The Gnarly Toybox

Cassandra Reynolds

2024-03

These guys are so awesome! Really great customer care and a pleasure to do business with. The store is great! Very nostalgic, takes me back to my childhood for sure and lots of variety . Fair pricing when selling stuff there also! Really appreciate these guys! 5 stars without a doubt

O.マイケル

2024-04

The Gnarly ToyBox is superb! A must see for collectors of rare and hard to find nostalgic toys, figures, games and more. Pricing is awesome and it's always a pleasure to see what items are in stock. There is always something different to see every time I visit the store or watch the live auctions and claim sales online.

Sparks Nation

2023-12

Everything I see in this store brings me back to my childhood. I could spend hours in this store. A must see. I wish I could buy the whole store. Good people that donate to a great cause. And the prices are better than expected considering the awesome products.

Ry Nisogi

2024-01

This place is a retro toy utopia! If you haven’t been here check it out! They also offer competitive pricing if you want to sell your toys and collectibles and the owner and staff here are awesome.

robert street

2020-05

A hidden gem!I found this place by chance looking for something at the science supply store on sunday but they were closed.I saw this store and immediately noticed the skateboards in the windows. I went inside and was pleasantly surprised to see tons of toys from the 80's and 90's at unbelievable prices. Like 1 to 10 bucks an item. Old starwars, TMNT, He-Man, scooby do, Thunder cats, my pet monster! Dude that runs the place has everything and is super knowledgeable, and friendly af!He also carries old gaming machines. And has an impressive amount of arcade machines in the back.While I was there, parents were bringing in their kids, and their kids were having a blast going through the 1$ toy boxes. One random kid showed me his found treasure and told me "I don't know who this guy is! But I'm buying him!"They have just about any toy you can think of from your childhood for less then you can imagine, and some items that you don't see anywhere ranging from humorous too bizarre. Go there. Buy stuff. If I could buy it all I would. Lol

Kim H

2023-11

I shop online at home on the go which convenience is awesome it’s live stream though there fb. They show item more then once if needed. Owners are kindest people around and became my friends after shopping though them. I recommend them after my experience if you have problem ask to talk to owners because writing review doesn’t solve it because of staff. I think every thing is good about this place. They want to make it right even if I shop online or at there store.

Baking Gaming time

2023-11

This is an awesome store. I met the owners, Stacy and Branden. They are so nice they give you great deals on their items I follow their Facebook page and buy a whole bunch of things on their lives. I recently have bought a few Star Wars items and sold a few Star Wars items to them, and was given a great price. And they are awesome and I’m so glad to have them in my collection. I really recommend visiting their store.This is definitely my favorite collectible store

Theresa Burrows

2023-12

This place is just a treat. Toys from a few eras reside here, and it's just the storefront. They conduct online sessions to purchase that rare blast from the past. That Bama boy, absolutely friendly, knowledgeable and just a nice guy. Oh, and don't forget to play the old arcade games in the back.

rob lee

2023-11

I always have a great experience with The Gnarly Toy Box! The owners are two of the best people! They really love what they do and it shows! Make sure you tune in online auctions and claims 4 to 6 nights a week. I promise you won’t be disappointed!

Violet Ravotti

2023-05

Wow!! What a groovy and unique series of toys! Nostalgia and vintage galore! Wonderful place to walk down memory lane. The owner is super nice!

Manuel Torres

2023-11

If you are a collector or want to start up your own collection then this is the perfect place to be! I have bought so many items and they’re great! Great customer service and good quality items. Stacey and Brandon are great!

Sagrario Wang

2024-04

Looked cool, but went and it was closed. Disappointed even though online it said they were open. Sign says they close at 7ish. Went there at 5 pm and it was already closed.

Daniel Young

2024-03

This place is amazing. Literally has everything from my childhood and some stuff further back. Literally the only place I'm getting my collectibles from now on out.

Cassamdra Reynolds

2023-11

The woman that works the front every time I have ever come into this store has always been extremely rude! She almost always refuses to buy my.merchamdise and most times without even looking at it , and when i have sold to them she has literally given me pennies on the dollar. Store is nostalgic and cool but staff is absolutely rude . Would not shop or sell here again I recommend " out of the box toybox" staff is always courteous and friendly and they pay better to!

Adam Young

2024-04

The Gnarlyiest dudes in all of colorado. They got the coolest toys, comics,Video games, posters & everything Gnarly!

Nate A

2024-04

The most fun I've had in any store ever. My kids agree

michael moniodis

2023-11

I purchased an awesome vintage star wars piece and couldn't be happier. Pleasant transaction all around. And tons of fun to watch live auctions on FB. Thanks

Phillipe Rivera

2023-05

Super Nifty Nostalgia!!! This store has most of the toys to bring you back to your childhood. From Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles to the Simpsons, this store offers some serious collectables at reasonable prices.

Danny Galindo

2023-11

I love this place, I've been shopping online with Gnarly for about two years now, always been satisfied on how smooth the transaction goes, they are very professional and Awesome, highly recommend Gnarly Toybox

Grant Owen

2023-11

When I went into sell my toys I asked if she was still buying for the day and she said I will look at what you have so I proceeded to get the toys and as soon as I set the first toy down she said it smelled like cigarette smoke and we had just gotten the toys today and I had smoked outside. So we told her we would wipe then down and we were cleaning them in the car and she came out and said if we were just wiping them off she wouldn't expect them or the owners wouldn't pay us for the toys

Arvind Karwan

2023-05

Love this place! Great, always changing selection that seems always at and often much under Ebay sold prices. Every inch of this store is filled with nostalgia bombs. If you're ever in the area, do yourself a favor and check em out!

Janine Gagnon

2023-05

We live in Aurora but drive out to the Gnarly Toybox most weekends because you never know what treasures you’re going to find next! The store is always well organized and the staff are friendly and knowledgeable. The prices are very reasonable and affordable.

Steven Sandoval

2024-03

Great selection and prices! Guy working the desk was awesome!

Richard Blascow

2023-07

I purchased storage units at auctions and I found some really cool vintage toys. I brought them into The Gnarly Toy box to get some information on what I had as well as possibly sell them if we both agreed. The very short man with long greasy hair behind the counter was extremely rude and had a very disrespectful attitude about buying my merchandise. I do not recommend The Gnarly Toy, terrible customer service bgrefuture business

Victor Plasencia

2023-07

This place is amazing, a lot of great finds, and employees are awesome too, he helped me find what I was looking for and helped me find other things I overlooked. Lots of things to choose from and brought back a lot of childhood memories. Definitely the best Toy store I’ve ever found!

Joey Rodriguez

2023-11

I am out of state costumer , but feel as they are my local toy store ! They have great service ,great shipping . Brandon and Stacey and team do a great job 👏 !

Rodney Upton

2024-01

Don’t keep their word on shipping incredibly rude to me on their downfalls if you can’t keep true to your agreements don’t make them.

Simon Haslemere

2023-05

I brought in a collection of Star Wars figures, vehicles, and playsets to sell. Brandon was extremely friendly and happy to appraise. Very transparent about the method of appraisal and promptly provided a fair and honest estimate. Great experience all around.

the rigged gamer

2024-03

This is the spot for vintage toys and games. Great place to find what you're looking for

Jarred Burch

2023-05

Used to love coming here, selling old collectables and usually spending more than I would earn in selling items. But this new employee doesn't seem interested checking out anything anyone brings in. Atleast the old employee would look something up and see a value before turning you away. And I feel like I'm being followed around and watched the whole time I'm browsing, not feeling a great vibe in this store anymore