Seaside Sweets

Jasmine Shaughnessy

2023-10

This place is so clean and smells so good. They even stayed open so we could get some sweets. Everything was delicious . Small friendly shop . Definitely worth a visit if you're in tybee island . See you next time we come down to Georgia. Thank you .

Tosha Howard

2024-04

…More

Tristan

2024-04

…More

Tim B.

2023-09

I found this place while in search for gelato, it did not rise to the occasion unfortunately, so don't expect great gelato, it's satisfactory. The slushy lemonade was very sweet , however give the ice time to melt and it's great. The service was outstanding. As mentioned in a few reviews this is a small and I can confirm it's snug.Raspberry Chocolate Chip Gelato and Lemonade Slushy.

Yvonne Cano

2023-05

I can not even begin to express the professional experience and what this meant for our event. God is good and I am absolutely glad that we chose Seaside to host our event! You won’t regret using them for your event! ❤️🙏🏼

Cortney Ayers

2021-05

They had just opened for the season so options were limited (end of Feb ‘21). The ladies were nice and they had a variety of things (candy, sweets) aside from the gelato. The gelato was delicious - we had three different flavors and all were excellent.

Island

2023-09

My favorite chocolate ice cream i ever tasted. I haven’t been in awhile but I used to live across street. I’m going back this weekend. I do wish there sizes were bigger even if they had to raise price to justify because back in the day i used to get two lattes from here lol. Maybe they have increased sizes. Maybe I’m just a pigBut either way it’s worth it.

Kelly Yam.

2023-07

The VERY BEST ice cream on the island!Butter Brown gives the Pup Cup 5 stars

Kailey Case

2023-05

They must not give out free samples because they know how bad their ice cream tastes.I was interested in the fudge brownie and asked what was in it. I was told fudge, chocolate ice cream and brownie pieces. It tasted like coffee. I had 2 other people try it to make sure I wasn’t crazy. My sister got the Cookie Monster which had an off taste to it…almost tasted like soap. We threw it away and did not eat anymore than what we tried.The young man working was nice. We did not share with him our disappointment in the ice cream as I believe no refunds were available.So I share this to 1) inform the owner; I strongly suggest you start offering samples and re-evaluate your flavoring.And 2) to warn people to not waste your money here.I am bummed that I am unable to recommend a local place over a chain. This time Ben and Jerry’s won. They got my money, a happy customer and a returning customer.

Demetrius Q. Russell, MS-HRM, CPC

2021-05

The kid working acted like he didn't care or even want to be there... The ice cream taste freezer burnt and this was way over priced ice cream... THIS IS NOT THE PLACE TO GO FOR ICE CREAM IN TYBEE ISLAND.This is a pic of a $4 cup of ice cream before I took the three bites needed to empty it.

Veleka Fernandez

2023-05

I went here 2 days in a row. The 1st time I went I got a frozen lemonade before I went to the beach. It was very good and reasonably priced. The 2nd time I went I got a frozen blended coffee and 1scoop of superman ice cream. Both were delicious. I was greeted both times and the customer service was excellent. Most definitely recommend when on Tybee Island. Also they serve donuts in the morning and sell various candies and treats.

Christopher Perkins

2017-05

They were giving out some warm fresh glazed pecans at the front door, but don't serve them that way. I'd suggest that this should be something they offer rather than the ones that are already bagged and cooled. Other than that, great place for a guilty pleasure rush of sugar.

Dorrenna Mullins

2023-09

Really good ice cream. Reasonably priced for beachfront. Cute, kid friendly atmosphere. Really sweet young lady served us.

Brian Smith

2022-05

My family and I stopped by to get a cold treat before we hit the road, and the ice cream was great. They have some crazy flavors. I got the Spiderman ice cream and it was great! The staff was very friendly and down to earth. Definitely would recommend a stop here!

Greg Schechter

2023-07

Don't go here. They're thieves. I paid with a credit card. They use square and didn't show me the screen where I would put in a tip. But moments later I got an email receipt with a 25% tip on it. They are stealing from their customers. Stay away.

Ryley Lee

2022-05

Delicious in-store made ice cream! The owner was really friendly and gave my significant other and myself a free gummy starfish on our ice creams. They have all sorts of other candy in the store too, not just ice cream. Highly recommend if your sweet tooth is going off while you're in Tybee!

