poor flowers had been in the heat of the day I worried they would not look good.. I was wrong!! Rexburg Cakes went through the flowers and decorated with what was available making sure everthing was just right.. When the bride saw the set up, she gasped with delight.. It. Was. Perfect! Thank you for making my daughter even happier on an already happy day!

lavinia osai

2022-05

‼️What I Wanted VS what I GOT‼️✨Paid $110.25 Marble cake, Cookies and Cream Filling, Gold drop sides, and chocolate covered Strawberries✨ It’s supposed to feed 12 people.I FB msg the owner and sent a photo of the cake I wanted and told her I wanted it just like the photo I sent her. Unfortunately, she doesn’t do alcohol props or logos but she said, I can put whatever on my cake when I pick it up. We then spoke on the phone to clarify my order and details. I asked her if the mini patròn bottles will be able to fit. I told her the measurements and she said, it will be fine.Upon arrival, I didn’t know the cake shop was at her home. We get there and she presents the cake and asked, “was this want you wanted?”. I told her not really because the mini patrol bottles would not fit on the cake and I noticed the cake was not what I asked for. The gold covered strawberries were replaced by Ferrero Rocher Chocolate (High allergic to peanuts), the strawberries looked like it was rushed, the frosting was not smooth, and the fishing swirls are clumped and squished together. The owner said, the bottles wouldn’t fit because it’s a 6inch cake. I told her, I wish I would have known that when we spoke but I guess it will do. She smiled and said, “thank you, have a great day, bye”, and closed the door.Over all, cake it’s self was mainly chocolate, taste good, moist, cookies and cream was was NOT Oreo cookies and cream, it was super thick and chunky Oreos that was smashed and mixed, and strawberries were nasty!!! 4 out of 10 strawberries were rotten🤮🤢 I’m embarrassed!!

Kris D.

2020-05

My husband and I had an amazing experience last August with Rexburg Cakes and with Constance, the lady who owns it. We were able to do a cake test to see what we liked for fillings, frostings, and cake flavors. We decided on a 2 tier, semi-naked lemon cake with raspberry filling for our wedding cake and a lemon- raspberry Texas sheet cake for the guests at our reception. We were not disappointed! I showed Constance a picture of what we wanted, got her the flowers & succulent, and she put it all together for us. Would highly recommend Rexburg Cakes to anyone looking for a beautiful, professional, and delicious job done on their cake for a reasonable price.

Jana Arbon

2023-05

Absolutely loved the cake that Constance made for my parent’s 66th wedding anniversary. I gave her a picture of their wedding cake and she recreated it, even down to the vintage bells.Constance is amazingly talented!! If you need a cake, for any occasion, head to Rexburg Cakes.

Kyla W

2023-05

Super impressed with the cake we ordered for my wedding. It was delicious and very very beautiful. I am allergic to all nuts and was super impressed at the level of commitment that went into making sure we had nothing with nuts. Communication was amazing and overall I am so impressed with everything. I most definitely will be ordering from them again.

Erin LeFevre

2021-05

The wedding cake we ordered turned out absolutely beautiful! It was exactly what we wanted. I was surprised at how moist and delicious the cake was, although I shouldn't have been. Constance is the best cake baker/decorator/artist in Idaho. She's a true professional, and went above and beyond what we expected. She took the flowers we provided, that were unfortunately wilted and sad-looking, and expertly (and safely) arranged them on the cake so beautifully that I couldn't believe they were the same flowers. We were so happy with our cake, and we did not let a single bite go wasted. I would recommend Constance and Rexburg Cakes to anyone looking for the highest-quality cake experience.

J W

2023-12

…More

Andrea Blanco

2024-02

…More

Erin Pullman

2023-05

I ordered a large and detailed cake and I was not disappointed. It came out beautiful AND delicious!! If you’re considering ordering from Rexburg Cakes, just do it, you will be happy you did. Moist and decadent! Not to mention, an absolute pleasure to work with!!

Nathan Nielsen

2023-08

Rexburg Cakes is amazing!! The cake made looks exactly like the picture I sent. The cake was very moist and it tasted so good! It was also a very big cake! If you need a cake made, go to Rexburg Cakes!

Madi

2023-10

Rexburg cakes did the cake and 9 dozen cupcakes for my wedding. They were absolutely stunning! They also tasted delicious!! She was so easy to communicate with. Overall excellent experience.

Dale Connally

2023-05

Flew in for a men's flyfishing retreat. At last minute, I ordered a birthday cake for one of my guys. Rexburg Cakes served us above and beyond expectations making Bob (and his wife back home) very happy. Highly recommend!

Julie Runyon

2023-05

Bride wanted an Aspen cake with their initials “carved” in the bark…. Beautiful day, beautiful cake…delicious, and the bride and groom, as well as the guests, loved it! (That tilt of the top tier in the second picture was our fault, not Rexburg cakes!!)

Gary Asper

2021-05

Great cake. Needed a cake for Valentine's Day since it is my wife's birthday also. So, I procrastinated again...and needed a cake the same day (the day before Valentine's Day). Rexburg's Cakes made a cake for me in 2 hours and the primary requirement was that it TASTE good. It tasted wonderful. It was the chocolate fudge cake with oreo cream filling. Sooooo good. Thanks so much.

Madison Houdek

2022-05

Highly recommend ordering a cake from Rexburg Cakes for any occasion! They were so nice and easy to work with. The cake was beautiful and soooooo delicious!!

e Brooke

2023-06

We started our Rexburg Cake adventure a week ago for my daughters birthday! We ordered a birthday, number-cake; in red velvet, with Oreo cream cheese filling, and cream cheese frosting. The cake was topped with flowers and chocolate dipped strawberries and cookies! It was exquisite! We ordered a new cake this week for my son’s birthday a 10” round chocolate fudge, with Oreo and chocolate buttercream. If you want a cake THIS is your dream place!They delivered to my kids apartments and sent me photos of them with their cakes!!!I recommend 100%, this is the place to cake your celebration!!!!

Alicen Kanzler

2022-05

I am absolutely blown away at how fast the service was for a last minute order! I called the day before the party needing a miracle and she politely took my order and guided me through the process in ordering exactly what I wanted. I could not have asked for a better result! I recommend this business 110%! The cake had great flavor as well.

Jeymi Proffitt

2023-05

Amazing Amazing Amazing! Thank you for the AWESOME pizza cake delivered to my brother. He loved it!! We will definitely be ordering from you again!

Steffany Faldmo

2023-07

LOVED her cannolis! I grew up in South Jersey where cannolis are a STAPLE and these were AMAZING and AUTHENTIC. I hope she makes more - I'm a fan!

Kellen Cook

2023-10

For regular desserts, they are soo expensive- more than double the price of great harvest or other bakeries I’ve been to. Not sure about the wedding cakes, but their zucchini huckleberry loaf bread (same size as a banana bread) is $25 a loaf for example!

Shannon Sibley

2021-05

I called Rexburg Cakes 2 weeks before my wedding in a panic because the previous plan we had was not going to work out. Constance was great to work with and assured me she would be able to do it. When the cake arrived it brought tears to my eyes! It was exactly what I wanted! It was beautiful! All of my guests were stating that this was the best cake they had ever had. (Chocolate Cake with Turtle filling) Rexburg Cakes went above and beyond my expectations. I am forever grateful and I will indeed use them again ❤️ Thank you ❤️

Valerie Lloyd

2021-05

Rexburg cakes brings elegance and professionalism to any event! Their creations taste as good as they look! Award winning artist and baker, Constance listens to her customers! She is attentive to their ideas and makes sure they will be happy with her finished product! Her recipes are delicious and absolutely decadent! If you have allergies or dietary restrictions she will accommodate them! She is our family’s favorite choice for weddings birthdays and special occasions! 💜

Kathleen Davis

2021-05

We love Rexburg Cakes!! I have ordered many cakes from Constance, and she never ceases to amaze me!! Her cakes are moist and delicious, and her talent for decorating is amazing. She is definitely our go to “cake lady” (as my kids like to call her)! You won’t be disappointed in choosing Rexburg Cakes.

DalKee Walker

2020-05

If I could give more than 5 stars I would. Constance has done our wedding cake and cakes for several parties and events for us since we first used her on our wedding day. Her cake is amazingly delicious. She has the perfect amount of options for flavors, fillings, and style. Constance cares deeply about her customers and does her best with every order, the one time we had a complaint she handled it very well and resolved the issue. Her cakes are beautiful, tasty, unique, and fun. I highly recommend Rexburg Cakes to anyone who is unfortunate enough to have not tried it yet!

Jami Himes-Jacobs

2022-05

I highly recommend Rexburg Cakes for anyone looking for a professional, creative, and detailed cake that also tastes amazing! Constance worked with me long distance for two months leading up to my event.The concept for my cake came pretty quickly to Constance, which is indicative of just how creative and talented she; and the execution was perfect. She didn’t miss a detail. Her cake was the hit of the party! Can’t recommend this bakery enough!

Amanda Walton

2021-05

Rexburg Cakes is phenomenal! Constance is a creative genius who will for sure make your dreams come to life! I’ve ordered cakes, cupcakes and chocolate dipped strawberries and I have never had any complaints!The taste is exceptional. The service can’t be beat!Do yourself a favor and order now!

James Hedrick

2023-10

This was an awesome experience for our son as he had his first birthday away at college. Thank you so much! They were so easy to work with, even long distance. I would recommend them to anyone.