My-Way Seafood

lissa west

2024-01

Always very fresh seafood. Friendly service. They sell what they have available from the boat. Won't always have everything but will always have great quality.

Daryll Johansson

2024-03

Tasty seafood at a good price and you couldn’t find better people - one of the highlights of my vacation was getting seafood here and talking with the guys that run My-Way! I’ll be back!

Michelle Kramer

2024-04

We spent a week in florida and wanted to bring some fresh fish home. They hooked us up and we came home happy 😊

Corey Bumbaugh

2024-02

Highest quality seafood great prices and amazing people. I gladly drive an hour one direction to enjoy there products

Ken Tomlin

2023-09

Best Fresh seafood around, been going there for 20 years. 4 lbs shrimp , 26 dollars, n heads off free, no preservatives. Fresh shrimp. Christian ownership n operation. Great people . Grouper 10 dollars a pound fileted. Great seafood, fresh, great service. ABSOLUTELY THE BEST ANYWHERE AROUND. Check it out.

Jo Reese

2019-05

Great fresh seafood! Enjoyed our mouthwatering snapper & grouper so much, we didn't add anything to our fish tonight. We love stopping by to see what they have to offer. Jacob and PA were very helpful. We just learned to check their Facebook page to see the fresh catch available & when. Still fun to stop and be surprised.

Katherine Milla

2023-05

My Way has the best seafood on the Gulf Coast!! Everything is always fresh and they have a great variety. It's the only place I've found where you can get a whole grouper or snapper. And they fillet it perfectly!

Jim Rich

2024-02

Great red snapper! I was waited on promptly, efficiently, and politely. I am a returning customer as this is a great value! Love their fish! Thanks guys. Jim

Nmn Mnn

2024-04

The best place and price for fresh seafood in the area.

Peter Muhr

2023-07

Based on previous reviews and recommendations, stopped to get some oysters. 50 for 50. So so.... hardly any liquid inside .... disappointed

Judy Onheiser

2024-02

Always the freshest local seafood and at a good price.

Brandy Jackson

2023-05

These guys are amazing. We went July 4th week. Their fresh oysters were worth every penny and they saved us fish heads for fishing. Such a great little place for the freshest seafood ever.

Perry Henry

2019-05

As always My-Way seafood is a can't miss. Drove down with my mother while she is visiting to pick up Gulf Shrimp, Oysters, and Grouper.

Dee DeWitt

2022-05

Great guys with super fresh seafood! Bay Scallops fresh caught shrimp. Garlic, white wine, old bay, s&p, cream and parnesan. Wow!

Tammy Webb

2023-07

We just enjoyed the freshest Flounder and Shrimp from My Way Seafood for Memorial Day weekendIf you are picky about your Seafood like I am this is the place to get the bestHighly recommend My Way

Gabrielle Thomas

2023-05

if you want the FRESHEST, right off the boat seafood My Way is the only place in panacea with right off their own boats fresh seafood! customer service is always top notch along with their product! the only place i go to get my seafood in panacea! try them for yourself you’ll agree with me!

Hope Runseternal

2019-05

We camped near here for 9 days and had fish every night from My-Way. Coming from Illinois, it was a treat to get fresh fish every day! Very well priced and great quality. I'd highly recommend them and hope to come back down here for more! Keep up the great work!

John VM

2021-05

Great generational family owned seafood business! Excellent service, attention to every detail. Fresh caught or harvested daily from their own fleet. Cleaned, ready to eat or in your freezer! Pick out your choice, you will never go wrong here.

Honest Trumps

2023-05

Placed an order with Ike for some fresh oysters! He was kind and professional. Give them your business and you won’t be disappointed!

Aly Sacleux

2020-05

Best seafood market in the panhandle! I grew up about 25 minutes away from this little gem but never knew it existed until I saw it driving to Orlando. Their customer service is second to none. The owner and his employees are always very cordial and make great conversation while they’re cleaning your fish or weighing out your shrimp. If you let them know that you have a long drive they’ll give you extra ice! Side note: If you want to get seafood from them for the holidays it’s a good idea to reserve in advance.