David Todd

2022-05

Good ice cream, small shop, and friendly service. Just a short walk from Tybee pier, my wife and I stopped here. My wife got a gelato cone and I had a milkshake. Basic flavors plus some local flavors. Any flavor ice cream can be made into a milkshake at your request. Everything was quite good and the young staff were helpful. Total was $14.

Samantha Young

2022-05

Very "sweet" owner and staff both times my family stopped in. Everyone loved their flavor choices! The ice cream was not as firm as I expected, and one daughter got a little drippy, but the friendliness and fast service made up for it!

Michael Ballew

2022-05

Stopped by this spot with my oldest one today for a couple of cones and some cups of ice cream to take back to the condo. Cookies and Cream in a waffle cone was great! A little pricy but you're at the beach at a very centrally located spot. Service was great.

Jessica Maddox

2022-05

Pretty good ice cream and gelato. Wish the store space was bigger as it’s cramped even with just a few people inside. They had about 16 different flavors total.We tried the birthday cake and vanilla ice cream. Would recommend both and they can make any flavor into a milkshake! Also tried the bourbon ginger snap gelato - also good! You can taste the bourbon but it’s not overwhelming at all.We also tried the praline and peanut butter chocolate fudge. Those I wouldn’t recommend - they weren’t bad just not anything to brag about. Seemed like they may have been in the case for awhile.

Sarah Ridenhour

2021-05

We were not super impressed. We went around 7 one night and they were out of most things which seems to be a theme on the south end. My husband got two scoops and I got a frozen hot chocolate. Both just ok. We really felt bad for the girl working. It was still so busy and she was working alone, scooping ice cream and checking everyone out. She was still friendly so kudos to her.

Grace G

2019-05

Visited on 4/24 after lunch. The gelato was good but the service was awful. The young man behind the counter acted like he wanted to be anywhere but there. We got two scoop cups and he didn't tell us we could have chosen two different flavors. On 4/26 we went to Peaches and Cream on River Street and had a much better experience.

Joykrystyna Mance

2023-10

Their online hours show them open until 10pm on Sunday. Went before 9:30pm, and they were already closed. Need to update their hours.

Anthony

2020-05

Ice cream quality seems pretty good. However this ship suffers from multiple issues. Their Oreo shake is not consistent with any other shops definition of cookies and cream shakes. It is more accurately a cookies and cream icy. Which is fine, however misleading when labeled cookies and cream shake.I personally very much enjoyed the bourvon Carmel flavor, I would recommend this flavor.I was purchasing a large quantity of ice cream and I was not given a options of lids for the ice cream I ordered. This makes traveling with the ice cream particularly impossible. Add on that they do not carry a drink holder to make transporting multiple milk shakes easierTL;DR they seem to do desserts well, however they seem to do everything else wrong. They mislabel their products, they do not carry the essentials when it comes to transporting their product. If you order and taste their ice creams and will be eating it right away, you will have a great experience here, however I can not igonre the massive inconvenience and short sightedness of their practice when giving them a little overall rating.

Melissa Febus

2019-05

Great little ice cream (gelato) place. :) The service was amazing. The young man there really understands children. He was very patient and kind. The ice cream is super rich and creamy. I got a single scoop and could barely finish it all.

William Richardson

2016-05

Great ice cream. Very rich, great unique flavors. Last spring when we visited Tybee I had a scoop of "mounds" ice cream, coconut ice cream with chocolate chunks (yes i remember the flavor, it was that good). I was disappointed that they didn't have that flavor when I came back this year but banana ice cream w pralines made up for it. Really, really good.

Jared Jones

2023-05

We had fresh donuts here a couple of mornings and they were great! Friendly staff and pet friendly. They have a nice selection of candy and have coffee, but I highly recommend the donuts!

Regina Donkers

2023-05

Gelato! Butter pecan and Chocolate pecan turtle with a frozen lemonade!!!

Ashley Cloud

2019-05

Was staying at a nearby hotel and was craving ice cream. I saw on the facebook page that it was National Ice Cream Day so we decided to give this place a try. I was expecting a small baby scoop for free. However I got a cake cone and 2 scoops. This was the best chocolate ice cream I've had & would definitely return when we go back to Tybee!

Zac Seidel

2023-07

Great customer service. Very friendly and happy. The Gelato is great with many flavors.