Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Fayetteville, AR

Dustin Brown

2024-02

…More

Debisree Ray

2021-05

The best part is their timing. You will find food here until midnight, when most of the places are closed. We stopped by for aquick late night dinner, and got a pizza. The sandwiches look delicious too, gotta taste them in future. The pizza was good, however a bit pricy I would say.

Alexis Brooks

2024-02

I have not yet tasted my food. I decided to get it to go due to an employee behind the counter. The woman who was wearing a hat tonight was extremely rude and making loud passive aggressive remarks to other employees while there were 10+ customers in line. It was clearly making everyone uncomfortable. The other 2 employees working tonight - 1 male and 1 woman with colored hair - (IM SORRY) you could tell we’re trying to make customers comfortable after her outbursts. Way more composed than I could have been! She then started being rude to customers. I understand everyone has off days but I never leave reviews and had to this time as her behavior was very concerning.

Katie M.

2018-05

I give it a 3.5 stars. Ordered a sandwich for delivery. Including food (no drink), tax, delivery, and tip paid close to $15. The sandwich was very good, however very small. A definite positive was the quality of food and even though delivery took quite a while, the food was all warm still. I really liked the fresh chocolate chip cookie. Overall I liked the food, however I still found it a bit pricey for how little you get.

Beth Cato

2022-05

An incredibly nice place for a Monday lunch. Nice staff, with food that's made fast. I really liked my cranberry walnut salad—very fresh ingredients. My husband loved his Italian beef sandwich. I am now more interested in visiting other locations in this regional chain.

Chris Ginnaven

2022-05

I stopped by Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe recently for a bite to eat while visiting family in the area. The staff were very welcoming and the soup and sandwich combo hit the spot. I had half of a veggie sandwich and a small tomato bisque. Both were excellent. Of course I got a pickle too!

Anthony Ferrante

2024-01

I want to apologize to the employee with orange hair that we so massively inconvenienced her at work by being customers. This employee proceeded to have the most poor and unprofessional demeanor you could ask for in an employee. This employee was cold, unapproachable, and completely uninterested in assisting us. Otherwise the food was fine and restaurant was clean. Truly frustrating to be treated so poorly for no reason.

William Wagner

2024-01

…More

Kelly Anderson

2022-05

EDIT: changed from 3 star to 5 star because Jed, the manager took complete care of me and graciously fed my 2 roommates and I for free and personally made sure that everything was perfect, and let me tell you, it was! He gave me 3 pizzas cooked perfectly, a buuunch of pickles and 2- 8oz soups to share. He went above and beyond to make sure i was happy, he even gave me his personal number! It was one of the best pizzas ive had. He had his most trusted delivery person bring the food and it came in a timely manner and assured my food was brought perfectly so of course i slid him a smooth 20. I will definitely be back and Jed deserves a raise!! He made a potentially tense conversation totally easy, he made me feel heard and he handled it with grace. Thank you JED! :::new pizza pics added:::I have been here a hundred times. And usually it’s pretty great/decent, i like the veggie sandwich, stocked up, and the cheddar broccoli soup 🤤Plus they deliver late! Buuuut, and this is not the first time, our pizza was super cold, scrunched almost in half, cheese displaced, the sauce ramekins had made dents in the solidified cheese in the middle of the pie and ranch was Allll over the sides. it was horrendous. They offered us credit which was nice but never once said sorry, it was like talking to a robot. This post isn’t to make people not come here but to tell the delivery people to be more careful with pizza and deliver it quicker. (We live right down the street on MLK so we must have been last on a multi order delivery) and womever is on the phone should have some heart and humanity when talking about a complaint... also there were no cutlery or napkins.

Ki Wi

2023-12

…More

Henry Denson, Jr.

2022-05

…More

Andrew Hensley

2024-04

Picklemans might be a top 3 PIZZA place in Fayetteville. Severely underrated. Would 100000% recommend. Always slaps.Vegetarian options: Imagine being vegan😭😭😭

B S

2023-11

…More

Debbie Bradberry

2023-05

Catered boxed lunches! Sandwiches were perfect, fresh, and packed so nicely in an easy carry out box (no multiple bags to worry about breaking or spillage). Best thing about this order, other than great food quality, was perfect timing (ready exactly at requested time), and the staff was super friendly. Much better than two other sandwich options used in the past. Will use Pickleman’s every time for future catering

Wisconsin Jane Doe

2023-07

I’m visiting from out of town, arrived late in the evening. I was delighted to see healthy food options for pick up or delivery at night. I ordered at 10:30 PM with a half hour confirmation for delivery. I called the store around 11:45 inquiring about the order. “Yo, check this out. My bad. But like hey they were really confused so yeah. Something about courtyard. But yeah I think I sent someone now. I mean I can call them. They couldn’t find you. Ha.” I understand things happen with systems and things of that nature. The customer service was subpar, I was talking to a college frat kid instead of an employee. I ended up ordering elsewhere when they attempted to give me cold food from 1.5 hrs ago. The menu looks lovely, I’m sure everything is fine during the day as the rest of the reviews are great. Just don’t order late at night.

Aaron Robinson

2023-11

…More

Noah Schroeder

2023-12

No bathroom after 12am? I am a paying customer and I have to piss like a camel, why can I not use the bathroom? Not everyone is a nuisance.

Kim Pope

2024-01

…More

Kegan Berry

2024-04

…More

Natalie Swatsenberg

2020-05

Great atmosphere. It's not just being located on Dickson Street, but the friendly staff as well. They have a variety of sandwiches at a decent price. I will definitely be a returning customer.

Jason Gittelman

2024-04

…More

Elizabeth pritchard

2019-05

The sandwich was delicious however I wish there was more of it. Definitely not as pictured on the website, our veggie sandwiches barely had any veggies on them for the price. Also I fixed your pickle poster for you, “Pickleman”

Peter Libby

2020-05

Pickelmans doing it right. Human tested. Dog approved. Great food and delivery service every single time. I love this #fayetteville hotspot on Dickson.

Lake Ashley

2023-05

After three visits to this restaurant over the winter, we are not returning. We ordered two sandwiches when they were NOT busy - literally didn’t have a customer inside. Upon arriving to get our food, the workers lazily served us while they continued their conversation with each other. Got our food and went back to the car to find they missed half of the ingredients on a veggie sandwich AND an Asiago chicken salad sandwich. This same scenario has happened all three times we have gone. Mediocre food, bad service, and way overpriced (a stick of bread for $4? Get outta here).

NotBlue3

2024-02

…More

No poison please

2023-05

…More

Randy Baker

2021-05

This is not the bacon sandwich that was pictured on line, but it is the one they sold me. As you can see, there is no thick cut bacon as advertised, barely any "bacon" at all. Very disappointed.

Will Coones

2023-05

Food is always great, but I suggest not ordering delivery. It can take in upwards of 90 minutes to be delivered (within the downtown area, even). This has happened a few times and not on game nights but on normal business evenings.

Matthew Warren

2022-05

1st time coming here and my turkey bacon was perfect for lunch size especially.That said, I think my only complaint is that I came for dinner and the larger size sub was a bit on the smaller/ thinner side.Considerably a petty complaint for it's value dollar for dollar, and an overall solid first experience. I will definitely return, but keep in mind when looking at the price and options.

Sean O'Bryan

2023-07

…More