Mom's Apple Pie

Britney Bradley

2023-05

Definitely a place to visit for a good pie! They have other desserts too. If I would have had it my way we would have left with 5 different ones. But I will say the blueberry and blackberry we went with were both very delicious!!

GeralynK Rangel

2022-05

Busy, busy, busy! Thanksgiving week. Order ahead! There was a line, everything we drove past. They did have pumpkin & pecan pies available for purchase. There's a freezer full of vanilla icebreaker to purchase with your pie! Highly recommend!

Stephany Clopton

2024-01

I heard great things about the pies here. Wanted to give it a chance so I bought an apple, peach, chocolate and lemon meringue. However, the fruit tasted mushy/slimy, huge air bubble, the chocolate was okay. The lemon meringue tasted like egg with lemon jello instead of creamy tartness. The crust was undercooked and mushy. I will not be returning due to my dissatisfaction in the taste/quality of the pies. I Don't usually leave reviews but these pies are expensive.

Colman Pigott

2024-01

I noticed that Mom's Apple Pie was open on my way to the nearest grocery store to pick up a party platter. I was late, and I had little time to get things done. I got a pie and some cookies. They cut the pie and wrapped the cookies and offered forks and napkins at no charge. Boxed everything up and put everything in a nice shopping bag. I was now good to go. Thank you Mom's Apple Pie!

Tashina Hingston

2024-01

I have been going to Mom's Apple Pie since I was a kid. Best pies in the world I thought. I grew up in Sebastopol, but live in New Zealand. Bought my favorite last week; Banana cream. It was awful, tasted like banana pudding with some pieces of banana. The crust was also terrible. My friend also bought a strawberry rhubarb. The crust was also bad, and the pie was only half filled. So sorry to experience such a severe decline of quality. What a shame, this place has been a regular stop on my trips home. Not anymore. The price also went up fairly drastically. Shame

Wendy Miller

2023-05

My daughter spent $20 on an apple pie at the Sebastopol Apple Festival. Were told to protect the high crown as we walked around with it. When we got home and cut it, we realized why the warning. If the crown had broken we would have realized right away that it was nothing but an almost empty shell with just a tiny bit of an apple mixture spread in the bottom. We were furious at this rip off. Could have spent less and bought a far superior apple pie at The Nugget. What a scam! If we hadn’t traveled to go to the festival we would be at the shop demanding money back on Monday but at least I can save others the experience.

Nancy Hayssen

2021-05

Consistent good tasting pies! We've tried numerous pies over the years & love to support our local Mom's Apple Pies. Although I do love my own mom's apple pies best ;)

Hannah Rose Schonwald

2023-05

Mom’s apple pie is the best. We got apple pie, triple berry pie, and pumpkin pie. The pumpkin pie disappeared the fastest. They were all delicious.

G

2022-05

Oh yum! What a treat to have found this awesome little local pie bakery with organic options. So happy to have tried this today. They made my day. Their chocolate pie was awesome and fresh. I got 2 scoops of organic vanilla bean ice cream added to my order just for $1.50! Couldn’t be more content. 😀👏

Gloria S

2018-05

Nice quiet pie shop away from the crowds. Delicious pies! We got the apple crumb pie a la mode and absolutely loved it. Make sure you get a pie and cold cider to bring home! You'll be craving it in the days to come.

SY L

2021-05

The pie is not tasty as I image. For me, pie should has a crispy pie crust and creamy filling. However, their pie crust is way way too thin like the picture I provided ! I can’t even feel the existence of it. 2 slices of pie is around $10. Kinda overprice in my opinion.

Amanda Pyland (EastCoast2WestCoast)

2024-04

…More

patricia moore

2020-05

We purchased the Apple pie and the BlackBerry pie and had them with vanilla icecream. Mmmmm! There are a lot more pies to try. So far the BlackBerry is my favorite! But that can easily change.

Rahn Appraisals

2023-05

After my first time here, I made it a point to stop by every time I was in the area. The first two times, the pies were excellent. And then, today, this happened. I mean, look at that. It looks like somebody baked a really good strawberry rhubarb pie, barfed it back up again, and baked a fresh crust over it. I'm such a pie junkie I ate that piece anyway, and damn if it wasn't still delicious, both crust and filling. My family is so grossed out by it, they won't touch it. I'll probably have to eat the whole thing myself, but don't think I won't. Since this strawberry rhubarf makes one bad pie out of three, I'm still going back. But fool me once...

julia thompson

2021-05

Moms pie shop is a place I have been meaning to stop on my trips to visit my mother, nieces and my sister. So, tonight I went in and bought 3 small pies. Apple, Starwberry rhubarb and peach, as well as one large strawberrie rhubarb for my 2 older children and their grandparents. Also, im about to go scoop up some organic vanilla bean icecream. I am excited to try it. The pies were great, don't pass them up and wait for years like I did.

