Finders Keepers

4.4 (33)

141 Boston Post Rd UNIT 3, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

Claim this business

Antique store

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Christian Patrick

2023-05

This is what thrift stores should be a place where stuff is reused where prices are low enough so that the turn over is quick and mostly everything sells. Unlike goodwill where they charge as much as they can and end up just throwing out half the stuff that doesn’t sell or taking it to their outlet stores. Also the owner was really cool and glad to talk about his interesting overseas heritage.

Joe Birner

2023-05

Fun place with great prices! New stuff every time I stop bye. Owner is always kind, fair and honest. 5 stars!!

Ryan Collins

2021-05

My partner and I came here on a whim, and it was definitely one of the coolest spots we've been to in town. A total hidden gem. Super charming, the selection is cool as heck and eclectic, the prices are good, and the woman who owns/runs it is super warm and friendly.

Elizabeth Cook

2023-08

I was very happy with all the treasures I found today at Finders Keepers. Heidi is very friendly and helpful.Stop in and say hi 😊

Dan Ryan

2023-05

Friendly, helpful, lots of stuff! I found a tool there that I've been looking for for years, and it's in perfectly serviceable condition. I couldn't be happier!

Ducky

2023-05

Super fun and interesting finds! The guy working the counter was very nice and insightful. Definitely worth the trip!

Heather Rettberg

2022-05

Always something fun and unique at Finders Keepers. The owner Heidi is very welcoming. I love the great deals!

N8_the_ Carpenter

2023-05

Owner will list items they have for sale on Facebook market place without making that known and has terrible communication if you have interest in a item posted through Facebook market place, thus basically selling the item out from under you.

Cynthia Sigurdson

2023-05

Heidi is amazing and this is definitely the best place to find the most interesting things!

Jordan Shropshire

2018-05

I love going to this place. For a small building there sure is a lot packed in. You never know what you'll find. The owner is very friendly and helpful.

Lola Colette

2023-05

So many incredibly wonderful things! So glad I finally stopped in.

Patricia

2020-05

This little shop has lots of goodies. The thing gs people dont keep amazes me. I'm the lucky one I get all the treasures.

Sandy Thomas

2021-05

You need to update your hours/ days you're open on the website. We drove a bit to come to your store only to find out that you were closed. We got here 12:30.

John Randazzo

2023-07

A wide range of stuff, some good finds !

Anthony Ronca

2022-05

I hallway find bargaining. Friendly atmosphere no pressure to buy price are great. 😀

Cheryl Allevo

2019-05

Always a great selection of stuff! Well worth the visit!

Christian Rubenbauer

2020-05

Been doing business with Amy for years.. She's great.

Bruce Benvie

2018-05

Great stuff and always somthing new. Personable and downright nice.

3275362

2019-05

A small old shop with some antiques and some cool findings. Kinda pricey. No A.C.

Doug Johnson

2020-05

Half hearted effort. Not good hours of operation.

Kathy Sylvia

2021-05

The best

Christian Rubenbauer

2020-05

Heidi is the best.

Sue Breen

2020-05

Fun to browse!

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday Closed
Friday 10:15 AM-5 PM
Saturday 10:15 AM-5 PM
Sunday 10 AM-4 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet