Pinetop Olive Oil

Randi Castle

2023-10

Amazing little store!! If you want a great selection of wines, cheeses, spreads, crackers, olives, olive oil, and just so much more- definitely stop in!! Samples are given, and the hospitality makes you never want to leave. Great vibes. Did I mention they have gift baskets?? Makes great gifts and definitely something off the beaten path. Support small business and do yourself a favor- stop in here! ❤️❤️❤️

Steve Slipek

2024-04

This is the place if you’re looking for quality olive oil. Not only do they make you feel welcome and are so friendly but they also have so much knowledge about their products. They also sell awesome cheese, beer and wines.

Michael DiNicola

2024-04

Great wine, olive oil, & every thing needed for a charcuterie board! Veteran ran buisiness & very supportive with the local community. My wife and I frequent this buisiness often. We really like the owners. Easy 5 star rating.

Betty Shuster

2023-09

We experienced Pinetop Olive Oil today and it was incredible.The product selection is unbelievable and the owners are knowledgeable and very personable. We loved our time with them. We will definately return many times.Jeff and Betty

Cindy Armstrong

2023-05

We stopped in for the firsr time last week and were pleasantly surprised ! Kim was so friendly and helpful! What a nice surprise! We'll definitely be back! We bought a variety of yummy things....the blueberry pecan bourbon spread is delicious!

Roger Shumway

2023-08

Love the owners, they are super friendly and helpful. Loved tasting the different oils they have. Top notch quality and a huge selection.

Kellen Feeney

2023-05

The staff provided excellent service and provided us with delicious samples. The owners had some great recipe suggestions, I used an olive oil and balsamic vinegar to marinade steaks and it was delicious!If you live in the Phoenix area, keep an eye out for them at the Gilbert Farmers Market.

Rachael Mann

2020-05

Great products for home or gift giving and lots of great ideas for hosting parties.

Darcie Mansfield

2023-06

Dave and his family are some of the greatest most decent folks on the mountain Their products are top of the line I've Never ever been disappointed in anything I've purchased there I Highly recommend this place to everyone and there friends and family as well You won't be disappointed I promise.....

Michelle Butler

2023-07

This store is the best Olive Oil store I have every visited. The owners are hands on and knowledgeable! Highly recommend!

Jana Angle

2023-08

Delicious olive oil vinegars and wine. One taste and you will want to buy a bottle.

Frank thomas

2020-05

Beautiful store with an amazing, knowledgeable, and helpful young lady assisting us. Came in yesterday to just check out the store. Left with delicious olive oil and balsamic vinegar.If I had a business in Show Low I'd definitely try to hire this wonderful woman.

Dale Brayden

2018-05

The selection of flavored / infused olive oils is pretty impressive. The person running the store the day we were there was helpful, and patient as we tasted several oils. We ended up buying about 5 bottles of oil and a couple balsamics. On the downside, the olive oil itself is not great. The infusions are interesting, possibly useful for some applications, but the oil was at the low quality end of EVOO.

Mary Schroeder

2020-05

What's not to love about this store? Huge selection of balsamics and olive oils. Plenty of bread for tasting the vast array of products. And the staff are friendly and very get in suggesting pairings/combinations for the oils and balsamics. I have purchased many of their products. My favorites are the Meyer Lemon olive oil, the basil olive oil, the rosemary olive oil, the mango balsamic, the blueberry balsamic, the white lemon balsamic, and the tradit 18 year balsamic. They also carry a line of pastas and condiments.

Tory Smith

2019-05

Do yourself a favor and stop here! They have the most delicious flavors of olive oil, avocado oil and white and dark balsamic vinegars. Every flavor is available to try. The blood orange evoo and white lemon balsamic vinegar are a staple in our house. They are fantastic on salad.This trip we also picked up a garlic avocado oil to try when we saute!

Russ Means

2018-05

Great treasure in Pinetop. We stumbled across the shop be accident but glad we did. Great selection of olive oil and balsamic vinegars with interesting infusions. Balsamics are nice and thick. They ship too!

Susan Anderson

2019-05

Fabulous, as always. Loved the various olive oils, but tried the white balsamics today and am in love with those as well. Will be wonderful on salads,vegies, and even in sparkling water. Friendly,helpful, and efficient. Highly recommend.

Joel Aguilar

2021-05

Disappointed in this place, I made a special trip to restock and get some new bottles. Walked in and saw the sales associate with someone so I browsed the store several time and no one else in the store acknowledge nor offer any assistance. After 15 mins I decided to leave, hopefully I can find a place with better customer service.

Jen Holladay

2021-05

Great selection of olive oils and balsamic vinegars. Roasted garlic and mushrooms sage are a favorite. White balsamic and traditional balsamic vinegars in a variety of flavors. Homemade pastas and other treats.

Marty Young

2022-05

Best place in Arizona for different oils. Friendliest owners ever! Will always come here for different oils and seasonings! 10 stars!

J S

2017-05

Nice folks, just wish they were more hands on in helping me choose products. I love oils, and they have A TON to pick from! :) Very nce customer service. PLEASE carry more products from LOCAL merchants <3

Arthur Madrid

2019-05

We love this place great selection of balsamic and olive oil also the owners are really knowledgeable on how to use them

Scott Vartanian

2023-05

Absolutely phenomenal olive oil. The infused olive oil‘s taste as you would expect.

Judy Lauby

2022-05

Even with a power outage, tasted done wonderful oils and vinegars! Love coming to this store!!

Paul Wilson

2022-05

Great people who are very knowledgeable and have great recipes and ideas for their products.

Debbie D

2022-05

great service, lots of history, explanation, pairings and tasting!

Miguel Vega

2020-05

Exceptional Olive Oils and Balsamic Vinegars (among other top notch items)

jr lasater

2021-05

Thank you Sharon for the amazing experience and spending time with us as well as the amazing conversatio.

John Alan Fox

2023-06

Nice people. Good food.

Ona Jackson

2022-05

Wonderful owners very kind very friendly love this place