Alison Middleton

2023-11

…More

nick c

2023-09

$$$$ pricey, but excellent. Excellent apple pie. (Said twice on purpose). Btw, the hump in the middle is full of air, not pie filling.

Derek Brigham

2019-05

To die for pie. We had 3 different types of pies in 24 hours and they were all AMAZING. You are able to taste the true flavors as the pies are not overly sweetened; tastes home-made. Strawberry rhubarb was our favourite, followed closely by apple, then blackberry. Order them with ice cream! Thanks mom!

Tim Adams

2023-06

The first time in MomsApple pie, WOW that’s a lot for pie. It was great pie. Last time in the pie tin is an inch smaller and the price 25% higher, but it was great pie before. The pie I just bought was peach, it didn’t taste anything like peach, it had a sour metallic taste, unlike any fruit. Almost like a scorched pan. I took the pie back as inedible and was blown off. “I can do nothing for you” was the reply I got. Worst pie ever at the highest price ever

Andrea B

2023-09

Nothing beats Mom's Apple Pie.Unfortunately, I am also a big fan of their delicious Turnovers !They're even good the next day.Last visit, I was lucky to snag some right out of the oven.Yum Yum YumI'm a fan for life !

Steven Plourde

2023-05

Phenomenal selection of fantastic pies!! They sell lotsa pies in spite of their remote location in the middle of an apple orchard! Pie pans are deeper than mass-produced, commercial pies & have substantially more fruit filling - crust tasted like "scratch" crust!We bought frozen pies & cooking instructions were confusing - we figured out how to prepare both pies with an egg-wash on the crust & the whole family enjoyed them -Rhubarb pie had the right amount of tartness - Blueberry pie was wonderful!

Michael Meo

2023-07

Very mediocre pie and very expensive. We got two small pies, one cherry and one peach. The crust is underbaked and lacking flavor. We got a quart of ice cream and it was icy as if it had melted then been refrozen. We gotten an apple pie from Oliver’s as a replacement. It was much better and about 60% the price.

Lee

2023-06

What happened to Mom’s Apple Pie?Is there an imposter in the kitchen?When I got home I found the apple pie ‘crust’ to be more like a tasteless sugarless cookie. Not the flakey crust I was expecting. Under the 5” high top shell was air. And about 1.5” of apple mush at the bottom.Not a bad Gravenstein apple sauce but definitely not the excellent apple pieI thought I was purchasing ($30.00).

brian rhodes

2023-05

Used to be great place to eat. Loved the cooked to order fried chicken. They no longer serve that, just wimpy mundane sandwiches and over priced pies. I haven't eaten there or even considered it for years after they stopped making real food. There always seems to be a crowd on weekends, but there is no accounting for taste.

T Wall

2019-05

Super cute stop we found on accident. We ate lunch which was delicious but they are known for their fresh apple pies and other desserts. There is an orchard behind them that supplies fresh apples.

Tom Singerline

2023-10

Fresh, delicious seasonal pies that are truly out of this world. Ever had Strawberry pie...I mean fresh picked berries? ... Don't miss out!

Steve Jones

2022-05

I'm not a big pie guy but was recommended by a friend. Did not disappoint. What I liked most is that the apple pies are made from apples grown on the family farm. The apple pie was delicious but if that's not your thing they have a large variety of fruit and cream pies to choose from. However, no key lime pie. There is a small French cafe attached to the property if you're looking for other food. We didn't go there but it was very cute and I will go back to try it when I'm in the areaBest of all, this is a local family business. Mom started out years ago making one pie a day and has grown from there. They still sell their pies at the local farmers market and county Fair. If you're in the mood for pie, I think you'll like what you find

Jennifer Mackres

2023-05

My expressed bad experience mentioned below was met with an explanation from Mom’s that the issue with her pies was because they are vegan. She was very gracious to reimburse me for both pies.I was embarrassed to have brought such terrible pies to a Christmas dinner. The apple was tasteless and the crust dusgusting and the raspberry was runny. Each was $30+ . I will never order from this pie place again.

Blake Cowan

2023-05

Stopped by today and got 3 different pies, all of which were equally amazing. The thinner crust really brings out the flavor of the fresh fruit. Dont get me wrong, the crust is really good too. Best pie of my life and worth the trip if you’re anywhere nearby

Chris Esh

2021-05

This place is a huge ripoff. They make you think the pie is filled with apples to the top under the crust...but nope, it’s all air. Would NEVER go here again. See photo.