Paradise Bagels

Leigh Ann Virzi

2024-04

Wow! Our first time here! Owner is fabulous and extremely helpful and has a wonderful sense of humor! Cute and quaint! If you have not tried it… you really need to! Excellent value!! Even added some fresh fruit!!Parking: Huge parking lot

THH Cleaning

2023-11

…More

Eric Dirauso

2024-01

…More

Cait Moore

2024-04

…More

Rose Deslyn

2024-01

The inside is super cute and cozy, staff was extremely kind to me and my baby and the owner was very informed about celiacs - she explained how they have separate toasters, butter and utensils to avoid cross-contamination. It’s rare for me to find somewhere that I feel safe eating from! This is an absolute gem. The GF cinnamon raisin bagel was super yummy!

Julia Kozodoy

2023-05

Such a great bagel! Owner was very nice and let us know what was most popular. We got the everything bagel with the delicious fresh ham, eggs, and cheese. Very good and love the laid back vibes.

Lisa Adinolfi

2023-05

This is the best bagel in Florida ! Coming from Brooklyn NY I can say that I haven’t had a better bagel in years .!!! The food is so fresh and the tomatoes are garden grown . They put extra love into the food they serve .

Patrick Wolfe

2024-04

…More

AngryGoat 6.0

2022-05

1st thing 1st this place was pretty dirty. The sitting area dirty and the bathroom was filthy. What I could see of the food prep area wasn't any better. But I continued to order. Ordered a couple of bagel sandwiches ( eggs ).Which brings me to the 2nd thing. I don't think the bagels are made onsite. If so I don't know where. The bagels didn't really taste like a bagel. They were more like just bread. 3rd thing is the eggs were probably microwaved. The texture was a little strange to me. I don't eat microwave eggs. I like real bagels which are crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Eggs which are cracked and made fresh.4th and because it's 4th does it make it any less important. The strawberries which were part of the meal had mold on it. Yes when I opened it up there was a moldy strawberry ( see pic ) !The two bagels and two drinks cost $24. I took a couple of bites and had to throw it all away.

Lisa Hubbard

2024-01

…More

Robert Bleckinger

2023-08

We love this place. People are great, food is good. They're so nice to our dog. Walked past there tonight (photo) and the dog was perplexed why a bagel place would be closed at 9pm. Promised her we'll go in the morning.

Pasquale Amato

2024-03

…More

Sarah Burdick-Ziebell

2023-10

High Quality Food every Time! I can Always count on Consistent Cleanliness also. If you have a Pet...don't Fret, because They are Pet Friendly!! (Make sure u ask wherever u go...do Not leave ur Pet in the Car even with AC running!)Absolutely Love sitting in the Sun while I enjoy my Coffee & fresh Eggs.😊

Ash W

2023-09

Mediocre, expensive, bagels. The coffee was undrinkable. The fruit they served us was brown and old. The employees were lazily sitting around at the tables when we walked in and didn’t show us a menu. Had no idea what to order. Very weird. Also, they are hateful, divisive anti - diversity people. If you’re not a white man, they don’t want you there. The crepe restaurant right next door was far superior in terms of quality and hospitality.

Linda Hoffman

2023-09

I came in and ordered pumpernickel bagels. I asked the price and also if there was a special price if you purchased a dozen.The owner who was working behind the counter replied:“We don’t have special pricing like other places. We’ve been in business for 29 years. Next year will be our 30th year.Same price if you buy 5 bagels, 5 dozen or 50 dozen. I’ve been here 29 years going on 30 next year!I took 3.I asked if they could please slice them. I was told by an employee they don’t slice bagels. The bagels did not look like pumpernickel nor taste like pumpernickel.More like rye!I paid and told employee I hope owner has a good day. She obviously is not a happy person. I WILL NOT BE BACK.Disappointed twice. No need to experience this a third time. I never post a rating…. But I couldn’t pass this up.

Mark Morrell

2019-05

Breakfast today at Paradise Bagels, delicious. Had the lox plate, onion bagel from NY, home grown tomatoes, with a smear. Staff so friendly and coffee was great. Definitely a return visit is in my future.

Leighanne Gray

2019-05

Came into this place because Peaches was too busy, and I’m really glad I did! My sister got the bagel, and I got the Island Club. The menu had it listed as a sandwich that doesn’t give you “lunch meat” and boy did they deliver. This sandwich was stacked HIGH with thick cuts of real turkey, honey ham, and bacon, as well as a HEARTY helping of tomato and lettuce. DEFINITELY worth the money! I somehow managed to eat the whole thing, and I’m not sure how? Probably because it was DELISH! The service was great, and the prices were great for such a large portion! If I find myself on Anna Maria I will be sure to stop in here for a bite! Thanks again!

AMBER CHAMBERS

2021-05

Fabulous!! Jackie the owner is a GEM!! Even personally gave me a ride back to hotel when UBER guy left me!! Love this place!! xoxo. We come every time we visit. Big Love from Michigan! Amber wRemax

Eric Tuck

2023-08

Very average bagel at a very fair price (for the beach). The shop prominently displays some controversial political views. That skews these reviews both ways. The "best bagel in Florida" guy is completely full of it and so are the over the top negative reviews.

Jenna Vanessa

2023-05

Really solid bagels and breakfast sandwiches. Staff was friendly. LOVED all the USA decor!

Justin Zaiontz

2019-05

PSA: “Parasite Cafe” is what they should call this place! I’m surprised the city has not shut them down. SHOCKED that they would serve donuts with that much mold on it and you can tell in the pic that the mold has been their awhile. I wouldn’t be writing this review if they had been genuinely surprised by it, but I can tell from their reaction that this has happened on multiple occasions.

Trenton Buell

2023-11

…More

Dock Master

2024-03

Great breakfast place on island. Fast service and nice spot to sit and relax

Frankie Alvarez

2023-07

$8 for a bagel is crazy! On top of that, the fruit they gave me was mushy and unappetizing:( better to spend your money elsewhere. Also if you are queer or brown, you're better off staying out of this trump supporter's store, as they clearly support people who are trying to erase our existence.

Brooke Clingerman

2023-09

Our favorite breakfast place near Anna Maria! Super nice people and we loved the sandwiches so much! Can't miss every time we are in our favorite vaca spot!!

Marina Mansour

2023-12

…More

Melissa

2023-05

I've been here a few times to grab a quick bite for breakfast. The staff is friendly and the breakfast food is delicious. I recommend getting a BLT or a bacon, egg and cheese on a bagel! Both are delicious.

Wendy Pohlmann

2023-05

Be aware - unless you call ahead you are limited on the number of bagels. I wanted 3 of one flavor and was informed I could only get 2. Bagels are really bready (if that is a word). They also have their love of the former orange guy displayed everywhere - went once - never again.

Evan Johnson

2023-05

Do you have a grandma who cooks great food while watching cable news? That's this place. Tasty, fast meals and good coffee, but if the Newsmax in the background and Trump/Tom Brady portrait in the dining room don't give you indigestion, the constant bickering between the owner (?) and her staff between customers might. Get your food to go, or eat on the patio.

Annie Kobus

2022-05

This place is absolutely fabulous! They have to have the best bagels anywhere in Florida. The owner and crew are very cordial and friendly. Wish I had found you guys sooner. But will certainly stop in again when I’m up your way. Thank you for really great food!! You guys are phenomenal!