LuAnn Karinen-Hebert

2022-05

They had run out of oysters in the shell, bought some oysters that were shelled in a container, they were from Cedar Key, FL. Had very few shrimp left. Bought some scallops, they were fine.Get there early if you want any variety of fresh seafood, I was there mid afternoon.

Michael Dolson

2023-05

This is the only place we get our seafood from. My family has been getting seafood from their since I was a baby. I would definitely recommend it if you are heading down to the beach.

Bonlynren McG

2021-05

Very sweet men. I am from Tallahassee but live in Birmingham and they made fun of me saying I'm an Alabamian now.But I won't hold that against them. 💕 Their prices were good and they have very fresh seafood. 🦀🦐🦑.

Ruthie Smith

2014-05

I can only say great things about My Way Seafood, for years I have been going there, I always get the freshest seafood and the oysters come from Apalachicola and that is the way I like it. The People who work there are so Professional and always so nice and willing to please. I go there year after year when I visit from North Carolina. I Highly Recommend My Way Seafood.

Bobbi Trick

2016-05

My husband and I were on vacation and thought some fish for dinner would be nice. After all we are here on the Gulf coast. It has been a very long time since we have had such fresh wonderful fish. Incredibly good!!! Prices were also very reasonable. Excellent!!

Phil Trick

2020-05

The seafood is always fresh. If you're lucky enough to get hogfish, it is truly wonderful. We tried the mullet on their recommendation. We were not familiar with mullet and we were amazed at how it tastes! Everytime we are in the area, we buy fish from them and are always very satisfied. You will see the whole fish, so you know exactly what you are buying; no mystery fillets here.

KriSSy Johnson

2021-05

Sign said open and so did google lights were on , but I waited about 10 or so mons walking around yelling and calling their phone to no avail , that's when I went down the road to another fresh seafood market and they were more than happy to grab me up just what I needed. I was really bummed bc I waited until our last night to cook shrimp and seafood and has wanted to try my way all week after passing by it multiple times. I will now keep my business with the other fellows that were at their shop and did serve me.

Brad Sandy

2020-05

I sometimes double check fresh produce and seafood purchases when I get home to see if I am getting played on as a tourist. I purchased a lb of large and a lb of jumbo shrimp in separate bags here. What I got was 15oz of the large shrimp and only 11.25oz of the jumbo. The shrimp was definitely fresh and the people there were friendly and helpful with their method for preparing the shrimp.

Trey Edwards

2023-05

One of the best seafood markets i have ever experienced . Great value, freshest seafood!, very friendly. I will go there every time I am in this area.

Teresa Coleman

2020-05

I have been coming here for a while, so I am posting my very first on line review because I bought scamp grouper yesterday, and it was amazing! This is not your typical fish market, this is the real deal! There is no "store" to speak of per se. Just a humble small cinder block building. You walk up to the porch and order, and they clean it for you and hand it over to you in quick time at a very reasonable price. They also visually present you your purchase before they clean it for your approval. They then ask if you have a cooler and pack your order up in ice if you don't.A few suggestions from a couple of years of experience coming here. There is a certain protocol...1. Ask what they have fresh today, they will tell you what is best to buy and why. These are some knowledgeable ( and very friendly) folks. I always take the suggestions and have never been dissatisfied.2. Be prepared to tell them how many people you are feeding. They always, ask,and prepare your order accordingly based on the size of the fish available that you are purchasing. They will then always tell you the price.3. They will ask how you want them to clean the fish. I have struggled with this as they have given me so many fresh fish choices, I just don't know how to answer some times. Tell them how you plan to cook the fish, and they will take care of the rest...If you are from a larger city with a typical fish market, this will seem new to you, but this fish market may be the best kept secret of panacea Florida! You can get fish at any fish market, but the expert advice here and the custom sizing of your order and cleaning of your order surpasses any of my previous fish market experiences.