Myrtle Avenue Market & Deli

Larry Higgins

2024-05

I decided to get a salami sandwich, which I haven't had in years. I expected to pay a ridiculous amount for it. But it was very reasonable, and it was delicious! Very happy.

Jesse hillbillytoker

2024-05

Avoid this place. Prices on items will be way different at the register and even if you show proof with a picture they refuse to honor the listed prices. Also check the dates, a lot of the items are out of date.

garrett sieloff

2024-03

Bought a case of beer. Upon returning home I found it was disgustingly moldy on the bottom and inside the box on the cans. Drove back and talked to the same cashier wanting to return it for sanitary reasons. He was annoyed and appeared inconvenienced. Couldn't find the same brand that wasn't moldy so i got a different kind. He found that clearly aggravating and made me pay cash for the difference... despite the fact that we live in the 21st century.One more thing. Their sandwich bread is always dry. Someone needed to say it.Should have just gone to Safeway. Won't be going back.

Brooks Call

2024-04

New ownership, won't give me a sale price posted and visible from the register. Probably won't come in here again.

Hum Spa

2024-04

This place has really gone downhill. Apparently they don't even have a restroom for employees. Avoid.

Bill Naylor

2024-02

This market has a great in-store butcher and deli.

Ali Mielke

2023-06

The people that work here have the worst customer service. Talking on their cell phones. Not honoring price tags. Barely responding to greetings or questions. Also, the avocado they sold us today was rotten. Won’t be returning. So sad because this location is so convenient.

Ms Faiai

2023-10

Quality of sandwiches just isn’t there anymore. Wish this Market wasn’t so over priced considering the neighborhood it’s located in.

burger time

2023-05

Should be zero stars , basically just charge you whatever they feel like, they advertise prices and then purposely overcharge you. Has happened multiple times, last time I took a picture of the price tag on the shelf and showed the guy at register and he's still tried to overcharge me. Never again

Jimmy Smith

2023-11

Pretty well stocked for as store that size. Somewhat spendy. No public restroom.

Ben Dimmick

2023-05

I wish I could give zero stars, this place is the worst to get meat. Ive got bacon there and twice its been rotten with black and bacteria all over and I brought it back and they tried to sey nothing was wrong with it And tried to convince me it was fine when the meat was obviously a dark almost blackish color where it should be dark meat and grey with orange on the white part. Wow what a disappointment in this place.

Sara Smith

2023-05

Under new ownership and is horrible. Prices on shelf say one price and when you try and get checked out; if the guy at the register can figure how to use it charges you a different price. New owners are horrible. Went in to get a sandwich from the deli only to be ignored by the staff while they talked on their phones.

Kim M

2023-05

New Owners: If you wish to stay in business you need to quit being rude to customers. The cashier is talking on his blue tooth every single time I come in. You would have been better off to keep the young staff that had great customer service skills. You could have learned from those kids. I quit shopping here.

Raylou Wisecup

2022-05

My mother came in to buy some hot dogs and stood there forever waiting to be seen while the man behind the counter ignored her. Then, more customers came in and he energetically greeted them and started to get their orders. My mother left without getting anything and we're not likely to return any time soon. If this is how they are going to treat people, I don't want any part of it.

Kimberly Shelton

2022-05

I love the sandwiches in this place so much! I haven’t lived in the area for a few years but I kid you not they are something that I think about every now and then. Honestly some of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had

the yetti

2019-05

We absolutely love Myrtle Ave market we go there every Saturday for sandwich Saturday. Everyone is beyond friendly.. it feels like family. You can tell Everyone loves their jobs. They know us by name, always make time to say hello. Humboldt's best kept secret .. but it shouldn't be a secret! We don't neglect dinner time either they grocery is very competively priced the meat selection is wonderful, always has fresh local breads and veggies .. see you guys next with my son's!Bill

J Abbott

2017-05

Perfect little, neighborhood market. Terrific deli sandwiches and a HUGE selection of beer, wine, soft drinks, and other goodies to accompany your sandwich.Also, *EPIC MEAT DEPARTMENT * with the best steaks I have seen in Eureka. (I don't go looking for 'meat departments very often, but when I get the hankerin' for the perfect rib-eye or NY Strip...I go here.Avoid the crowds, get a close parking spot, and enjoy the friendly staff!

Ann Mace Davis

2018-05

The deli has the best sandwichs around. They make them to your specifications. But they stack them high! Definitely not chintzy with the fillings. The market itself is clean and has friendly staff.

Landon Martin

2020-05

Went to buy a sandwich and a six pack and the clerk wouldn’t sell me the sixer! Told me my ID was fake! So I just got the sandwich, and it had brown and black avacado that I paid extra for... usually not a bad little market but idk if I’d go back after today.

Herb Mendoza

2020-05

Always the best sandwiches and perfect price for the size . 🦀 Crab sandwich is pure crab not crab salad. Definitely worth it. You will not be disappointed for sure

RICK KIMBERLING

2022-05

Ordered a Reuben sandwich, On marble rye with sauerkraut and mustard and thousand island. Got down the road and discovered it was on wheat ,no sauerkraut. Pastrami seem to be prepackaged type.Very sparse onions very sparse everything. Was very disappointed, Nothing likeprevious owners.

Who Onfirst

2019-05

Small, friendly, and great meats and deli. You won't find fresher hamburger or sausage anywhere in the county! Plus, try a crab sandwich.

Carolyne Schmidt

2023-09

Rude customer service. They tried to charge my entire card twice and argued with me about it when I confronted them

Jennifer Rodriguez

2016-05

The deli is awful. The sandwiches are rarely made to specifications. How hard is it to follow the check marks on the bags?! The dude who seems to run the deli is rude and he touches food with his bare hands after he's been on his cell phone and touching other items. I've purchased expired products as well.

Kolohe

2018-05

Good quality meat/deli!.. a bit of the high side (on prices).. the location is for ideal for the immediate area or commuter making a quick food stop on thier way home (if u like to take the back way old Arcata rd) into Eureka.. fantastic sandwiches and polite employees!!!

Davin Bowerman

2022-05

Jeremy in the deli put together 4 delish crab sandwiches, and whipped up one more without missing a beat when I got a last moment request from the office. 2021.12

Mikie Manalo

2018-05

Nifty little store. It has your basic esentials. Has a good deli, fruits, meats, vegetables. Can't remember seeing any seafood though. Plenty of drinks and snacks as well. Although, If you're looking for obscure ingredients, probably won't find any here. They also serve some meals made in store and some sandwiches.

Leann Spurlock

2018-05

Great meat counter. Their stuffed pork chops can't be beat. Grocery prices are a little high but this is a small neighborhood store.

Pat Stockel

2020-05

Excellent meat department, Alan will pick out a nice steak & pork chop, freshly cut. Courteous, friendly service from the checkers.

Patricia Bower

2020-05

I had the best crab sandwich in Eureka! Love their deli. You should check them out!