Ultimate Yogurt

4.5 (340)

1117 Myrtle Avenue, Eureka, CA 95501
(707) 443-9646

Claimed
Frozen yogurt shop
Cookie shop
Creperie

Service options

  • Delivery

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Saalav C

2023-06

YUM! Amazing yogurt, lots of flavors and sooo many toppings! Their crepes are Delicious as well. They offer a variety of food & drink options and have a party room for events. A great place to go with the family or all alone. Again...YUM! 😋

Michael Anderson

2024-04

It's hard to overstate the awesomeness of bringing your kid here and letting them pick their own toppings. For a kid that is picky it's great.Updated:Still great! An overall good experience.Update update:This place also has ice cream sandwiches.

HIPPIE

2024-04

I was actually at The Dollar Twenty-five Tree behind this place but I did eat there one time. It's actually a decent little place if You like Frozen Yogurt. They have like every topping You could want. You make it all Yourself and then they weigh it by the pound. Me and My Girl went in and each made it how we wanted it then went to pay for it. Let's just say we ended up only getting one because it was pretty expensive. Good but Expensive.

William Evans

2023-06

Kind of on the pricey side, (the yogurt and topings are sold by weight) but delicious! The staff is friendly as well. There are so many topings to choose from to put over like 10 varieties of frozen yogurt. My wife and I enjoyed it!

Jason Whitmill

2024-03

It was just a hit the spot,at the right time,kinda place a real hidden jem.go again and again it's bang for your buck must .Vegetarian options: It's just easy to read menusDietary restrictions: They can serve any of usParking: Easy to come and goKid-friendliness: Very kid friendly

Sarah Reid

2017-05

My daughter really likes this place because she can pick her own toppings and make piles off candy. Honestly though the product quality is mediocre and the yogurt often just tastes like sweet chemicals. It is way too expensive for what you get and is always a let down. I might take my daughter there once a year for the fun of it but would rather not especially since there are some much better options in the area.

Jennifer Bible

2023-08

They're frozen yogurt is absolutely delicious. They make crepes right in front of you and all around selection is outstanding. We go once a week as a family and will continue to go! Highly recommend!!

teresa javid

2024-04

…More

Justin Tidmarsh

2023-05

I recently visited Ultimate Yogurt in Eureka, CA with my kids and we had a wonderful experience! The flavors were absolutely delicious - we loved the Georgia Peach and Strawberry Banana. The shop was very clean and conveniently located. The staff provided great service and made our visit even better. Overall, I highly recommend Ultimate Yogurt for anyone looking for a tasty treat in Eureka.

crystal hickey

2023-10

The lady working the counter was very rude to my children and unfriendly. This place can get expensive so atleast hire people who are happy to help customers. Haven't been since covid and probably will never be back. Unfortunate because I have booked lots of birthdays here in the past.

Stephen Childs

2024-01

…More

Aayumi

2023-05

I absolutely love this place. One of my go-to places for icecream. The owner and employees there are always so kind, fun, and considerate. I love their rotating flavors and they always have options for people with diet restrictions. They also have such a wide variety of toppings to smother your yogurt with! ...And their cookies are made fresh and they are soooooo DELICIOUS!!!! HIGHLY recommend this lovely place.

Margaret Evans

2023-06

I love this place. Pick your bowl/cone, fill with as much of any frozen yogurts you want, and top with any number of toppings. It's sold by weight and they have lids you can take it to go with. They make crepes too. They sell pre-packaged containers too. It's fun to have "freedom of expression" in dessert! The flavors change all the time.

Natalie Witvoet

2023-05

They have good flavors most the time! I learned calling will save you a trip! I wish they always had chocolate sprinkles!

Karen Cendejas

2020-05

For my first time going eating frozen yogurt, I've got to say it was fantastic. The flavors were tasty! They have these weird ball things called poppers, no idea what they are but they looked like orbeez and I've always wanted to eat orbeez so I gave them a try and it was just soooo amazing! They like pop in your mouth and there's fright liquid inside. The person that worked when I went was really awesome too, he greeted us with a smile and just seemed overall friendly and happy to be working there. I was a bit confused on how the whole do it yourself thing worked but that's cause I'm a bit slow at times. It's actually really easy and cool because you get to customize your own dessert. 10/10 would recommend. 100/10 would get the poppers again! (Poppers are pretty addictive(not the drug kind of popper but the frozen yogurt popper))

andres valladares

2023-09

Good place to take the little ones to get some good yogurt.. you get to serve your on flavors and add the toppings you want.. large amount of different toppings... real nice and clean place..

Barbi Smith

2024-03

…More

greeley wright

2022-05

Nice Place. Took the the grand children there. Everyone had a wonderful time. the yogurt is good. the prices are good. But the cleanliness is absolutely amazing. They take a lot of pride in giving you a good experience. It is easy to forget that getting yogurt used to be self serve. I myself thought I was going to miss it.... but I do not 😁. Great job Ultimate Yogurt keep up the good work

Teresa Raphael

2024-04

…More

Daniel Hyde

2024-04

…More

I_could_use_sum_damfrenchfries

2023-05

The staff is friendly. They have cool, unique flavors of yogurt and so many topping options! You'll love this customizable fro-yo place!

Ismael G. Meraz

2020-05

Best Yogurts in the city. Really clean and nice inside. Great service.

CMT HUMBOLDT

2023-10

Friendly staff, nice treat, prices were much too high to encourage a return visit.

dora explorer

2023-05

The woman in here is really rude. My friend went in to use the bathroom and buy a red bull and the woman there literally yelled at her in front of everyone and told her to never come back. Also I went in one day while it was hot and she came to the counter and I simply asked if I could have some water and she looked at me like I was a freak? She made me feel super unwelcome and then asked if I was going to be a customer.Me and my friend both went here with the intention of getting something but before we even could we were made to feel really out of place and unwelcome. Do NOT come here if you have tattoos, piercings, dyed hair, etc…. Because this lady is gonna judge you and be really rude to you,,,,, just saying!

Jed mcC j

2024-03

…More

kevin bonstrangle

2023-05

Wow wow wow! This place is named correctly. It really is the ULTIMATE yogurt place. They have a a lot or yogurt options and an INSANE amount of toppings options. They sell yogurt and yogurt accesseries for heck's sake. It is absolutely splendid I tell you h'what

Elysia Christensen

2023-05

The staff is always super friendly while also busting out Door Dash and walk in orders. Always tidy and everything single thing is delicious!

AdventuresWest

2023-08

Pretty good FroYo shop. Crepes, smoothies and cookies available here as well. Reasonably priced.

Elsie Charles

2017-05

Place is very nice, service is lovely.But it's slightly pricy for not that good of froyo.

Jessica Heiden

2017-05

Very tasty flavors to choose from :)My favorites were alpine vanilla and no sugar added blueberry. The flavors rotate out periodically, and based on the previous flavors now in the to go case, I'm excited :)I love fruit toppings. There were strawberries, blackberries, kiwis, mangos, and cherries. It would be nice if they added more sweet toppings like raspberries, blueberries, and fresh pineapple. The kiwi and mango were too tart for me.The staff are always friendly.We try to go when there are deals to save money.

Opening Hours

Monday 12-9 PM
Tuesday 12-9 PM
Wednesday 12-9 PM
Thursday 12-9 PM
Friday 12-10 PM
Saturday 12-10 PM
Sunday 12-9 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet