Payfair Supermarket

JSK Watersports Florida Keys

2024-04

Premium steaks for the grill. It’s worth the extra money! Boars head subs with deli meat sliced to order. Steaks and subs are the best here. Closes at 7pm which is tough in summer time with sunset not til 8:30pm. Much more convenient to stop here for beer than the 7/11

Jeremy Aguirre

2024-01

Local Keys No-Frills Grocery Store..you can get most everything needed to cook and eat without long supermarket lines or having to spend 30 minutes perusing the isles.The staff is Friendly.

Janice Smith

2023-09

Super friendly staff!! Great local place. We stopped in to pick up beer and found a good selection from Islamorada beer company, plus some other Florida craft brews. We also picked up a smoked Wahoo fish dip that was incredible!

Scott Nelson

2024-01

Great Sub sandwiches and everything you need from a local supermarket. Very convenient

Aaron Hoffmann

2024-02

Super steaks. We've gotten ribeyes and NY strips. Best in the Keys.

Raul Gonzalez

2023-05

Best subs in the KeysCustom cut meat fresh on the spot. My go to spot when inTavernier. The store has a great variety of items not normally found in markets. Very down to earth staff. Must go

Ricardo Robledo

2022-05

Gary makes the best subs ever! No kidding. Awesome guy. Great quality. Super fun to talk to. Michelle is also awesome. Thank you again for everything. If you need to grab something to eat this is the place!

Joseph S Jaworski

2019-05

The best cuts of meat you will find in the Keys. A great little shop that has things you can find, and if you need something just ask and they will get it for you. They always have the best vine ripen tomato’s. They also have a very good wine selection. No frills just the way things used to be in your hometown market. Friendly staff and fair prices.

Edgar Moscoso

2020-05

Someone told me to try their subs, no regret! Best subs anywhere in South Flori! Staff is great, they treat you like they’ve known you for a long time. Great local small business. I heard same family has owned it for 40 years.

Marge Klein

2018-05

It's the friendly neighborhood market everyone remembers from childhood whether you grew up in Tavernier or not. The produce is local whenever possible. They have the best meat in town, organic and gluten free foods. The deli makes huge, scrumptious sandwiches and subs to order. A great place to get quality food for yourself, your out-of -town company and call in orders for your Super Bowl parties or a day on the boat.

michlusa

2022-05

Payfair is the skilled local butcher we turn to for everything from burger meat to giant roasts. They do some aging which is a wonderful service that's hard to find. They also provide expert advice with a smile. The rest of the grocery, while small, usually has what you need to complete your meal or a basic shopping trip. Check hours before going.

John Gregg

2023-09

Friendly service and the best sub sandwiches in the keys..Two thumbs up 👍👍

Salvador Borja

2023-08

The best place to find anything you want.I love payfair.One of my favorite stores in the Upper Keys. Come on and find out for yourselves.

Robin Yates

2022-05

Great deli, subs and beautiful meats. The butchers and the cashier are nice and very helpful. Very deceiving from the outside, chock full on the inside

Beau Bennett (THECLIP)

2020-05

I shop here 4-5 days per week because it's close to my house. But its a great little store with a great meat counter and deli sandwiches besides all the usual stuff. They don't have everything but what they have is good.

Jonathan Bettner

2018-05

Pretty much everything you need w/o the lines plus they have Boar's Head products and fresh dinner meats. Original fish dips available and a great ice cream selection. Just check dates on the bread products. = )

Maria Ward

2023-05

the sad part is that this could be the coolest specialty food store if the owners wanted it to be....however for now it's the best place to get steaks n quick items......

Alex Wolfe

2015-05

Their subs are excellent. They fresh cut any kind of boars head meat or cheese right there for you. Best subs in the upper keys.

David Turner

2022-05

This is a great little market. They have everything. Great deli. Great steaks. Massive wine selection. Produce . Great people.

Pol Consulting

2021-05

No frills convenient market and if you’re looking to find a place to shop local, none better! Great subs, meats and wine selection (a whole aisle dedicated to wine).

Kim Carter

2019-05

Hometown market. Neighborhood market. Old school. They have awesome wines. Fab subs in the deli and we will die if they ever close. Just go. Love them !

Jay Meltzer

2020-05

It's a supermarket from a different time, reminds me of Old Florida. But let me tell you, if you want a GREAT steak, this is the place to go.

Chris

2019-05

Great little old school market that's locally owned and operated. Locals spot that makes monster deli sandwiches and they have a little bit of everything. Do it.... Do it.

Cole Watson

2020-05

The BEST Submarine sandwiches in the hole keys.Excellent grocery store amazing meat and deli section.

judy bradley

2023-07

Not much to look at but best meat and sandwiches around!

Kurt David Gooch

2023-05

It reminds me of my old small town grocer in Indian Rocks Beach, Florida, high quality meats and delicatessen (Boars Head), with stardard convenient fare for odds and ends!!!

Deb S

2018-05

This store is very convenient to where I stay in Tavernier. The meat counter in the back has the best choice of fresh meats.

patti doll

2018-05

Great steaks. Very expensive but you won't find this quality of meat in any chain grocery store in this area.

Gail Feddern

2019-05

Nice little neighborhood store. Can't compete with supermarkets but they usually have beefsteak tomatoes, and a butcher.

Janet Ciccarelli

2022-05

Best subs in town! They carry stuff you can't find around here.