Good Nature Market

3.3 (69)

44 Whitney Ave, New Haven, CT 06510
(203) 776-0400
theshopsatyale.com

Claim this business

Grocery store

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Highlights

  • Great produce

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Cassie Johnson

2024-04

Terrible service, woman in front is rude, guy making the sandwiches has a nasty attitude problem. Even sold me hard bread on my sandwich. For 10 dollars you would expect fresh bread

Phillips G

2023-12

Go there for lunch and some grocery items and fruit. Like the food prepared behind the counter. .variety of subs etcSome indoor and in summer outdoor seating.Can be crowded with High school students after 0ne o'clock.Also large open buffet in center of store. Large selection from soup to salads.Staff friendly but busy.On street parking tight. Think most patrons live or work in area.

JAY Era

2023-11

They charged me 20$ for a plate from the salad bar, not what was advertised (11.99) salad bar. Never again will I be doing business with good nature market.Don't waist your time or money there...

Steven Oldani

2023-05

The prices are absolutely murderous. Everything is marked up to 2, 3, or 4 times what it’s worth and mostly unlabelled. It’s like “if you have to ask, you can’t afford it.” The hot sandwiches are pretty good though, so 2 stars for that.

Jayden Poop

2023-12

Food prices are outrageous for insanely bland food. Nothing even healthy there u might as well go to edge of the woods it's way better

Apex

2022-05

5 stars for variety/hard to find items. 1 star for attention to detail, and friendly service. Seems like they hire people that don't really want or need a job based on the attitudes. When you are charging a premium for items, you would think they could afford better help. 2 times in a row, panini was made wrong, and/or provided a tiny amount of chicken for a $10 panini.To sum up: Come here for a rare chocolate bar or specialty drink, if you could care less about service or price. Don't come here for anything else.

Lady Di

2021-05

The food is good but I agree with everyone who complains about the staff and management. The women who work at the register are very rude and unfriendly, and the manager needs a course in interpersonal skills. The prices are outrageous and food items that are made on premise, do not provide a label of ingredients. I believe the scale at the registers are rigged, and I don’t understand why the customer has to ask for a receipt. During the covid pandemic, African Americans were denied service. Even though the food is good and they offer healthy food, I won’t be patronizing them anymore. I can go to Walmart and buy items for far less than you pay at this store. In my opinion they are over charging customers because it’s their belief that the bulk of their customers are Yale students and staff and they believe these people have money. Pure greed. Also, be careful with the spare ribs, I purchased them one time and they were still raw inside.

JSN

2022-05

About what you'd expect of a boujee market near Yale University. Despite insanely high prices on the hot food, it tastes pretty good. Prices for drinks, snacks and essential items here aren't horribly overpriced and from my experience with the staff, they've been very friendly. Would recommend if you and friends can't decide what to eat and want to get a variety of things.

CHI APAS

2023-05

When I walked in 2 days ago in the a.m you can see the disgust in her face before I can even ask for a pen 🖋️ and 📜 to write my number down for a family member who didn't have a phone , I ask was she ok due to the expression on her face an how was her morning. But Im written this to say humble yourself and put some respect on the aboriginal Americans,(Land Lords) that's food for thought , what I experienced I can imagine how many cooper color she has distain with. Peace an blissings

Aaron Askew

2020-05

Definitely 5 star food hands down. Open cuisine offers a variety of different food and all of it is delicious. The best brand name cold cut sandwiches- Boars Head. Ive only had one bad experience with "Gourmets"located on broadway next to the apple store. The original name is gourmets.. I asked for a buffalo chicken cold cut hardroll. After receiving my sandwich i went to my truck and realized it was a hot sandwich -i tried to return my sandwich untouched and they refused to give me my money back and only offer credit as a form of refunding. Fast forward long story short, a cop was involved to arbitrate because i was very upset how a business is friendly and polite when you handing over your hard earned money but act like its pulling teeth when they're wrong. I was refunded in the form of a credit to any other good nature market location but it was principle they made an error and wasnt willing to be accountable. I continue to go to good nature market as they are very clean. But my preference is the good nature market located on whitney ave by Chase Bank downtown.

Dorothy Post

2023-05

Second time in a month I've gotten sick eating there. Stay away from the buffet. I will be calling the health department.

Xiomari Caban Garcia

2023-05

Good service. Great hot bar buffet style food. Lots of variety from groceries, food, & snacks to choose from. Wether it’s dine in or to go.

Bijal Khunti

2021-05

They are open 24 hours but refused to let a group of black people in claiming they were closed. When they let white people in, the group tried again, gave them a hard time and called the cops on them. I’ll never spend my money here or their sister store on Whitney.

Kelly W.

2023-12

Not doing business here any longer.

Kozmo Flores

2020-05

Convenience for sure but that comes at a price. Yes the staff is nice and all. And most of all I needs when I loved nearby was available.

Janet

2020-05

Been Going to that Store for Years..Food Always Fresh made Daily, Sandwiches, Soups and an Array of Groceries..Great Customer Service too..

DOUGLAS D LEE

2021-05

I love sandwiches from this market.Fresh food nice serviceI will come next time!

Edwin Baez

2020-05

It was good, if it wasn't so expensive they would get 5 stars.

Latasha Townes

2023-11

Nice place first time visiting

William Ruiz

2022-05

Messed up my order. Instead they gave me a flavorless turkey sandwich.

John Correia

2020-05

Great place to shop with a diner. Great lunches. Very clean, well stocked

Sheila Hutchings

2020-05

I go here just about every day. They are a little overpriced but they have good food

kaitlynsonpointe

2023-05

Workers are rude and snobby and don’t listen to what you order for.

Jake Dressler

2023-05

Made me a really good vegan burrito

Dustin Hecker

2020-05

Good grilled spicy chicken sandwich. Good price.

Goldenpie Hk

2020-05

convenience and a lot of groceries to choose

Gerald Smith

2020-05

Good food

Capitán #1

2020-05

Nice.

Benjamin Atkin

2022-05

Nice selection

Prince Grover

2023-05

Overpriced stuff.

Opening Hours

Monday 6 AM-10 PM
Tuesday 6 AM-10 PM
Wednesday 6 AM-10 PM
Thursday 6 AM-10 PM
Friday 6 AM-10 PM
Saturday 7 AM-10 PM
Sunday 7 AM-10 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet